It was a topsy-turvy night in local school board races.
Two incumbents in the Mt. Lebanon School District fell to defeat in unofficial returns. In McKeesport and Penn Hills, school board presidents lost their seats. The same fate befell an eight-year incumbent in the Woodland Hills School District.
In Upper St. Clair, a last-minute write-in campaign by three unsuccessful primary candidates appears to have failed. In Hampton, an 18-year-old college student learned some political science the hard way, losing in her first bid for a public seat.
North Allegheny
The power of incumbency trumped ballot position in the North Allegheny School District, where Scott Cunningham defeated Carole Shepard.
With nearly all of the vote tallied, Mr. Cunningham, a Republican from Marshall, built an insurmountable lead over Mrs. Shepard, a Democrat from McCandless. As expected, the two candidates were vying for the last of five available seats with the other four cross-nominated incumbents easily winning re-election.
In somewhat of a surprise, Alan Shuckrow of McCandless emerged as the apparent top vote-getter over Beth Ann Ludwig of McCandless, who had gotten the most overall votes in the May primary. Not far behind those two were Karen Boujoukos and Maureen Grosheider, both of Marshall.
While Mr. Cunningham lagged well behind the other incumbents, he easily outdistanced Mrs. Shepard, whom he credited with waging a spirited, grassroots campaign. Mrs. Shepard had gained a tactical edge when she was given the No. 1 ballot position. Mr. Cunningham, meanwhile, appeared last on the ballot.
All five GOP incumbents had run as a team, although Mr. Cunningham had stepped up his campaign on his own after the primary when he, unlike the other board members seeking re-election, failed to win nomination from both parties.
North Hills
Two newcomers and three incumbents appear to have won election to the North Hills school board.
Incumbents Arlene Bender, Jeff Meyer and Ed Wielgus won re-election, and will be joined by newcomers Robert Barto and Lou Nudi on the nine-member board.
All but Mr. Wielgus had won both the Republican and Democratic nominations, which almost guaranteed election last night.
Mr. Wielgus, who won nomination only as a Republican, appeared to be the winner in a close race against Tara Howey, who had received only the Democratic nomination, for the fifth open seat.
Hampton
Hampton voters stuck with what they knew for their school board choices that ended up being a Republican sweep.
Robert J. Shages, Alma A. Kolkman, Mary Alice Hennessey, Larry J. Vasko and Pam Lamagna all won seats on the board, according to preliminary results.
Mr. Shages, who also served the last three years as school board president, felt the voters were sending a clear message by electing himself and another incumbent Mr. Vasko.
Ms. Kolkman had served on the board before and is returning after a 16-year absence. She believes voters recalled her accomplishments from the last time she served.
Tiffany Tupper, an 18-year-old Chatham University student who lost in her first run for elected position, expressed disappointment in her defeat.
Mt. Lebanon
It appears that longtime Mt. Lebanon school director Carol Walton, 64, lost her bid for a sixth term last night, as did incumbent Rene Garson, 49, who was running for a second term.
With nearly 100 percent of the vote in, newcomer Elaine Cappucci, 46, an environmental engineer, was the top vote-getter in the race for five open seats on the board.
Next in the vote totals was Faith Ann Stipanovich, 47, a payroll manager for the Allegheny County controller's office, who also is running for her first term, followed by incumbent Susan Rose, 46, a community volunteer.
Also winning seats were running mates Ed Kubit, 37, a district manager for Cadre Computer Resources, and James Fraasch, 34, a network architect for PNC Bank.
Woodland Hills
Regis Driscoll defeated eight-year incumbent Linda Cole and former Forest Hills council President Mike Belmonte in an extremely tight race for the Woodland Hills school board Region 8 seat. The race between 20-year incumbent Marilyn Messina and Joanne Peterson for the Region 4 seat went to Ms. Messina.
Voters cast ballots with several issues in mind, but the looming decision, whether or not to close East Junior High School in Turtle Creek, was one of the most prominent. An ad-hoc committee of school board members concluded in October that one building would best suit the needs of the district's 800 middle school students, and many believe East Junior High School in Turtle Creek would be the most logical choice because it is an older building. The board expects to make a final decision about the school closings at its meeting Nov. 14.
Upper St. Clair
In Upper St. Clair, what appeared to be an uncontested school board race for five seats changed drastically a week ago when three candidates who failed to win general election slots from the primary announced they would run a write-in campaign.
Patricia Donlon, Bob Walker and Ernie Harris blitzed the township with 6,000 fliers and 6,000 automated phone calls in the past few days in hopes of upending the five candidates who are running together as the Restore group.
Nonetheless, incumbents Angela Petersen and Barbara Bolas, plus Rebecca Stern, Louis Piconi and Amy Billerbeck appear to have won seats from three write-in candidates.
"We do believe the other side won," Mrs. Donlon said. "I do think, though, that we made an impact and in the end, it was important for us to give the people a choice and to make a statement."
Due to the additional work of confirming write-in votes, it might be days, possibly weeks, until a final total is reached, an Allegheny County elections spokeswoman said.
In the primary, the Restore party swept both sides of the ticket. Almost 50 percent of the township's eligible voters turned out in what has become an emotional school board race, sparked in part by the current board's debate over keeping the district's International Baccalaureate program.
McKeesport
In a contentious McKeesport school board election, incumbent President Ocie Paige was ousted while all four candidates who were targeted in a recent lawsuit were elected to fill four of the five empty seats. Democrat Joe Chiaverini captured the fifth seat.
Jim Brown, Steven Kondrosky, Joe Lopretto, and Christopher Halaszynski, all city employees, won last night over Republicans Jerome Halaszynski and Mr. Paige.
Late last month, school board member Dave Donato filed a lawsuit to block the four city employees from running. A judge overturned the suit, allowing the employees to stay on the ballot.
West Mifflin
It appears the four incumbents running for school director in West Mifflin all won re-election and will be joined on the board by newcomer Albert Graham, 44, a chiropractor with a practice in Pleasant Hills.
Incumbent candidates who were re-elected are: Kathleen Bracco, 49, a pharmaceutical representative; Ned Mervos, 76, a retired teacher, administrator and coach in the West Mifflin Area School District; Richard Fialkovich, 73, a retired West Mifflin police detective; and Pat Natale, 78, a retiree from Mesta Machine Co. Ms. Bracco was the top vote-getter.
Losing their bids for one of the five open seats were: Theodore Cale, 47, a police and fire dispatcher for West Mifflin; Brett VanDyke, 32, a photographer; and Daniel Davis, 41, a senior project manager for Robert Kimball Associates.
Penn Hills
Penn Hills school board President Richard Vuocolo lost his seat, as voters elected five board members.
Two incumbents were re-elected: Margie Krogh to a fourth term and John Zacchia to a second term. Each of them won both the Democratic and Republican nominations in the primary. Also winning as a cross-filed candidate was Donald L. Kuhn Jr., a newcomer to the school board who is office manager of an auto body shop.
Also newly elected were Joseph Bailey, who had a previous tenure on the school board, and Catherine Mowry.
In addition to ousting Mr. Vuocolo, a registered Democrat who won the Republican nomination in the spring but not his own party's, voters rejected Robert Larko, who was chairman of the district's Act 1 study commission.
Plum
Five candidates nominated on the Democratic ticket in the spring, including Republican board President Jeff Matthews, won election to the board. The lone incumbent defeated was Republican Paul Olijar.
Elected along with Mr. Matthews were incumbents Tom McGough and Linda Eazor; Jeff Russo, a former Plum councilman who teamed with Mr. Matthews in the school board race; and Rose McGuirk, a former administrative assistant for the school district.
The others who failed to win election were Republican nominees Keith Nowalk, Anthony Shreve, Peter J. Bobich and Joseph Ambrose Jr.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.