Democrats increased their advantage in Allegheny County Council yesterday when voters replaced an incumbent Republican from Plum with a Verona Democrat.

The new makeup of council will be 11 Democrats to four Republicans, which gives the party one vote more than the two-thirds needed to impose taxes or set the budget.

The new member, Nick Futules, who owns a banquet facility in Harmar on the Westmoreland County line, opposes imposition of the alcoholic drink tax, which he said will hurt his business. Defeated incumbent Susan Caldwell, R-Plum, also opposed the tax pushed by Chief Executive Dan Onorato.

Allegheny County voters yesterday also ignored the publicity surrounding Chuck McCullough's bid for an at-large seat on council and overwhelmingly voted him in, along with incumbent at-large Democrat John DeFazio of Shaler.

Advertise with us

It was the end of an odd campaign for Mr. McCullough, an Upper St. Clair Republican, who bowed out of the primary too late to have his name taken off the ballot only to win the nomination by 6,000 votes.

Framers of the county Home Rule Charter intended to have a Republican and a Democrat in the county's two at-large seats. Voters of each party nominate one candidate in the primary. In the general election, voters choose one, but the two top vote-getters are elected.

This summer, after Mr. McCullough won the primary, David Tessitor of the North Side filed petitions to run for an at-large seat as a member of the Reform Party. He said he was concerned about reports regarding Mr. McCullough's handling of the trust for an elderly widow. Mr. McCullough had directed a bank to issue checks for campaign contributions to fellow Republicans as the trustee of an account for the Upper St. Clair widow. The funds were ultimately returned. The matter is being investigated by the Allegheny County district attorney's office.

Mr. Tessitor trailed badly in unofficial returns last night.

In the District 7 council race, Mr. Futules unseated Ms. Caldwell, who was appointed to fill a vacancy left by the resignation of Eileen Watt.

Advertise with us

"I came from one of the smallest districts in Allegheny County with 2,900 people and here I am winning a major election. I feel that's an accomplishment," he said as his voice cracked with emotion.

A separate race in that district was held to decide who would fill out the rest of Ms. Watt's term, which ends with the year, but neither Ms. Caldwell nor Mr. Futules actively sought the two-month term, which could be decided by write-in votes cast yesterday.

The two other contested council races went to the incumbents. Joan Cleary, D-Brentwood, defeated Republican challenger Donald Lacek of Castle Shannon to win a second term in District 6. In District 5, incumbent Vince Gastgeb, R-Bethel Park, who has held the office since the inception of council, defeated Democrat Barbara Logan, a Mt. Lebanon commissioner.

Correction/Clarification: (Published Nov. 8, 2007) Chuck McCullough, the Republican elected to a County Council at-large seat Tuesday, directed a bank to issue checks for campaign contributions as the trustee of an account for an Upper St. Clair widow. A story yesterday incorrectly said he issued the checks.