His legal name is Samuel W. Howze. But for the past 35 years and through eight elections, he has gone by the name Sala Udin. And yesterday, that was good enough for a county judge.
Common Pleas President Judge Joseph M. James refused to remove the city councilman's name from the May 17 primary ballot, saying he found no evidence that Udin was trying to deceive anybody by not using his given name.
James made the ruling during a long day in a small, stuffy, packed courtroom in the Frick Building -- "Remind me not to use this courtroom again," he joked at one point -- where he heard dozens of challenges to the nominating petitions filed by candidates for municipal, school district and county offices.
By the end of the day, James had ruled on more than three dozen challenges, in some cases giving candidates renewed life and in others tossing them off the ballot.
One candidate left hanging overnight was county Councilman Charles Martoni, D-Swissvale. Edward T. Samuel, a resident in Martoni's District 8, asked James to bump Martoni from the ballot because the candidate's financial interest statement was incorrectly filed at the Swissvale borough building instead of the county manager's office.
In Udin's case, Matthew Moore Jr. challenged the candidate's nominating petition, claiming the name on it was fictitious and designed to "mislead the signers."
Udin is facing two challengers in the Democratic primary: party-endorsed Tonya Payne of the Hill District and city school board member Mark Brentley Sr. of the North Side. A separate challenge to Brentley's nominating petition was withdrawn yesterday.
The fact that Udin's given name is Samuel Howze is not new. It is widely known on Grant Street and has been reported in the newspapers.
In a 1995 Pittsburgh Post-Gazette article, Udin said he changed his name after his experiences in Mississippi in the mid-1960s organizing black voters and after converting to Islam. Sala Udin, he said at the time, meant "seeker of knowledge."
In court yesterday, Udin, who has been on council since 1995, said his driver's license, mortgage, Social Security card and city-issued paychecks carry the name Samuel Howze. But he added he is registered to vote under the name Sala Udin and that Udin "is the name I've been going by as long as I've been on City Council and in public office." He said he has been using it for 35 years.
The councilman added he has no plans to legally change his name to Udin. Asked why, he said, "personal choice."
Moore's attorney, Angelo Papa, said Udin's nominating petition should be declared invalid because he did not use his legal name, claiming it was an attempt to confuse voters.
Udin's attorney, Ira Weiss, noted that Papa was unable to produce any witnesses who were confused.
"I would submit that if he ran as Samuel W. Howze, it would bring more confusion than if he ran as Sala Udin," Weiss said.
James agreed.
"I find no fraud on the electorate," he said. "They intended to nominate the person they nominated."
"Obviously, I'm pleased with the judge's decision because it now puts this race in the hands of the voters ... rather than in the hands of a tiny group of manipulators," Udin said.
In other decisions, James ruled that Wilkinsburg Mayor Wilbert Young may run for a third term in the Democratic primary but must file an amended ethics statement by Friday.
Councilwoman Sandra Roberts wanted Young stricken from the ballot for not revealing back taxes he owes to Wilkinsburg, the school district and county. She also claimed that Young has additional debts under the alias "Wilbert Jones," but Young testified that the Jones debts were a matter of mistaken identity.
James struck Andrea Vok from the Republican ballot for district judge in Braddock, Braddock Hills, Rankin and Swissvale for failure to get enough signatures. Incumbent Ross Cioppa filed the challenge.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.