At the groundbreaking for the new Pittsburgh hockey arena in August, announcer Paul Steigerwald positioned Gov. Ed Rendell, Allegheny County Executive Dan Onorato and Pittsburgh Mayor Luke Ravenstahl around Mario Lemieux as they gripped shovels shaped like hockey sticks. He directed Mr. Rendell to the Penguins' legendary center's left wing.

"There are no right wingers. We're all Democrats," Mr. Steigerwald said, getting a roar out of the crowd.

Except Tim Murphy, that is, who was seated in the front row at the politics-heavy event. As usual for the three-term congressman from Upper St. Clair, he was one of the few Republicans in a place swarming with Democrats.

The Democratic challenger Mr. Murphy faces in next month's 18th District election -- Monroeville's Steve O'Donnell -- is not well-known, and national analysts consider his seat safe for retention. But with polls pointing toward a tough year nationwide for Republican incumbents, there is a danger that the voters will be the ones with the shovels -- or pitchforks -- come Nov. 4.

Advertise with us

Mr. Murphy is taking that threat seriously. With far more in his campaign coffers than the retired entrepreneur he's running against, he is advertising heavily and hitting pocketbook issues relentlessly on the stump, telling voters he can reach across the aisle to get things done.

"I'm concerned all the time" about voter unrest, he said in an interview last week. "In Congress, we are nothing but temporary employees. But if you look at health care reforms, education, jobs and other issues, there is nobody else who can do what I do."

Where the incumbent projects concern about the Nov. 4 election, Mr. O'Donnell projects confidence.

"Tim Murphy is going to be one of the people worrying about where he is getting his health care on Nov. 5," he said.

Mr. O'Donnell, 62, was born in Homewood and moved to the South Hills, graduating from South Hills Catholic High School, now Seton-La Salle, in 1963. He joined the Navy upon graduation and was stationed at the U.S. Naval Hospital in Charleston, S.C. He later graduated from Duquesne University before earning a graduate degree in rehabilitation counseling from West Virginia University.

Advertise with us

He worked first at the State Correctional Institution Pittsburgh on the North Side, then for a series of social services and mental retardation agencies, mostly in Westmoreland County, for about 25 years. At age 50, he co-launched an investment firm called ROAM Investments Inc. before retiring three years ago to run unsuccessfully against Democrat Joe Markosek for the state House in 2006.

Asked why he's running, Mr. O'Donnell said, "Residents in the 18th Congressional District are very concerned. This economic collapse has driven up the cost of food, the cost of gasoline. It has taken away their ability to borrow, to send their kids to school. Thousands in our district have or are facing foreclosure ... and they are thoroughly disgusted with what's going on and very worried."

The other major issues facing the district are health care, education and energy, he said. To address health care costs, Mr. O'Donnell said he favored the universal health care legislation introduced by Michigan Democratic Rep. John Conyers. Like many other Democrats, Mr. O'Donnell favors quick withdrawal from Iraq.

He said Mr. Murphy "is a Republican who has voted consistently to spend $10 [billion] to $12 billion monthly in Iraq, which has taken these dollars out of the economy and has driven up the debt, which drives up interest rates and depresses the economy back home."

Mr. Murphy, 56, grew up in a family of 11 children in Cleveland. He attended Wheeling Jesuit College and Cleveland State University, then moved to Pittsburgh to get his doctorate in psychology at the University of Pittsburgh . He worked in private practice and at Mercy Hospital -- and appeared regularly as a child psychology expert on KDKA-TV -- before joining the state Senate in 1997.

Advertise with us

He entered Congress in 2003 after the Legislature redrew the boundaries of the former 20th District, placing then-incumbent Frank Mascara into the Johnstown-based 12th District of fellow Democrat John Murtha. In his last race in 2006, Mr. Murphy beat Democrat Chad Kluko by 16 percentage points, even though the district is registered 54 percent Democratic.

Mr. Murphy identifies the same major issues in the 18th District as his opponent, led by the economy. He voted twice against the $700 billion bailout pushed by President Bush, saying it would not create enough jobs.

"The only person assured of a job is the person at the mint, printing money," he said at a forum last week at the Coraopolis student loan accounting firm ECSI.

He placed the blame for the financial crisis at the feet of mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and banks that enabled the mortgage-backed securities frenzy.

"The problems have their roots a decade ago, when there was a push for banks to offer a lot of loans to people who simply could not afford them -- to people with no down payment, no credit, no jobs and no identification. I want to make sure everyone has the opportunity to have a home, but we have to make sure we're not stretching us to the place where we are now," he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Murphy has made the rising cost of energy a major part of his campaign, saying the country needs to invest more in clean coal plants, nuclear energy, and drilling offshore and in Alaska. Offshore drilling alone would generate more than $2.5 trillion in federal revenues, he said, which the government could plow into research into hybrid cars, public transit and other energy alternatives.

He would address health care costs by cutting waste, such as the money lost on duplicative record-keeping, the lack of follow-up doctor visits and hospital infection rates. On Iraq -- which the congressman has visited three times and where he was injured in a van accident in 2005 -- he said he favors withdrawal but not on a timetable that would embolden enemies.

The war is another thing that affects energy, he said.

"We spend 10 times [the war's cost] on foreign oil," he said, so investing in "energy independence is a part of that."

Some mud has been flung by both sides in the race. Mr. O'Donnell noted that a Washington advocacy group named CREW called Mr. Murphy one of the "most corrupt" members of Congress in 2008 after news reports said he used government staff for campaigning. Mr. Murphy fired a congressional staffer in 2006 after she complained to the Post-Gazette about doing such campaign work.

Advertise with us

Mr. Murphy has not been charged with any wrongdoing. When asked about the allegations, he said, "Those are old issues from a partisan Web site. They've been addressed before."

The Murphy campaign points to questions about Mr. O'Donnell's record -- which also came up during the Democratic primary -- regarding Life Service Systems, a Greensburg social services agency that went bankrupt in 1997. The nonprofit agency, partially funded with tax money, was accused of renting and purchasing real estate from a for-profit firm that Mr. O'Donnell also ran.

Mr. Murphy tied that to complaints about the Wall Street bailout.

"One of the biggest issues facing America now is millionaires making money off taxpayers. I don't know if voters want that in this race," he said.

Mr. O'Donnell noted that he was cleared by U.S. Bankruptcy Court of any of the agency's financial problems and was named to the creditors' committee placed in charge of its finances.

Advertise with us

"When I took this agency over, I ran it well and I ran it ethically and honestly, and anything said to the contrary is an absolute and unquestionable lie," Mr. O'Donnell said. " Tim Murphy either should know better or does know better."

The 18th District covers parts of Allegheny, Beaver, Washington and Westmoreland counties and Pittsburgh's southern and eastern suburbs.

As of the last federal reporting period, Mr. Murphy's campaign had raised five times as much money as Mr. O'Donnell's -- $1.5 million to $349,000. The incumbent had spent $738,000 to the challenger's $246,000.

More than $200,000 of Mr. O'Donnell's funds came from money he loaned his own campaign. The Murphy camp's largest contributors were Allegheny Energy, Federated Investors and Blue Cross/Blue Shield, according to OpenSecrets.org.

In an election year in which polls -- such as one from the Washington Post last week -- say 90 percent of Americans think the country is on the wrong track, it could be a bad time to be an incumbent. Fellow Republican Phil English, of Erie, was down 7 points to his Democratic challenger in a poll released Thursday.

Advertise with us

Yet the nonpartisan Cook Political Report has judged the 18th District race to be a "solid" Republican win.

It is no wonder, then, that Mr. Murphy is emphasizing issues usually reserved for Democrats, his opponent claimed, even though he voted with the Republican majority 85 percent of the time, according to a Washington Post study.

"At this point in time, absolutely no question the collapsing economy is the biggest issue that worries people. That I think is a function of this failed administration," said Mr. O'Donnell. "What I think you see with Tim Murphy is someone who's trying to run away from being a Republican, let alone from being a Republican who voted with Bush so often."