Attorneys in the trial of state Sen. Jane Orie clashed Thursday over a defense threat to seek testimony from District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr.
William Costopoulos, Ms. Orie's attorney, told Judge Jeffrey Manning that he wanted the prosecutors to stipulate, or acknowledge, that Mr. Zappala had not hired a professional fundraiser in his campaigns for district attorney. If they do not, he said, he planned to seek a subpoena for the district attorney's testimony.
The defense hopes to use that information to counter prosecution calculations of the value of the services Ms. Orie and her sister, Janine Orie, are charged with stealing from the public by using her Senate staff for campaign fundraising.
"We didn't have [district attorney] staffers doing fundraising ... that's a substantial difference," said prosecutor Lawrence Claus.
The exchange, after the jury had left the courtroom, was a sideshow at the end of a long day of testimony. But it carried echoes of the Orie family's very public pretrial characterization of the prosecution as a personal vendetta pursued by Mr. Zappala because of Jane Orie's scrutiny of gaming interests involving members of his family. Under a pretrial ruling, the defense is barred from raising that contention in court.
The issue arose at the end of a day in which the focus of the trial had shifted for a time to the counts against Janine Orie.
Jane Orie, the chief defendant, faces charges of using public resources for political ends over a period that stretches for nearly a decade. Janine Orie, formerly an aide to their sister, Justice Joan Orie Melvin, faces two counts, theft of services and conspiracy, based on the accusation that she helped direct the use of the senator's staff in Justice Melvin's 2009 campaign for the high court.
Under questioning from Mr. Claus, Joanne Crane-Tsucalas, a Philadelphia fundraising consultant in that race, identified a series of e-mail exchanges on the campaign between herself, Janine Orie, Jane Orie and other Orie associates. In one of them, Janine Orie told Ms. Crane-Tsucalas that Jamie Pavlot, Jane Orie's chief of staff, "will work with us to use her lists and make follow-up calls."
On cross-examination, however, James DePasquale, Janine Orie's attorney, led the consultant through a review of the e-mails in which she said repeatedly that none of those communications, which used private e-mail addresses, had any specific references to the use of Senate staffers or resources.
Before and after the consultant's appearance, the day's testimony, like most of the trial so far, was dominated by descriptions of the work of Jane Orie's staffers at her offices in the North Hills and Harrisburg.
Joseph Smith, a onetime senior aide to the senator, finished up a lengthy appearance on the stand in which he told the jury about his extensive work on fundraising and other political chores and his increasing concern about the propriety of that work. Mr. Smith described himself as a loyal ally of the senator and her family.
"It was a privilege [to work for her]," he said. But he also acknowledged that the 2005 conviction of Rep. Jeff Habay, a North Hills Republican, for using public resources in his campaigns, made him nervous about his potential criminal jeopardy.
"I believed I was doing similar activities," he said.
He left the staff to go to law school in 2006.
"Law school was a way for me to leave the staff on good terms," he said, suggesting that he was eager to maintain his ties to the family despite his reservations about political work.
Audrey Rasmussen was on the North Hills office staff from 2006 to 2009 and, like Mr. Smith, told the jurors that she came to have similar concerns, spurred by a parade of prosecutions in Harrisburg over the use of legislative employees in campaigning -- "seeing things in the news about Bonusgate and all the scandals that were going on."
She said she shared her concern with Ms. Pavlot and was relieved of political duties. She remained on the staff but said thereafter there was, "not a huge change, but I felt I was kind of on the outside."



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.