Greene County President Judge H. Terry Grimes has asked for written arguments from the county's incumbent district attorney and a challenger over disputed Republican votes cast in the May 15 primary election.

In a hearing yesterday, Judge Grimes directed District Attorney Marjorie J. Fox and attorney David F. Pollock of Waynesburg to submit legal briefs outlining their positions in the dispute over the use of the surname Fox.

Ms. Fox, who is running for re-election, and Mr. Pollock, who held the post from 1988 to 2000, are both registered Democrats. Ms. Fox defeated Mr. Pollock in the Democratic primary by 355 votes and in the Republican primary by six write-in votes, according to results that were certified last month.

But Mr. Pollock has challenged those results, arguing that Ms. Fox was not a legitimate candidate because she is registered to vote under her married name, Marjorie J. Niedbala, and did not file an affidavit that stated she was known by another name as a candidate.

Mr. Pollock, whose middle name is Fox, also contends that Republican voters who wrote in only the last name of Fox could have intended to vote for him rather than for the incumbent. He wants the judge to toss out write-in votes for either the Fox or Pollock surname or both surnames, eliminating Ms. Fox's winning margin and enabling him to run as a Republican in the fall general election.