Election results by county
Courts will decide whether Baldwin-Whitehall school board member Beverly Coon tried to kill her estranged boyfriend -- Bethel Park school Superintendent Ronald Grimm -- but voters appeared to have little trouble rejecting Ms. Coon for a second term on the board.
Ms. Coon, a Democrat, was headed for overwhelming defeat last night, and appeared to be taking her former running mate, Michael Stelmasczyk, to defeat as well.
In Pittsburgh, incumbent Democrat Theresa Colaizzi won the only contested race among five school board seats on the ballot.
In Moon, voters installed four school board candidates who are opposed to a controversial $76 million building and renovation program, tipping the board majority and raising doubts about the plans.
Baldwin-Whitehall: Coon out
Unofficial results indicated that Ms. Coon was in last place in a field of six candidates seeking four seats in a school district made up of Baldwin Borough, Baldwin Township and Whitehall.
Newcomer Nancy Sciulli DiNardo, a homemaker from Baldwin Borough, was heading the ticket, followed by current board President John Schmotzer.
Republicans Edward Moeller and George L. Pry were leading for the remaining two seats, according to unofficial tallies.
Before Ms. Coon's arrest, the chief issue in the race was differences of opinion about the size, scope and cost of a renovation of Baldwin High School, an enormous venture that is expected to cost more than $60 million.
In the primary, Ms. Coon and Mr. Stelmasczyk, both incumbents, often campaigned together, raising questions about the cost of the project, the leadership of Mr. Schmotzer and the philosophy of his team, which included Mr. Pry and Mrs. DiNardo.
Ms. Coon and Mr. Stelmasczyk won the Democratic primary, but lost the Republican primary. Mr. Schmotzer and Mrs. DiNardo won both primaries. Mr. Pry and Mr. Moeller won the Republican primary.
On Oct. 12, the political landscape changed when Allegheny County and Monroeville police charged Ms. Coon, 46, of Whitehall, with drugging her estranged boyfriend, Dr. Grimm, 60, with pastries laced with sedatives and setting fire to his Monroeville apartment on Sept. 9. Police believe Ms. Coon acted out of revenge after Dr. Grimm tried to break off their two-year relationship.
After a preliminary hearing Oct. 22, Monroeville District Judge Walter Luniewski Jr. ordered Ms. Coon to stand trial for attempted homicide, arson, risking catastrophe, criminal mischief, reckless endangerment and stalking.
Since her arrest and hearing, the focus of the school board race switched from questions about the renovation project to the scandal. Mr. Stelmasczyk immediately began distancing himself from Ms. Coon, using purple tape to cover her name on political yard signs.
Pittsburgh: Incumbent wins
Ms. Colaizzi, District 5 representative on the city school board, easily defeated Republican Tom Baker last night to win her second four-year term.
It was the only contested city school board race on the ballot. Besides Greenfield, where Ms. Colaizzi and Mr. Baker live, District 5 takes in Hazelwood, Hays, Lincoln Place and parts of Oakland, Squirrel Hill and the South Side.
Ms. Colaizzi, 45, co-owner of a hair salon, said she has been an aggressive board member who helped bring Superintendent Mark Roosevelt to the district and gained valuable experience working on budgets and union contracts. Mr. Baker, 25, recruitment and retention specialist for Three Rivers Adoption Council, criticized Ms. Colaizzi for her frequent arguments with board members.
"I guess I'm doing something right," Ms. Colaizzi said. "People want me to stay."
Retired federal housing employee Thomas Sumpter will succeed Alex Matthews as the District 3 school board member, covering Garfield and parts of the Hill District, Bloomfield, Friendship, Stanton Heights, Larimer and East Liberty. Mr. Matthews did not seek re-election and endorsed Mr. Sumpter, 55.
Bethel Park: A GOP winner
Republican Charles J. Scheuble Jr. won the only contested race, for a two-year term, defeating Democrat James A. McGrath.
Mr. Scheuble, 52, is currently serving on the board as an appointee. His new term will begin next month.
He is vice president of J.B. O'Connor Co., a local manufacturer's representative, and has lived in Bethel Park for 24 years.
Four incumbents were re-elected to four-year terms without opposition: Daniel B. Duff, Charles G. Koch, Richard N. Rose and Connie H. Ruhl.
Moon: Building foes take over
Voter wrath over a $76 million building and renovation project for the middle and high schools carried the vote in Moon, as four new school board members -- all vocal opponents of the project -- swept to victory.
Republican Jeff Bussard defeated Democrat Gary Aiello in the only contested race on the slate. Three others -- Republicans Ben Bonham, Carol Cellini-Dillon and Mark Limbruner -- ran uncontested after winning both parties' nominations in the May primary.
Billing themselves as the "Candidates Four Integrity," the new members tip the balance to a 5-4 Republican majority on the board. Though a groundbreaking was held Friday, the new board members have said they will try to halt the project.
Montour: 3 newcomers win
Three newcomers and an incumbent were elected to the Montour school board.
In Region 3, four candidates vied for three seats, and Republican incumbent Leslie Muha Power, who did not campaign, was the loser.
Newcomer Cynthia Morrow and former Montour principal and administrator John Mosimann, both of whom won both party nominations in the spring, led the race.
The third victor was incumbent Democrat Joyce A. Snell.
Former Ingram councilman and tax collector Mike Steele ran unopposed after having defeated incumbent Jan Esterly of Thornburg in the primary election. He will represent Region 1.
Mt. Lebanon: Changes in wind
Incumbent Rodney Shepherd was a narrow loser to newcomer Josephine Posti in unofficial returns.
Mr. Shepherd, 48, a lawyer in private practice, was seeking a second full term on the board.
The other leaders in unofficial returns were: Mark Hart, 41, director of business and chief financial officer of the Pittsburgh Steelers; Alan Silhol, 49, chief counsel for the real estate division of American Eagle Outfitters Inc.; and Dan Remely, 54, president of H-Squared Properties Inc.
Ms. Posti, 37, is owner of her own advertising and public relations firm. Besides Mr. Shepherd, the other unsuccessful candidate was Faith Stipanovich, 45, payroll manager for the Allegheny County controller's office.
All of the candidates said they were prompted to enter the race at least in part because they were angry with the current school board's $500,000-plus buyout of former Superintendent Margery Sable a year ago.
Mr. Hart, who appeared to garner the most votes, said he believed the support he received indicates that voters "want a complete change in how the board operates." Mr. Hart has pledged to make the board more open in its operations and decision-making and has vowed to try to uncover the reasons Dr. Sable was asked to resign.
Penn Hills: 2 incumbents lose
Robert Hudak decided to run for school board in the spring because he wanted to contribute his talents to the district where he was a teacher and administrator for many years.
He was genuinely surprised to be the top vote-getter in the race for five open seats on the board yesterday.
"I am thrilled and excited and overwhelmed," Mr. Hudak said.
One of his priorities will be to spread "a positive message about the Penn Hills School District in the region." This was his first try for public office.
Also a clear winner was incumbent Barry Patterson, who, like Mr. Hudak, captured both party nominations in the spring.
Democratic incumbent Erin Vecchio and newcomer Carolyn L. Faggioli won narrowly over Republican incumbents Linda Schlegel and Heather K. Hoolahan for the two remaining seats carrying four-year terms.
Democrat John A. Zacchia, 55, a truck driver making his first try for public office, defeated Republican Robert I. Miller for a two-year term.
Peters: Stepusin leads
Republican John Stepusin led Democrat Ernest Sichi for the fourth of four school board seats carrying four-year terms.
Three candidates who won both party nominations in the spring appeared well on their way to victory for four-year terms: Diane Ritter, Gregory J. Smith and David Hvizdos.
Dr. Smith, 52, a psychologist, made fiscal restraint the centerpiece of his campaign, saying he was "convinced we're not spending our money well."
The board has raised taxes in the rapidly growing district the past two years, and projections are that a third consecutive increase might be needed.
Mrs. Ritter, 52, is a lifelong Peters resident with a background in advertising.
Mr. Hvizdos, 50, is a lawyer appointed to a board vacancy last year. Dr. Stepusin, 55, is a veterinarian.
Incumbent Sandra Gregg was unopposed for a two-year term.
Plum: 4 newcomers triumph
With seven candidates, none of them incumbents, vying for four seats, the winners were Dawn Caruso, Kevin Dowdell, Loretta M. White and Kris Traficanti.
Ms. Caruso, 38, works in the Wilkinsburg School District as a librarian. She has two daughters in Plum schools, and campaigned on a theme of restrained spending and holding down taxes.
Mr. Dowdell, 47, is an engineering manager.
Mrs. White, 69, a retired Plum High School teacher, said she would like to see the curriculum strengthened with more concentration on math and science.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.