For some, talk of consolidation in a cluster of Mercer County communities over the last five years has worn them out. It didn't pass in last week's referendum, and many are sick of hearing about it.
For others, the defeat of a measure to transform five municipalities into a new, larger city should be a starting point for more work.
The question on the ballot, which had to be approved by a majority in all five communities, asked people to consolidate Hermitage, Sharon, Farrell, Wheatland and Sharpsville into the new city of Shenango Valley. The only cities to pass the measure are the two in financial trouble -- Sharon and Farrell.
Sharon has been declining in recent years because of various plant closures, and Farrell is already under Act 47 status as a distressed city. It had the distinction of being the first in the state to enter the program in 1987 when Sharon Steel, which employed thousands of people, filed for bankruptcy. That led to a loss of property taxes for Farrell, and a rapid decline.
After years of struggling, Farrell is finally in the black, said Tom Tulip, the city's Act 47 coordinator. This year, there's a surplus of about $125,000.
It might appear, then, that the city could rebound and come out from under state control, but it has the surplus is because of a 0.4 percent nonresident wage tax it's allowed to collect under Act 47.
Without that money, the city would lose $200,000 and any kind of surplus, Tulip said.
That's why many in the two communities saw the consolidation as a way up.
But voters in Sharpsville and Wheatland easily defeated the referendum, and voters in Hermitage, the most vocally opposed, rejected consolidation by more than 2 to 1.
"Economically, we're in good shape, and things are getting even better," said Pat White, a city commissioner in Hermitage.
Just like Sharon and Farrell in the 1980s, Hermitage faced the same problems of losing jobs and property-tax revenue. But, White continued, officials in Hermitage worked aggressively to turn the trend around.
"We didn't prosper overnight. It took 20 years," White said.
Though Hermitage does have low real-estate taxes and a growing population, Alan Kugler, president of PA Futures, a consulting firm that's worked on the consolidation issue for six years, said it was not as well off as other suburban areas across the state.
"Hermitage and the other municipalities are all interconnected," he said. "For Hermitage to survive and prosper in the future requires a vibrant Sharon, Farrell, Sharpsville and Wheatland.
"I think there's broad recognition of that."
What consolidation would have done to create that, besides easing obvious burdens of cash flow, was show the world that it's a dynamic place, Kugler said.
Supporters of consolidation believed it would draw more attention from developers -- the new city would have been the third-largest in Western Pennsylvania -- and allow it to be more competitive in grants and loans because of its new clout.
The defeat of consolidation, though, has not ended hope of fiscal recovery.
"I think regardless of how the vote turned out, it was a success," Kugler said.
That's because he believes that the years of talk about consolidation have raised awareness among the communities of the need for shared services and intergovernmental cooperation.
The area has a strong regional council of governments, and they are already working on consolidating some services, such as animal control, recreation and comprehensive planning.
"That, I'm certain, is going to continue. Intergovernmental cooperation is essential," Kugler said.
But for officials in Farrell, they will now have to figure out new ways to continue to decrease spending.
Already, the city has eliminated its police department and joined a regional one. It has only a paid fire chief and deputy; the rest are volunteers, and it's reduced staffing in the city.
"They've taken a lot of hard steps to cut staff and services," Tulip said. "The bottom line is they're going to have to bite the bullet by cutting expenditures even further."
There are a few more things left to try, he continued. For example, they could talk about merging streets departments and public works.
Kugler thinks it's possible for officials in Sharon and Farrell to look into merging their communities into one, though others have raised concerns about consolidating two struggling cities.
Sharon Mayor David Ryan, though, says everyone is fed up with talk of consolidation. He wasn't surprised the idea failed because of the plan developed to support it.
"It wasn't fiscally sound," Ryan said.
Kugler agreed.
"That was a weakness coming into the vote," Kugler said. "It was asking people to come in and vote on faith."
Ryan is hopeful Sharon and Farrell will recover; he's just not sure how.
Under state law, the specific question on the ballot last week cannot be presented again for at least five years. The law doesn't have much impact, though, because simply changing the name of the newly proposed city would be enough to get it on again.
In the meantime, Ryan says officials in Sharon are thinking about pursuing a home-rule charter.
"We're just barely holding our head above water," Ryan said. "It's the jobs. It's the economy that's killing us. If that turned around, there'd be no talk of consolidation."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.