As campaigners for mayoral challenger William Peduto knocked on doors in Brookline over the weekend, they found Mayor Luke Ravenstahl's smiling face at every house, on a city flier that had just hit mailboxes.

And if Mr. Ravenstahl's campaign aides checked local political blogs, they found an anonymous, 36-second spot that touts Mr. Peduto and disparages the incumbent's age by calling for "a mayor, not a minor."

Nine weeks from the May 15 primary, both sides found something to dislike in a Pittsburgh mayoral campaign that's being fought under evolving rules.

In a written statement, Mr. Peduto said the city mailer touting the 311 help line may be "a misuse of taxpayers' money" if "certain neighborhoods are now being targeted to receive 311 postcards as a way to boost support for Ravenstahl's campaign."

Advertise with us

The 311 line was launched in late October, and a first wave of postcards went out in the fall.

"The timing of it is irrelevant," said mayoral spokesman Dick Skrinjar of the new wave of cards. "We launched this information program before there were any candidates for mayor."

He said 45,933 cards were mailed out, part of a campaign that ultimately will be three times that size and cost $20,444 for mailing and $8,858 for printing. Complete it by the end of May, and the city can dodge a hike in postal rates, he said.

The mailing wasn't motivated by a need to drum up more business for the 311 line, he said, adding that it has handled 8,000 requests for service. In the few neighborhoods where the special number doesn't work, residents can call 412-255-2621, he said.

"Is he justified in informing the citizenry of a new service? Sure," said Jerry Shuster, professor of political communication at the University of Pittsburgh. "Is it right to put his picture on it? If I was an incumbent, I would."

Advertise with us

On the lawless Internet, anyone who goes to www.YouTube.com and types "Bill Peduto" in the search field can find a video called "Big Shoes."

It features a still shot of tied, black shoes with text that says the city is "at a crossroads" and that "Mayor O'Connor's death left some big shoes to fill ... A man's shoes. Bill Peduto. We need a mayor, not a minor."

"The word minor, that's a little bit of a cheap shot," said Damon Andrews, campaign manager for Mr. Ravenstahl. "He's 27 years old, and has been an [official] since he was 18," when he joined the Democratic Committee.

The spot ends with a disclaimer saying neither the candidate nor his campaign had any role in its creation. An effort to identify the spot's producer was inconclusive.

Pro-Peduto political blogs have embedded the spot in their postings in recent days.

Advertise with us

"The Peduto campaign does not know the producer of the 'Big Shoes' video commercial and will not comment specifically on its content," the councilman's campaign said in a statement. "YouTube provides a unique platform for grass-roots expression, and people can judge these things for themselves."

Mr. Peduto has repeatedly said he'll conduct a clean campaign, noted Mr. Shuster. That often involves denouncing negative ads by third parties.

"I think he does need to address the anonymity of it, and to some extent, take away the validity of the online ad," Mr. Shuster said. "Will [the ad] change votes? I'm saying no."