When Allegheny County Council took up the issue last week of whether to post the words “In God We Trust” on a wall in the county courthouse, leading the charge was Councilwoman Sue Means.
Ms. Means, 63, a Bethel Park Republican, lost her bid.
The day before the Tuesday vote, county Executive Rich Fitzgerald sent a message to council members urging them to vote no and threatening a veto if the bill passed.
No veto was necessary, as just six votes, including the one Ms. Means cast, supported placing the national motto on the wall of the Gold Room with a replication of the Bill of Rights.
Much of the meeting, though, was devoted to discussion of the issue Ms. Means raised. It was not the first time Ms. Means, a sitting council member for just 10 months, has driven a discussion at meetings of the 15-member council.
Councilwoman Amanda Green Hawkins, a Stanton Heights Democrat who did not vote for the “In God We Trust” proposal, said Ms. Means’ effectiveness as a councilwoman lies in the questions she asks.
“While I may not always agree with Sue Means, I am thankful that she is there, because she brings another perspective to the table, and she brings discussion to the table that may not occur but for her being there,” she said.
Ms. Means arrived on council in December, elected to fill the seat that longtime Republican councilman Vince Gastgeb vacated. She is a graduate of Bethel Park High School and West Virginia University, a former nurse and holder of a third-degree black belt, which she earned by breaking a board with her head, she said.
She’s the mother of five adult children, whom she home-schooled. It was in home-schooling issues that she cut her political teeth. She played a role in the passage of Pennsylvania’s home-schooling law in 1988, where her job was making sure every member of the Legislature received 10 letters and three visits about the issue, “poly-sci 101,” she said.
She also was a member of the Bethel Park Republican Committee and the Friends of South Park.
She made two unsuccessful bids for seats in the state House and Senate before turning her sights to the county seat, where she defeated a Republican opponent in the primary and then ran unopposed in the general election.
Ms. Means said she is for “limited government.” Her mantra is that government is too big, spends too much money and doesn’t have enough oversight, she said.
Ms. Means, a homemaker, estimates she spends about 40 hours a week working as a council member, a position that was designed to be part time. In committee meetings, she frequently poses numerous questions about the topic being discussed, she said.
“I want to understand everything. I don’t want to go upstairs and not understand what I’m voting for.”
Ms. Means, who took over leadership of the Republican caucus after Councilman Ed Kress, R-Shaler, was voted out in May, said she is realistic about what she can accomplish as a member of the minority in a Democratic-controlled legislative body.
“You’re checks and balances,” she said.
Since her swearing in, she has challenged legislative initiatives from Mr. Fitzgerald, whom she describes as “heavy-handed.” She unsuccessfully petitioned to have an outside attorney review a proposed lease involving drilling beneath Deer Lakes Park, and dissatisfied with meetings held about the plan, she called her own.
In December, she was one of four council members to vote against Mr. Fitzgerald’s capital budget. In February, Mr. Fitzgerald used his first veto to strike down two tax abatement programs for some homeowners that he said would be too costly.
Ms. Means, one of several council members who supported the legislation, said in an interview last week: “Before I arrived, Rich Fitzgerald never had a veto.” She led an override attempt of his veto that failed.
Mr. Fitzgerald said he does not see her as a challenge to his legislative goals. Instead, she’s part of a small bloc of council members that “band together to be disruptive,” he said.
“She’s probably the most vocal, because she really comes from that Tea Party, right-wing, anti-government philosophy of government,” he said.
Ms. Means said she would not describe herself as a member of the Tea Party group.
She said she is an evangelical Christian, and she does not shy from discussing her faith. Her office in the county courthouse, decorated with patriotic wall art, contains a painting of George Washington kneeling in prayer at Valley Forge.
“God is a key component of our American history,” she said. “The founders were men of great faith.”
Councilman Bill Robinson, a Hill District Democrat who often votes with the Republican minority and who voted for the “In God We Trust” proposal, said Ms. Means is playing the role of “agenda setter,” in that she’s requiring the Democratic majority to spend “inordinate amounts of time discussing issues that are important to her.”
Ms. Means “studies the issues well,” said Councilman Michael Finnerty, D-Scott.
He said, however, that “she has some controversial views,” and he said the “In God We Trust” proposal was an issue that was divisive.
Another colleague, Councilman Jim Ellenbogen, D-Banksville, voted against “In God We Trust,” and said he probably disagrees, more than agrees, with Ms. Means on issues.
He said Ms. Means “works very hard,” and he called her “very passionate.”
The “In God We Trust” issue, however, he saw as unnecessary.
“Basically, that’s how I see some of this stuff,” he said. “It’s unnecessary, and it creates controversy in areas that aren’t really necessary for part-time councilmen.”
As for the “In God We Trust” issue, Ms. Means said she is “making careful study of all my options.”



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.