Four Democrats secured the four vacancies on Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, leaving the sole Republican candidate far behind.
Two of the winners, Cathleen Bubash and Michael E. McCarthy, were confirmed by the state Senate this past summer to fill the posts through the end of the year and spent the past few months serving on the court. Judge Bubash hears cases in the Adult Section of the court's Family Division and Judge McCarthy works in the Civil Division.
The other two Democratic candidates, Kelly Eileen Bigley and Jack McVay, currently work as attorneys.
All four will serve 10-year terms, beginning next year.
They defeated Arnie Klein, of Upper St. Clair, who is registered as a Democrat but was forced to run as Republican. He cross-filed for the primary, but won only the Republican Party's nomination.
"I'm a Democrat," Mr. Klein said, but "having the word Democrat under your name is a big advantage."
The 46-year-old said he was grateful to make it to November in his first candidacy and planned to run again in the future.
Three judges retained their positions on the county court. President Judge Joseph M. James, who is the administrator of all sitting judges, Judge W. Terrence O'Brien, a civil court judge, and Judge Lester G. Nauhaus, who tries cases in the Criminal Division, will all serve another 10 years.
The four vacancies opened up when Judges Robert C. Gallo and R. Stanton Wettick Jr. advanced to senior status, Judge Cynthia Baldwin was appointed to the state Supreme Court and Judge Walter R. Little retired in 2006, shortly before he died.
The new judges will earn $152,115 and may be assigned to serve in the county's Civil, Criminal, Family or Orphans' Court divisions.
Judge McCarthy, 57, of Ross, said he was looking forward to permanently taking on the role of judge. He has heard cases in the Civil Division since his confirmation, taking on some of Judge Gallo's backlog. He worked 15 years as a hearing master for the Allegheny County Board of Viewers. Previously, he ran a one-man law firm, handling personal injury, estate and criminal cases. He also worked as an assistant district attorney.
"I welcome this opportunity," he said. "It's an honor. I'm a common guy for Common Pleas. I can't wait for tomorrow."
Judge Bubash, 48, of the North Side, was also appointed last summer and currently tries child support, divorce and custody cases in the Family Division. She worked as a trial lawyer for the Allegheny County public defender's office and then as a private criminal lawyer before serving seven years as district judge on the North Side.
"Having been appointed gives me a little bit of an edge," she said. "Nobody is a genie, you're not always going to come up with the right answer. You can only use the law and apply it to the facts to come up with the answer that best approximates justice."
Kelly Eileen Bigley, 42, of Upper St. Clair won the judgeship despite the fact that the county bar association rated her as "not recommended." She has practiced law since 1994, specializing in criminal and family practice. She worked for 10 years as a judicial law clerk for her father, who is Senior Judge Gerard M. Bigley.
Jack McVay, 51, of Brighton Heights, has practiced public service law for 23 years. He served 17 years as assistant Allegheny County solicitor for Children, Youth and Families. He also worked as general counsel for the county Housing Authority from 1993 to 1995.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.