It was a Sunday morning that should have fit the political bill for Melissa Hart: a slow news day with no distractions for local media, clear weather for the cameras and a red-meat endorsement from a Gold Star mom.
But as Ms. Hart stood in front of the American Legion in Springdale, a lone reporter took notes -- and not for the next day's paper. The only video camera was a home version brought for posterity.
"Thank you so much for defending our troops," said Debbie Lee, whose son was the first Navy SEAL to die in Iraq and who was flown in from Oregon for the Hart endorsement by Moving America Forward, a conservative pro-troop organization whose Web site also tracks anti-war activities under the heading "Sedition Report."
Two years ago, the very war the organization backs was the stuff of her defeat. As American casualties in Iraq climbed past 2,500, Ms. Hart's close association with the Bush administration and its war was to become her undoing, as well as that of Sen. Rick Santorum, a fellow member of Congress whose political career began on the same night in 1990.
On this day, Ms. Hart was unapologetic.
"A lot of people have chosen to make this war a political football," she told the sparse crowd outside the Legion hall. "I'm running against a guy who does that."
She meant Jason Altmire, the Democrat who unseated Ms. Hart two years ago -- and whom she hopes to extract from her old district before he grows roots. But so far, Mr. Altmire has no visible scars from his first term in Congress, and has built a sufficiently comfortable lead in the polls that he could beg off on a campaign debate that was to take place tonight.
By contrast, Ms. Hart, a woman accustomed to upending expectations, has had to battle a twin legacy of a Democratic registration edge in the 4th District and her ties to an unpopular president.
"Two years ago I think the voters didn't know a lot about me. In large part it was a referendum on Congresswoman Hart's job in office," Mr. Altmire said.
The Hart-Altmire rematch has lacked the urgent atmospherics of the matchup of two years ago. As one Hart adviser complained, "This race has no center of gravity."
Part of the dilemma is an economy that cannot be easily pinned to an incumbent with only two years in office. She has tried her best to tie Mr. Altmire to House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, sending out a tri-fold mailing that depicts the incumbent as a ventriloquist's dummy on Ms. Pelosi's lap.
"Jason Altmire has voted the way liberal Nancy Pelosi has told him to almost 90 percent of the time," the mailer declares.
Mr. Altmire, though, points to more than 200 votes that flew in the face of the House leadership, including two successive votes against a $700 billion economic rescue bill that found little enthusiasm in his district.
"He must have heard my interview last week," was Ms. Hart's response at the time.
In fact, both candidates heard from voters furious that the federal government was bailing out banks and investment houses as home foreclosures climbed.
"This time it's clear that the No. 1 issue is stabilizing our economy and actually this should favor me," said Ms. Hart.
But with both candidates claiming the populist turf on economics, the lack of a stark contrast has not helped the challenger. Polls have consistently put her behind by double digits, even as the Republican national ticket appears to make inroads, filling rallies and drawing the conservative Democrats who populate three of the border counties that are part of the district.
"Sen. McCain is going to run strong in this district," concedes Mr. Altmire. "We have a high senior population and a high veterans population, so that makes sense, but I don't think it's going to have an effect on this race."
What could have an effect, in fact, is a remark by a congressman from outside the 4th. John P. Murtha, a 17-term incumbent Democrat from the adjoining 12th District, made remarks this month about Western Pennsylvania being "a racist area" and, in a retraction, instead called it "redneck."
Whether the ire raised by that remark could spill over into the 4th has yet to be seen. At a rally in Beaver County last week, several Democrats in the audience cited the Murtha remark as the thing that brought them out to hear Republican vice presidential nominee Sarah Palin. Some spoke warmly of Mr. Altmire, who is among the more conservative members of his caucus, as a staunch foe both of legal abortion and gun control.
But a strong McCain showing in the 4th could help Ms. Hart, say her backers.
U.S. Rep. Tom Cole, who chairs the Republican National Congressional Committee, made an early stop on Ms. Hart's behalf, pledging "air cover" with a strong McCain showing and promising that, should she return to the House, she would resume her seat on the powerful Ways and Means Committee.
Two other high-profile figures have traveled to the district to raise money for Ms. Hart. Newt Gingrich, the one-time House speaker and architect of the 1994 GOP takeover of the House, swung through. A week later, Mitt Romney, widely viewed as the conservative alternative to Mr. McCain in this year's Republican primaries, held a series of roundtable talks on her behalf at the Duquesne Club.
"Melissa has spent her lifetime in regulating and guiding industries and guiding the economy and her posture on issues of the day is right; her opponent's is wrong," Mr. Romney said.
Even as those speakers tout her case, Ms. Hart has continued to lag in her bid for a comeback.
Mr. Altmire, who has easily outspent her in the contest, shows little sense of worry about his candidacy as the economy sours.
"The argument I make is that Melissa Hart was there for a lot of those decisions leading up to where we are now," he said.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.