The attorney for accused Allegheny County Councilman Charles McCullough contends that his client settled many of the questions surrounding his handling of a widow's $14.5 million trust fund in Orphan's Court last year.
"We filed a line by line description of what happened with Mrs. [Shirley] Jordan's expenses back in August. The court confirmed the accounting, which means it accepted the accounting, and we thought that should have been the end of it," said Clifford Levine, Mr. McCullough's attorney.
Mr. McCullough, 53, of Upper St. Clair, was charged Thursday with 23 criminal counts, including theft, misapplication of property, criminal conspiracy and making false reports.
The Republican member of county council is accused of improperly making $40,000 in political donations, using money came from the trust fund of the 91-year-old Upper St. Clair woman.
"Many of the issues that have been charged here were addressed in Orphan's Court. We actually got to explain what was done," Mr. Levine said. He added that the court, which reviewed Mr. McCullough's dealings with the trust in May 2007 and August 2008, found no wrongdoing specifically because "we had a chance to address the issues."
"It's very frustrating for us right now because this grand jury presentment is very one-sided. And now there is this impression out there that [Mr. McCullough] tried to move all this money," said Mr. Levine.
But the county district attorney's office countered that the grand jury, in its review of the evidence presented against Mr. McCullough, found inconsistencies in his presentation to Orphan's Court.
"It's the grand jury saying that the [Orphan's Court] judge was in error. As part of their investigation, they can put in their presentment whatever they want to put in there. And it was their position that the Orphan's Court decision was based on information that was not accurate at the time," said Mike Manko, a spokesman for Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr.
Therefore, Mr. Manko added, John Eidemueller, guardian of the estate of Mrs. Jordan, will seek to have Orphan's Court reconsider its acceptance of Mr. McCullough's accounting.
Mr. Eidemueller could not be reached for comment yesterday.
Meanwhile, Mr. McCullough, a former county solicitor who was elected in 2007, has no plans to resign his at-large seat on County Council because of the charges he is facing, said Mr. Levine.
"He is going to stay because he has done nothing wrong," he said.
Mr. McCullough has sought to establish himself as a fiscal hawk on county finances since his first day on council.
So far, he has also consistently battled county Chief Executive Dan Onorato's administration over regulation and control of funding of county entities like the Port Authority and the Airport Authority. In addition, he is a vocal Onorato critic, specifically with regard to revenue from the much-debated drink tax and the county's use of state funds.
As a result of a lawsuit Mr. McCullough filed against the county, a Common Pleas Court judge last month ruled that the county must spend all excess revenue from the drink and car rental levies -- about $12 million in total -- only on the Port Authority.
A second lawsuit Mr. McCullough filed against the county, challenging the legality of a fund created three years ago to receive the county's estimated $80 million share of state slot machine revenue, is still pending.
"He is a voice for fiscal responsibility on council, I hope he doesn't resign," said Kevin Joyce, owner of The Carlton restaurant, Downtown, and a critic of the county's drink tax.
According to the county's home rule charter, a County Council member can be removed or forfeit office if County Council determines that he or she has been convicted of embezzlement of public monies, bribery, perjury or other infamous crime, among other things.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.