Jurors are poised to consider the charges against state Sen. Jane Orie after a day-long cross-examination in which she insisted anew that she never ordered her staff to perform political work on state time.
The defense and prosecution will offer their final arguments today in the case against Ms. Orie and her sister Janine Orie. Jane Orie faces charges including conspiracy and theft of services; Janine Orie faces two counts claiming that she helped direct the staff to aid in the campaign of another sister, state Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin.
After receiving instructions from Judge Jeffrey Manning, the seven men and five women are on track to begin deliberations this afternoon on a decision that could shatter or rehabilitate a once-stellar political career.
As she began more than six hours of fending off questions from prosecutor Lawrence Claus, Jane Orie acknowledged that thank-you notes for fundraisers were prepared and printed in her legislative office, and she conceded that she at times "got lazy" and used her state e-mail account to issue political directives to her staff. But the North Hills Republican maintained that she had always trusted her chief aide's assurance that political work by her staffers was performed on comp time or vacation days.
She said that her former chief of staff, Jamie Pavlot, a person she regarded "almost as a sister," was in day-to-day control of an office where, according to numerous witnesses, political work was done on state time. She also insisted that Ms. Pavlot had informed her of the complaints of some employees who balked at performing political chores.
Ms. Orie also disclosed that in 2008, she began to suspect that her office computers had been hacked. She said she called then-state Attorney General Tom Corbett, now the governor, for advice.
She said Mr. Corbett directed her to a forensic computer expert used by a mid-state district attorney to inspect her system, although it was not clear what the inspection might have uncovered.
Through the lengthy cross-examination, Jane Orie sparred with Mr. Claus in generally civil tones as she offered explanations for some of the incriminating evidence piled up through the prosecution case.
The charges against the senator span nearly a decade, but on Tuesday, as throughout the trial, much of it focused on the actions of the senator and her staffers in the days surrounding the November 2009 election in which Justice Melvin won a seat on the state Supreme Court. It was the Friday before that election that intern Jennifer Rioja resigned and complained to prosecutors that political work was being performed on state time in the senator's North Hills office.
One of Ms. Rioja's chief complaints involved another intern's role in preparing a letter to Catholic nuns. The letter lauded Justice Melvin's anti-abortion credentials in advocating her election. Ms. Pavlot had testified that she subsequently concocted a substitute letter that was never sent, but intended to deceive the second intern, Erika Frantz, that she had been mistaken in thinking that she had been working on political matters.
Jane Orie testified on Tuesday that in her view the problem with the letter was not its content but the fact that it was sent out on Justice Melvin's letterhead rather than on her own. While it stated in part, "Please, support Judge Melvin on Nov. 3 ... she is the candidate that shares your values," Ms. Orie said that if the message had gone out on her letterhead, rather than her sister's campaign letterhead, it would have been appropriate because she was the head of the Senate's Pro-Life Caucus.
"This is purely legislative, absolutely," she said of the substance of the letter.
She said that she had not ordered Ms. Pavlot to produce a phony substitute, but had angrily instructed the aide to "correct her mistake."
"I was upset; I was yelling at Jamie, 'You've compromised me as Pro-Life Caucus chair,' " Jane Orie said.
Mr. Claus pointed out that the original letters went out with poll cards advocating the judge's election. She said she never authorized those cards. She also dismissed testimony that when she learned that some of her sister's poll cards were still in an office waste basket, she took them out of the office to try to conceal them. She acknowledged that she may have taken them from the office but said that, "I didn't think anything of them."
By that time, she said, Ms. Pavlot told her that she had been informed that the intern's complaints were unsubstantiated. Mr. Claus pressed her on how she knew that. In one of his final exchanges, he tried to get her to admit that the information amounted to hearsay. The issue could prove important because some of the charges against the senator allege that she tampered with evidence, including the poll cards. The question of whether she believed that an investigation existed could prove crucial in determining whether the removal of the cards amounted to innocent house-keeping or an attempt to conceal evidence.
On another matter, Ms. Orie conceded that she did not have a ready explanation for an e-mail in which she told a staffer, after Ms. Rioja's complaint, that they needed to find a campaign office just a few days before the 2009 election. She said that her response was puzzling because she did in fact have a campaign office, another suite in the McKnight Road building that housed her Senate office.
Rejecting Mr. Claus' assertions, she said, "This was not an attempt to cover up."
Mr. Claus noted that in the e-mail exchange with Ms. Pavlot, she had instructed her to put signs and campaign materials in the office so they could "cover ourselves." She suggested that the phrase merely meant to cover the normal requirements of an office.
"I didn't mean it in that nefarious way that you're inferring," she told the prosecutor.
Jane Orie's attorney, William Costopoulos, had led her through an extended review of correspondence in which she had repeatedly admonished staff members to strictly avoid mixing politics with legislative activity.
At one point, Mr. Claus seemed to be voicing skepticism about the authenticity or timing of some of the written instructions to her staff.
In one of her sharper retorts, Ms. Orie said, "I don't know where you're going with this but I did not alter or change any of those documents."
Mr. Claus also led the defendant through a lengthy review of e-mails exchanged with a former staffer, Joe Smith, over the logistics for a 2005 fundraising event.
In one, she told Mr. Smith, "Joe, you are to be making [fundraising] calls all day today and tomorrow." She said that she assumed, based on her abundant instructions in the past, that Mr. Smith knew to use comp time for the work.
"I said, get out of the office, take the time and get it done," she said, explaining the directives. She acknowledged that the e-mails were sent on state accounts and said, "I get lazy ... rather than get on AOL. I was remiss."
James DePasquale, the attorney for Janine Orie, rested his case without calling his client to the stand.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.