The evening of Feb. 22, 2007, Charles P. McCullough arrived at the Allegheny County Lincoln Day Dinner, a yearly gathering of Republican bigwigs, bearing gifts for four lucky political candidates.

The $10,000 checks were marked "Shirley H. Jordan, care of Charles P. McCullough," and made out to judicial candidate Cheryl Allen and County Council candidates Susan Caldwell, Jan Rea and Vince Gastgeb.

Doling out money from the trust of an Upper St. Clair widow, Mr. McCullough, who had recently decided to make a run for a council seat, instantly raised his profile.

Word of the donations made it back to former County Executive Jim Roddey, who did not attend the dinner.

Advertise with us

"I thought it was unusual," Mr. Roddey testified yesterday at a preliminary hearing in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, where Mr. McCullough is charged with misappropriating about $200,000 of Mrs. Jordan's money.

"Perhaps it was to make it more dramatic."

Mr. McCullough, who served as county solicitor under Mr. Roddey from 2002-04, stared at the former county executive from across Judge Donald E. Machen's courtroom yesterday. After three full days of testimony, the hearing was continued until April 29.

Mr. McCullough was arrested in February after a lengthy investigation by the district attorney's office, prompted by an April 2007 article in the Post-Gazette in which Mrs. Jordan, then 90, said she did not approve any political donations.

Prosecutors claim that Mr. McCullough, acting as power of attorney and trustee of a fortune worth nearly $15 million, siphoned money to himself, his family and politicians with whom he wanted to curry favor.

Advertise with us

Mr. McCullough won that council seat in 2007 and has said he will remain in his position despite the charges. His defense team contends that the 23 charges are unfounded because each payment -- from the campaign donations to Mr. McCullough's attorney's fees -- was approved by an Orphans' Court judge in a detailed accounting of Mrs. Jordan's affairs.

Mr. McCullough's sister, Kathleen, is also his co-defendant, charged with embezzling more than $1 million from a former employer.

Yesterday's testimony focused on the Fred J. and Shirley H. Jordan Foundation, which was formed but never funded in the wake of the scandal.

Mrs. Jordan's will stated that the foundation should be formed after her death, but Mr. McCullough pushed to start it in 2006, and his law firm, Eckert Seamans Cherin & Mellott, collected more than $36,000 in attorney's fees to do so.

Mr. Roddey, a member of the foundation board, said he was perturbed by the fact that nearly all the members were involved in Republican politics and that Mr. McCullough wanted to pay board members $1,000 per meeting. For a fund of that size, Mr. Roddey testified, the payments and size of the board were extraordinary.

Advertise with us

The board met once, Dec. 15, 2006, at the Eckert Seamans law offices, and discussed possible charities to support and drafted a mission statement, focusing on philanthropy to children.

In April, after the story broke, Mr. McCullough sent an e-mail in which he dissolved the board, accusing members of leaking information to Post-Gazette reporter Dennis B. Roddy.

By then, Mr. Roddey had already resigned his position because of his concern about the political donations.

The influence those checks carried is debatable. Under cross-examination from defense attorney Thomas J. Farrell, Mr. Roddey said he was unaware of any arrangements between Mr. McCullough and the politicians -- all of whom returned the donations after they were revealed in the news articles.

Correction/Clarification: (Published Apr. 23, 2009) Charles P. McCullough handed out political donations, allegedly from the trust of an Upper St. Clair widow, at the 2007 Lincoln Day Dinner. This story as originally published Apr. 22, 2009 about his preliminary hearing on charges that he misappropriated money from the woman contained an incorrect name for the dinner.