Shootings are all too frequent. Investment is rare. The streets are crumbling. The incumbent faces corruption charges.
That's the landscape in Pittsburgh Council District 9, where eight candidates are on next Tuesday's Democratic primary ballot.
"You have a community that just looks like it's in so much disarray that it's kind of a turnoff," said candidate Leah Kirkland.
The latest blow to the district was struck April 11, when a county grand jury handed up 17 corruption charges against Councilwoman Twanda Carlisle. The 48-year-old East Hills resident is accused of funneling $43,160 in city money through consultants into her personal and campaign bank accounts.
Most of her rivals haven't made an issue out of the charges, noting that she's innocent until proven guilty.
Two candidates take a more aggressive stand. Judith Ginyard, a 48-year-old real estate broker from North Point Breeze who lost to Ms. Carlisle in 2003, wants the incumbent to step down. Larimer community organizer Ora Lee Carroll, 65, wants the General Assembly to impeach her.
More pressing is the district's violent crime, said the Rev. Ricky Burgess, of North Point Breeze, who has the Democratic committee's endorsement.
The 50-year-old pastor of Nazarene Baptist Church in Homewood said he'll link police, probation and parole officers, nonprofit groups, churches and schools in a four-part assault on crime. They'll work together to prevent young people from getting into drugs, intervene when they do, conduct "targeted sweeps" of crime-infested areas, and then work to reintegrate released offenders into civic life.
He said the city also needs to show young people "that there can be something different" than crime, by creating "pipelines" to union jobs and posts in the police and fire bureaus.
The Allegheny County Labor Council has endorsed Ms. Kirkland, 25, of Lincoln-Lemington. She also may have some Democratic committee support. Her mother is chair of the 12th Ward committee, and her father is part of that committee.
With managerial experience and a political science degree from Slippery Rock University, Ms. Kirkland presents herself as a business-savvy choice.
"We cannot expect big business to come into our community and put money into it if we don't take care of it," she said. She is working with Alex Development to get a Family Dollar store in Lincoln-Lemington.
That effort is controversial. Ms. Ginyard, who was director of the Lincoln-Lemington Community Development Corp. until last year, had a $1.5 million concept for the same site, which she maintains was a better plan.
But council voted to sell the site to Alex Development because Ms. Ginyard's group owed $5,679 in property taxes on its Frankstown Avenue headquarters. The headquarters has been sold, the taxes paid, and Ms. Ginyard has left the director's post.
She said she has the skills to forge "an implementation strategy" to redevelop the district.
Ms. Carroll, director of East Liberty Concerned Citizens, said her neighborhood has a development plan, as do others, and the plans should be linked together.
She argued that the city, even as it heads for rough fiscal waters, should neither cut services nor raise taxes.
City government, she said, should "get rid of the fat ... Too many employees, and some people need to be removed from the City-County Building."
Homewood repair shop owner William Anderson, 34, wants to make council membership a part-time job and cut the salary.
Eric S. Smith, a 36-year-old academic training counselor from East Hills, said experience in banking would help him evaluate the city's $419 million budget. "I think privatization is the way to go with a lot of the problems we're having," he said.
Ms. Ginyard said she wouldn't rule out hiking "a few taxes" to support city needs.
Ms. Kirkland said the city should "force a commuter tax," and cut costs by merging some functions with the county.
"If we merged with the county tomorrow, the county does not have the wherewithal to get us out of debt," said Mr. Burgess.
He said he'd like to see the state take on some of the city's $469 million unfunded pension obligation. He also wants the General Assembly to give the city leverage to negotiate payment plans with large nonprofit institutions that currently make only voluntary contributions to the city.
Mr. Burgess has been the subject of anonymous e-mails questioning his taxpaying history, ownership of a liquor license, and management of the Concerned Citizens Community Creation Center, or 5Cs, a nonprofit counseling agency for families.
He has paid off back property taxes to the city and county that had built up over 10 years.
He said the liquor license he holds is for a Butler Street tavern operated by his mother-in-law before her shooting there two years ago. He denied ever working there. The bar is closed, and he said he may sell it.
He said that if he wins election, he will step down as director of the 5Cs, which has paid him slightly more than the council salary of $55,029. He said he will reduce his role teaching communications for the Community College of Allegheny County, but will not give up his pastorship.
Ms. Carlisle did not respond to requests for an interview. School board member Randall Taylor, 45, of North Point Breeze, is on the ballot but not campaigning.
David Adams, publisher of a newsletter called The Conscience, is running a write-in campaign for the Republican nomination.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.