It was a primary that gave new meaning to the term foregone conclusion, at least for the highest-profile jobs. But it proved to be a topsy-turvy night for other candidates.

Pittsburgh Mayor Luke Ravenstahl and Allegheny County Chief Executive Dan Onorato yawned their way to easy victories last night in an election where the most competitive races weren't at the top of the ballot.

But there was upheaval in City Council, with two incumbents falling to challengers and a third trailing in a race too close to call. And a longtime row officer in Beaver County suffered defeat.

Mr. Ravenstahl, who assumed office after the death of Bob O'Connor in September, in essence won the primary in March, when his lone opponent, Councilman William Peduto, dropped out of the race.

Advertise with us

"Nine months ago, we began a journey that we never anticipated. Pittsburgh didn't know me very well. But, nevertheless, you embraced me," the mayor said in his victory speech.

However, Mr. Ravenstahl could face a Republican in the fall if a write-in campaign for businessman Mark DeSantis succeeds. Those results weren't available last night.

On the county side, Mr. Onorato, a Democrat, cruised to the nomination with only token opposition from Richard Swartz, executive director of the Bloomfield-Garfield Corp. He could face a GOP challenge in the fall, depending on the success of a last-minute write-in campaign. More than 3,000 such votes were cast.

"We're going to continue on the path that we started. We're going to continue to clean up the brownfields. We're going to continue to consolidate duplicated government," he said.

As speculation swirls that he has his eye on higher office, Mr. Onorato added, "When I enter a second term, I will give this 100 percent of my effort. We are just getting started. Pittsburgh has turned a corner."

Advertise with us

On a warm May day, hundreds of candidates competed for spots on local school and municipal boards, county and statewide judgeships, and city and county council races. In Philadelphia, a hotly contested mayor's race commanded the city's attention.

Turnout was as lackluster as the races at the top of the ballot. Allegheny County Elections Director Mark Wolosik predicted a 30 percent turnout on the Democratic side and 25 percent for Republicans.

But in some predominantly Democratic city districts, turnout was running 20 to 25 percent. Overall turnout ended at 27 percent for Democrats and nearly 25 percent for the GOP.

In Pittsburgh, the biggest battle was not for mayor, but the second highest job -- controller, as five candidates slugged it out in the Democratic primary.

That race featured some of the city's better-known political names, including Council President Doug Shields, former county commissioner Mike Dawida and county Prothonotary Michael Lamb.

Advertise with us

Mr. Lamb, who ran for mayor in 2005, ended up taking the race in a comfortable margin. A primary victory would all but assure his election, given that no Republicans ran.

The night was not without upsets.

City Councilwoman Twanda Carlisle, facing charges that she funneled $43,160 in city money through consultants to her personal and campaign bank accounts, lost to Ricky Burgess for the Democratic nomination in District 9.

In City Council District 3, challenger Bruce Kraus beat Democratic incumbent Jeff Koch in a fierce battle for the nomination. And in District 7, challenger Patrick Dowd held a paper thin lead over incumbent Len Bodack for the Democratic nod.

For Allegheny County Council, Jim Ellenbogen defeated incumbent William Lestitian for the Democratic nomination in District 12. And Charles McCullough, a lawyer who ended his campaign for the Republican at-large post last month amid an investigation into his handling of an elderly client's trust fund, nonetheless won the nomination.

Advertise with us

For sheriff, political novice and law enforcement veteran William Mullen Jr. triumphed over two opponents for the Democratic nomination. Mr. Mullen became acting sheriff when Pete DeFazio resigned last fall. In November, he faces Republican Edward Kress, who was unopposed last night.

In Beaver County, there was another big upset. County Controller Richard Towcimak, a Democratic party stalwart who has held the office since 1984, lost the nomination to Monaca Councilman David Rossi.

And in the Philadelphia mayor's race, former city councilman Michael Nutter defeated six other candidates in the battle for the Democratic nomination.

Annie O'Neill, Post-Gazette photos

Allegheny County Executive Dan Onorato, who easily won the Democratic party's nomination, pauses before speaking at the IBEW hall on the South Side. With him are his daughter Kate, wife Shelly, and son, Danny.

Advertise with us

Click photo for larger image.

Mayor Luke Ravenstahl and his wife, Erin, after his primary win last night.

Click photo for larger image.Related Stories, Unofficial Results

More primary coverage

Video: Scenes from an election night headquarters

Advertise with us

The PG's Early Returns blog

Allegheny County

Armstrong County

Beaver

Butler

Advertise with us

Fayette

Greene

Washington

Westmoreland

Pennsylvania Department of State -- Primary 2007 Returns

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.