Rick Santorum's vote in Penn Hills will count, at least this time, but the former senator's standing as an elector in the community he still calls home could have changed once he left Congress.

Yesterday, after a 15-minute hearing, county election officials ruled against a Penn Hills Democratic committeeman who challenged absentee ballots cast by Mr. Santorum and his wife, Karen, on Nov. 4.

They said Ed Vecchio failed to make his case that the couple does not legally reside at a home they own on Stephens Lane.

"Our decision is that you didn't produce enough evidence here," elections director Mark Wolosik said.

Advertise with us

Whether a case could be made remains unclear, but one authority on election law said the law would appear to argue that the Santorums are no longer entitled to vote from that residence because they no longer use it as their home.

"The way the election code reads and case law reads, residence for purpose of voting, is the equivalent of domicile. It's the place to which you return," said Ralph J. Teti, a Philadelphia attorney who wrote a chapter on voter eligibility in a book on state election laws.

Individual states establish their own standards for voting eligibility and federal law adds an additional twist.

Under federal statute, anyone who leaves a state for federal service is permitted to retain a state address, a move that allows members of the military to vote by absentee ballot and federal employees, including elected officials, to maintain their residence.

Former Gov. Dick Thornburgh, for instance, had been away from Pittsburgh for several years while serving as attorney general during the Reagan and Bush administrations, but retained a legal residence at Gateway Center, which established his eligibility to run for Senate in 1991.

Advertise with us

In one of the more curious episodes of the 1988 presidential election, Democrats held a fundraiser in a Houston hotel room that then-Vice President George Bush listed as his Texas address.

Mr. Santorum left government service in January 2007, after losing re-election. He has moved his family to a home in Northern Virginia.

Mr. Vecchio, who works as a truck driver for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, and his wife, Erin, president of the Penn Hills school board and head of the Democratic Party there, have tangled with the Santorums on two other occasions. Mrs. Vecchio challenged the family's bill to the school district for a cyber charter school their children attended while being home schooled. In 2006, the Vecchios challenged Mr. Santorum's right to vote when he turned up at the polls in Penn Hills. A judge of elections permitted him to cast a ballot.

Yesterday, Mr. Vecchio said he was unsure if he will appeal Mr. Wolosik's ruling and insisted he was not engaged in a vendetta.

"He has a right to vote -- he has a right to vote where he lives, though," Mr. Vecchio said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Teti, the election law expert, said that establishing -- or in the case of Mr. Vecchio, disproving -- someone's residence is a fact-driven task.

"When these kinds of challenges come up, the fact finder or court or county board of elections look at a range of things from how much time you spend there to where do you receive mail, is your car registered from there, does the electric bill come there. Does anybody live there? Do you spend any amount of time there or do you just keep your shoes there?" he said.