A second Pittsburgh mayoral debate has been scheduled, but it's not yet clear whether all candidates will get to join.
KDKA-TV and the League of Women Voters of Greater Pittsburgh will sponsor an Oct. 30 face-off between Democratic incumbent Luke Ravenstahl and Republican Mark DeSantis, but the two organizations have not yet decided whether to include third-party candidates.
League Vice President of Voter Services Arlene Levy raised the issue Sunday in an e-mail to KDKA staff noting that Libertarian Mark Rauterkus and Socialist Workers Party member Ryan Scott have also filed petitions with enough signatures to qualify them for the mayoral ballot.
"Could we, also, extend an invitation to them to participate in our candidates forum?" she asked.
That's a thorny question. On one hand, giving voters a look at all candidates seems fair. On the other hand, if a candidate has no chance of winning, their presence on the stage could be a distraction.
The debate on debates is also playing out in the presidential race, where activists with video cameras are making a novel play for third-party inclusion.
KDKA's news release announcing its debate noted that Mr. Ravenstahl and Mr. DeSantis have agreed to participate, but the station was silent on other candidates.
WPXI-TV, the United Jewish Federation and the Jewish Community Center have scheduled an Oct. 28 debate between the Democrat and Republican.
There are pros and cons to including third-party candidates, said league President Suzanne Broughton.
"Whether or not they have a chance to win, they're legitimate candidates," she said.
Sometimes they "toss something into the mix that wouldn't otherwise become part of the discussion." On the other hand, including quixotic candidates "takes time away from candidates who have a real chance."
KDKA has no blanket policy on third-party inclusion, said News Director John Verrilli.
The downside to inclusion?
"You have an hour," he said, "so if you have more candidates, you have less time to hear from them."
For the mayor's race, the station hasn't decided whether to include Mr. Rauterkus and Mr. Scott, he said.
Mr. Ravenstahl's campaign is welcoming all comers.
"Open debate is the foundation of the democratic process," said his campaign spokeswoman, Danika Wukich.
"Mayor Ravenstahl believes that all mayoral candidates on the November ballot should participate in future debates," she said.
Mr. DeSantis wants to "leave it up to the sponsors," said the Republican's spokeswoman, Meghan E. Jones.
The conventional wisdom holds that a crowded stage favors the incumbent by drawing attention from the challenger. That's not necessarily true, said Mr. Rauterkus, a South Side swim coach who is also running for city controller and councilman.
A regular attendee at council meetings, he argues that he'll be better able to parry Mr. Ravenstahl on neighborhood issues.
"I think DeSantis and the Libertarians and the Socialist Workers Party can take down Luke Ravenstahl," he said. "I don't think DeSantis can do it himself."
The model for such a take-down may be the 1992 presidential race. Texas billionaire Ross Perot, running as an independent, was allowed to debate with incumbent Republican George H.W. Bush and Democrat Bill Clinton. Some analysts have said that Mr. Perot siphoned support from Mr. Bush, throwing the election to Mr. Clinton.
Since then, third-party candidates have effectively been barred from presidential debates.
The Commission on Presidential Debates requires that a candidate get on the ballot in enough states conceivably to win the post, and show support from 15 percent of the electorate in five organizations' polls before taking the stage.
In past years, candidates and activists have sued in failed efforts to overturn the rules.
This year, a political group called Rock the Debates is organizing an effort to videotape all of the major party candidates saying whether they would consent to debates with third-party candidates. They are posting the clips on the Internet site YouTube.
The theory: Once on the record, the eventual nominees will have to insist on inclusive debates prior to the 2008 general election.
The reality: Some answers have been muddy.
"I'm not going to make a 100 percent commitment," said Democratic candidate Sen. Hillary Clinton in a clip posted on YouTube.
"I would certainly be open to do it. There might be a couple of people who I would be a little bit reluctant about" debating.
Activists want to take the push for inclusive debates "all the way down the line" to state and big-city elections, said Richard Winger, editor of the San Francisco-based newsletter Ballot Access News.
"There are big ideological issues in big-city government."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.