If approved, the referendum would have created Western Pennsylvania's third-largest city and brought much-needed economic opportunity to two desperate towns in Mercer County.

Instead, the cities of Farrell and Sharon will have to continue to fight on their own. With 61 percent of the precincts reporting, a ballot measure to consolidate those two cities, along with Hermitage, Sharpsville and Wheatland, into the new city of Shenango Valley was being easily defeated.

Pat White, a city commissioner in Hermitage, was one of the people who fought hard over the last several weeks against consolidation.

"I think this could have been really catastrophic if it would have passed, not only for Hermitage, but for the whole Shenango Valley," White said.

Advertise with us

Part of the motivation for consolidating came from Farrell's status as a distressed city.

Its problems started in 1987 when Sharon Steel filed for bankruptcy. It lost much of its property tax revenue and has struggled ever since. Even though about a dozen businesses have moved in under the state Keystone Opportunity Zone program, no tax money will come from those companies until 2011.

Officials from the state suggested studying consolidation, and a committee was formed in 1999 to study what benefits might come from forming one new, larger city.

After years of meetings, the committee chose not to make any recommendation, and a group of volunteers, calling themselves Citizens for the Valley, collected more than 900 signatures on a petition to get the question on the ballot and let the communities themselves decide.

Over the last several weeks, though, a new committee, "Hermitage Residents Against Consolidation," joined the fight. They donated time and money and placed huge banners around the community that read, "Higher taxes, less services, vote no for consolidation." Their work prevailed, and now the issue cannot be raised again for at least five years.

Advertise with us

Proponents of the consolidation said it would have slowed the increase in property taxes across the Shenango Valley, decreased general government spending and eliminated repetition of services.

Jim DeCapua, who participated in the four-year study, believes consolidation would have put the new city in a better position to lure companies to the region and generate additional grant money from the state.

"For sure, the status quo is not working. That's quite obvious," said DeCapua, executive director of the Mercer County Regional Council of Governments. "The only salvation for the valley is the creation of new employment opportunities."

But opponents believed it would result in the elimination of police and firefighter positions and make other communities carry the weight of Sharon and Farrell's problems.

Consolidation would have greatly increased property taxes in Hermitage, which has been booming, to help keep everyone else's low, White said, and he couldn't stand for that.

He is willing, though, to help Farrell and Sharon in sharing services and resources, and that hasn't changed. In fact, he hopes the dialogue started by the consolidation issue will prompt even more of that.