A defense attorney for state Sen. Jane Orie denounced the charges against her as "a low blow" Thursday as prosecutors began a methodical attempt to prove that the North Hills Republican had followed a nine-year pattern of using state resources for her own and her sister's political campaigns.

As Ms. Orie's long-anticipated trial opened, her defense attorney, William Costopoulos, derided the prosecution's case as petty and politically motivated. He spoke to the jury of seven men and five women after Lawrence Claus, the lead prosecutor, told them that Ms. Orie had exploited her state-paid staff to campaign and raise money for herself and for state Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin.

"These things were done on the taxpayers' dime," Mr. Claus said, noting that she had raised $1.8 million for a succession of elections between 2001 and 2009.

"The coffers of the public were used to fund her own campaign," he charged.

Advertise with us

Ms. Orie faces charges including theft of services and conspiracy based on accusations that she enlisted the work of state employees in a district office to assist in fundraising, door-knocking and other campaign activity. Another sister, Janine Orie, who had worked on the staff of Justice Melvin, faces two counts charging that she directed Sen. Orie's staffers to assist in the justice's 2009 high court campaign.

In his 35-minute opening statement, Mr. Costopoulos extolled Sen. Orie's political and family background, as a half-dozen members of the extended Orie clan were in the front rows of Judge Jeffrey Manning's courtroom.

In the court of public opinion, various members of the family have tried to portray this case as a political vendetta by District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr., who, they have argued, targeted Sen. Orie because of her opposition to gaming. The defense is legally barred from raising that claim in Judge Manning's courtroom, but Mr. Costopoulos alluded to partisan motivation as he pointed out that Sen. Orie had refused to accept a controversial legislative pay raise.

"She stepped on a lot of toes," he said. Closing his remarks, he added, "Politics is a dirty business, and for many, it is a contact sport. But this hit, ladies and gentleman, was below the belt."

He insisted that any political work performed by the district office employees was done voluntarily and on compensatory time accrued in doing their required legislative duties.

Advertise with us

Janine Orie's attorney, James DePasquale, underscored the comp time contention as he told the juror, "I represent someone who should not be here."

The opening statements were delayed by the need to pick two replacement jurors after members of the panel selected Tuesday, which has not been sequestered, reported that their objectivity had been tainted by hearing information about the case.

After the opening statements, Mr. Claus called his first witness, Michele Lantz, who had worked in the Orie district office from 2001 to 2003. Ms. Lantz testified that she had performed extensive political work during her normal hours, with responsibilities including maintenance of a fundraising data base and handling the planning and invitations for a fundraising reception for one of the senator's campaigns.

The case, which is expected to last for the better part of two weeks, resumes today with the defense opportunity to cross-examine the former employee.

After the trial recessed for the day, Judge Manning had one final bit of business, as he threatened the Post-Gazette and one of its photographers, John Heller, with a contempt of court ruling "for taking or attempting to take photographs while court was in session and in a clearly prohibited area of the courthouse."

Judge Manning scheduled a hearing on the issue for next week.