Allegheny County Councilman Rich Fitzgerald edged county Controller Mark Patrick Flaherty Sunday to win the Democratic organization's backing in the primary that will choose the party's nominee for county executive.

State Rep. Chelsa Wagner won the three-person race for the party endorsement to succeed Mr. Flaherty as county controller while, in a startling collective rebuke, all four Pittsburgh City Council incumbents seeking re-election were rebuffed by the Democratic committee members, along with another sitting council member who is hoping to move on to a judicial seat.

Mr. Fitzgerald won by just five votes, 923 to 918, over the controller.

Mr. Flaherty, calling the result "a virtual tie," said he would remain a candidate in the May 17 primary to succeed incumbent Dan Onorato. Mr. Onorato, the Democrat's unsuccessful nominee for governor last year, chose not to seek a third term in the county's top job.

Advertise with us

Ms. Wagner. a Beechview Democrat, collected 755 votes to prevail over George Matta, a former clerk of courts, who had 672 votes, and Valerie McDonald Roberts, a county administrator, who collected 411 from the committee members, who are elected from each of the county's voting districts.

Controversy was injected into the previously low-key controller's contest last week as Ms. McDonald Roberts sent a letter to committee members reminding them that Mr. Matta had been the target of a civil suit while clerk of courts in which he was accused of having used a racial epithet to an employee. Mr. Matta, now a community relations official with The Rivers Casino, denied the accusation and the suit was later settled. He said that he would review Sunday's vote total before deciding to go on in the controller's race. Ms. McDonald Roberts could not immediately be reached for comment.

After a year in which city council had been enmeshed in rancorous disputes including the city's ongoing pension imbroglio, the committee members voted to oust all four incumbents seeking their support. The development was as a net plus for Mayor Luke Ravenstahl. While he did not make any public endorsements in the races, four of the defeated council members were chronic administration opponents challenged by candidates perceived to be running with administration support. But the losers also included Councilman Ricky Burgess, one of the administration's more dependable allies on council.

In council District 1, Vincent T. Pallus had 50 votes to easily defeat Council President Darlene Harris, with 25. A third candidate, Bobby Wilson, picked up just one vote.

In District 3, Councilman Bruce Kraus was defeated by Jeff Koch, a former member of council and a city employee. The vote was 38 to 22.

Advertise with us

In District 5, Corey O'Connor, the son of the late Mayor Bob O'Connor, easily defeated Chris Zurawsky, 63 to 25. Councilman Doug Shields, the incumbent there, chose not to seek re-election to council in favor of a bid for the region's district judge seat. Adding to the sweep of rejection for the sitting council members, Mr. Shields was defeated for the judicial seat endorsement by Hugh McGough, who outpolled him 65 to 37.

Councilman Patrick Dowd lost the contest for the District 7 endorsement to Anthony Ceoffee Jr., the son of a district judge. The vote was 53 to 32, with a little known third candidate, David Calfo, earning a single vote.

Community activist Phyllis Copeland-Mitchell, of Lincoln-Lemington, won a narrow victory over Councilman Ricky Burgess in Distinct 9, with 43 votes to the incumbent's 38.

Two spots on Common Pleas Court are being contested this year. The committee gave its support to Judge Mike Marmo, who had 1,287 votes and who is already sitting on the court by appointment, and Alex Bicket, with 937.