Three members of Allegheny County Council yesterday said they are returning $10,000 campaign donations written from the trust fund of an elderly Upper St. Clair woman who said she never authorized the donations.
Two of the recipients, Jan Rea and Vince Gastgeb, said they held back several weeks before cashing the checks given to them by Pittsburgh attorney Charles McCullough because they were puzzled by their size and the intentions behind them. A third recipient, County Council Member Susan Caldwell, also will be returning her donation, her campaign treasurer said.
"I think I did say to him, 'Are you sure that she would want me to have this amount of money? He said she had ... eight figures in dollars and she wants to help women," said Ms. Rea, the first of the trio to announce her plan to return the donation.
The woman from whose funds the checks were written, Shirley H. Jordan, 90, a wealthy widow whose husband left behind an estate estimated in the millions, said this week that she never authorized campaign donations, and would never make contributions of $10,000 to a political candidate.
Her attorney, Mr. McCullough, who has overseen her affairs since she granted him power of attorney after an Orphans Court judge ruled her incapacitated, said he had discussed the donations with her.
Mrs. Jordan was diagnosed with moderate dementia in 2005 after she was taken to St. Clair Hospital, complaining that she heard voices threatening her. At the time, she could not name the current president. Allegheny County voting records list her status as inactive, and show that she has not cast a ballot in seven years.
The County Council members, all of whom are up for re-election this year, with Ms. Rea running unopposed, said they were handed the checks during the Republican Committee's annual Lincoln Day Dinner Feb. 22 at a Green Tree hotel.
A fourth Republican candidate who received a $10,000 check, Common Pleas Judge Cheryl Allen, is seeking the Republican nomination for Pennsylvania Superior Court. Her campaign manager did not respond to inquiries today about her plans.
Informed of the donation to Judge Allen, Mrs. Jordan indicated that she did not know the judge and declared that she would "never vote for her."
Judge Allen and Mr. Gastgeb both sit on the board of the Frank J. and Shirley H. Jordan Charitable Foundation, a charity set up last year by Mr. McCullough, who said he was fulfilling an 11-year-old estate plan by the Jordans. The Foundation board has met once, with members paid $1,000 each for their attendance, but none of the board members has met Mrs. Jordan.
Mr. McCullough noted that the political donations came from Mrs. Jordan's personal trust fund, not through the charitable foundation.
One board member, former Allegheny County Chief Executive Jim Roddey, abruptly resigned from the board Tuesday after hearing about the campaign donations.
"I did not have a good feeling about it," said Mr. Roddey, who was in Texas and said he sent an e-mail to Mr. McCullough stating that he was quitting the board and wanted to talk with him about his concerns.
Like other members of the board, Mr. Roddey has not met Mrs. Jordan.
"It was represented to me that she was an elderly woman who was a little eccentric and she was in the early stages of dementia," Mr. Roddey said.
While Ms. Rea and Ms. Caldwell will return the donations outright, Mr. Gastgeb said he plans to send back the money, but also request a meeting with Mrs. Jordan to determine whether she had, in fact, intended to contribute to him.
"I'd like to have a meeting with her to clarify if she wanted me to have it," Mr. Gastgeb said.
Christa Meeder, who handles campaign finances for Ms. Caldwell, said the council member became concerned after reading in yesterday's Post-Gazette that Mrs. Jordan had been diagnosed with moderate dementia in 2005.
"At the time we accepted the check, we were unaware of her mental state," Ms. Meeder said. "I am willing to do whatever it takes to make it right."
Mr. McCullough said earlier this week that Mrs. Jordan had a history of political giving in the past and wanted to become active in giving again.
"She asked me if there are good people out there that can use some help. I suggested a number of names to her. We talked about them more and she seemed to be more interested in helping local people and she thought she could make a difference," Mr. McCullough said.
Mrs. Jordan, however, said she would not have made donations of that sort.
"It was not my decision," she said. "I knew nothing about it."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.