If you were unable to attend the Sept. 27 mayoral debate on civic design or listen to it later on WDUQ, you still can get a sense of the candidates' positions on various issues by visiting the Pittsburgh Civic Design Coalition's Web site.
Not all of the audience's questions, submitted in writing, could be answered by Luke Ravenstahl and Mark DeSantis in the debate's 90-minute time period. So the candidates responded in writing after the debate, and the design coalition posted the questions and answers at www.pghdesigncoalition.org (look for the Mayoral Forum button).
While the candidates agreed on many things, some clear distinctions between the two were drawn.
Asked how they would balance quality of design with the pressure to allow any and all development, Ravenstahl responded that building permits are now easier to get, that developers are now able to get in one day what had taken a week or a month.
"It's about being more efficient," he said.
DeSantis responded that the city planning department, not profit and developers, should drive development and that planning should start in the neighborhoods with the support of the Urban Redevelopment Authority.
In response to a question asking how they would make quality design part of developments, DeSantis expressed a desire to "draw out the history in everything we do," including street lighting and how we position our buildings. "Put that history front and center so people who live here understand where they came from and who they are."
Ravenstahl said "good design is a good business investment," one that also enhances property values.
In the Q&A's on the Web site, the candidates were asked if they would consider appointing architects or other design professionals to the city Planning Commission. "Absolutely," DeSantis answered. Ravenstahl responded that there is none currently on the commission because architects and other design professionals "have their own panel," the Contextual Design Advisory Panel. True, but they also should have a voice -- and a vote --on the commission.
Asked about the role of a citywide master plan, Ravenstahl said the planning department's neighborhood-based SNAP approach -- Sector Neighborhood Asset Profile -- forms the framework for a neighborhood development strategy that will be his administration's version of a master plan.
DeSantis, who advocates merging the planning department and the URA, would reinvigorate a planning department that has diminished in size and influence in recent years. He would put the decision-making with planners, leaving only implementation in the hands of the URA. As for the master plan process itself, DeSantis was vague, saying it's "a function of the integrity" of the planning department. "We should make sure that the people we put in those positions understand the importance of standards."
Both candidates gave thoughtful, detailed answers to most of the questions, which also covered adaptive reuse of Mellon Arena, neighborhood retail development, a moratorium on memorials and more.
Thanks to the Civic Design Coalition for giving Pittsburghers a chance to comparison- shop on design issues and for kicking off what became a spirited debate season.
Frank House book
Carnegie Museum of Art has received a $60,000 grant from the Heinz Endowments to produce a book about Shadyside's Frank House, an important but lesser-known masterwork of modern architecture, furniture and landscape design. Designed in the late 1930s by architects Walter Gropius and Marcel Breuer, the house was their largest private home. The clients were arts patrons Robert and Cecelia Frank; Mr. Frank also was an engineer and industrialist who designed the house's mechanical systems.
The book's major essays will be written by Barry Bergdoll, curator of architecture and design at New York's Museum of Modern Art, and Alan I. W. Frank, the Franks' son and the house's historian. He hopes to develop the 12,000-square-foot home as a nonprofit house museum.
The publication also will include photography by Ezra Stoller, Richard Pare and others. An exhibition on the Frank House is scheduled to open at Carnegie Museum of Art's Heinz Architectural Center in 2009 and later travel to museums in New York and Boston.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.