A week from now Mark Patrick Flaherty's campaign will have ended a headlong sprint for the Democratic committee's endorsement for Allegheny County executive, in competition with Rich Fitzgerald to get their names atop the party's slate cards. The candidates have raced to political meetings from Brighton Heights to Moon to West Mifflin all in one night, and then repeated the cross-county trips the next night and the next. They have treated party officials like prized cattle -- massaged, fed, then coaxed into the voting booth.

At this point Terry Matuszak will start doing something more important -- going over piles of petition signatures to make sure his boss, Mr. Flaherty, actually gets on the May 17 ballot. Executive candidates need 500 only signatures, but the 42-year Grant Street veteran will get to work Sunday night making sure that the first 1,000 pass legal muster. The campaign will have collected many hundreds more just to have a cushion when the petitions are filed two days later on March 8.

"No ditto marks. Correct addresses. No blank spots," said the Flaherty campaign's political director. "I'll check the first 1,000 against the voter file to make sure there's no possibility of a challenge."

Every year, political campaigns from U.S. president down to school board member go through the process. During the primary season, the law allows almost anyone to run for their party's nomination but first they have to clear one hurdle -- they need enough registered voters from their party, who also live in their district, to petition the government to add them to the ballot.

Advertise with us

It is boring, time consuming and -- at this point in the fledgling election year -- absolutely essential.

"I look at it as an opportunity for the campaign. It forces campaigns to get out in the community, meet voters and do a test run for your organization," said Mike Mikus, the campaign manager for Mr. Fitzgerald. "The key, like anything, is to be prepared."

The rules are deceptively simple. A petition circulator passes around a sheet collecting signatures, printed names, addresses and dates. Both the circulator and the signer have to live in the district (that is, in Allegheny County for the executive race, or within the smaller district lines for a local government seat), and the circulator signs an affidavit at the end swearing he or she was present for the signatures.

Only blue or black ink can be used. A wife's and husband's signatures better look different. A circulator cannot fill in address information for a signer. Only real names -- no nicknames or city abbreviations -- can be used.

A circulator can't leave a petition on a Mount Washington bar and come back for it later, which almost sunk one South Hills candidate two years ago. That's a rule that goes back to a 2001 case when Mr. Flaherty's sister, Mary, was running for Commonwealth Court, and the state Supreme Court ruled a Flaherty petition passed around at a party was ineligible because the circulator wasn't present for every signature.

Advertise with us

There are also the rules residing outside the Purdon's Pennsylvania Statutes book. An experienced circulator might also carry extra reading glasses, clipboards and pens during the petition drives, which always start in February.

"Bring three pens, for when the first two freeze up," said Dan Ernsberger, a 25-year political vet whose wife, Barbara, is running for Commonwealth Court. "It's always cold. Every time, it's cold."

Weather aside, local Democrats still have a relatively easy time getting them. Not only do they outnumber Republicans, 2-to-1, in the county, but their calendar is filled with committee meetings this time of year with rooms packed full of the gold standard for signatures: local party members who are registered to vote. Democrats can host a breakfast for a few hundred committee people -- as they did Saturday at the Rivers Casino -- and get all the signatures they need in a single morning.

Membership in the GOP's county committee has swelled lately, but their candidates still have to try harder -- not only to find registered voters to sign, but in educating new circulators in the rules. Executive candidate Patti Weaver held a meeting Thursday night to give a refresher on petition drives to her volunteers, including some she met while leading the local tea party movement.

Chuck McCullough, another executive candidate, circulated petitions himself on Pitt's campus Thursday and, with the help of volunteers, will seek out registered Republicans with a computerized "street list" of voters. "It's a lot of legwork," he said. "But when you tell them you want to repeal the drink tax that's a popular thing with Pitt students," he joked.

Advertise with us

Fellow Republican D. Raja has hired former Pat Toomey campaign manager Mark Harris, who oversaw a petition drive among all 67 Pennsylvania counties last year in the U.S. Senate race. Signatures are not required from all counties in a statewide race, but the campaign got them anyway to test their organization, Mr. Harris said.

Getting signatures "is absolutely our number one priority -- 1A is petitioning and 1B is raising money. But if you're not on the ballot the amount of money you raise does not matter," he said last week.

The Raja campaign, like others, will use the petition drive to help build a voter database that is buttressed by the other aspects of retail-level campaigning, from door knocking to phone banks to direct mail. (Campaigns used to send mail to most everyone who signed their petitions, but rising postal rates has made that costly.)

The county GOP does not endorse candidates as the Democratic committee does, so their campaigns have more time to devote to petitioning, as opposed to wooing party officials. That's another way, Mr. Harris said, that Republicans can build the wide base they will need for an underdog win in November.

"Democrats are the machine party in a way the Republican party is not. That's a benefit to Republicans, to not be in that [endorsement] process, but reaching out and talking to new voters and folks in a way Democrats don't," he said.

Advertise with us

Just as campaigns put signatures into a computer database, their lawyers use databases to challenge petitions from rivals in hopes of keeping them off the ballot.

"In the old days it used to be a little more relaxed," said Flaherty campaign manager Sal Sirabella, who has worked decades in city, county and state politics. "The detail and exactness is checked more now than what it ever was before, because in the last 10 years there's been a wave of challenging petitions. It's resulted in many good candidates getting knocked off the ballot."

Better databases make it much easier to check addresses and party affiliations that it used to be. Also, as courts have moved to a strict constructionist model they are more willing to keep candidates off the ballot, said Pittsburgh attorney Clifford Levine, an expert in election law.

With some 1,000 local races on the ballot this spring, armies of lawyers will surely be poring over the petition signatures for weeks -- checking everything from ink color to nicknames -- before Common Pleas Court begins hearing challenges March 23. To ward them off, smart campaigns will file about three times the number of signatures that are required. Dumb ones will file close to the bare minimum.

"People have seen success and the ability to eliminate their competition in a primary," Mr. Levine said, of the growth in petition challenges. "Once you've seen that success, and if you see a relatively low number [of signatures], then you go ahead and challenge."