Martha Rial, Post-Gazette
Brenna Gallagher, 8, of Brookline, plays her GameBoy while waiting for her father, Perry High School football coach Bill Gallagher, outside a polling station last night at the Church of the Resurrection in Brookline.
Click photo for larger image.
See more Election Day photos Election results by county
Two Democratic Pittsburgh city councilmen easily won rematches against their Republican opponents last night, and a third Democrat fended off a GOP challenge to capture the other open seat.
But even with victories in contested races by two incumbents and a former staffer to Councilman Sala Udin, the City Council that will convene in January to engage new Mayor Bob O'Connor will be a relatively young, inexperienced bunch with arguably less authority than it has had in the past.
In yesterday's contests, Councilman Dan Deasy defeated Samuel C. Berninger for the second time in six months to capture a four-year term in District 2.
In District 4, incumbent Jim Motznik prevailed against Bob Hillen, the city GOP chairman, in a rematch of their 2001 clash.
In the third race, Tonya Payne, a former executive assistant to Mr. Udin, trounced Alan Perry to win in the District 6 battle between two non-incumbents. Ms. Payne defeated Mr. Udin in the primary.
In District 8, incumbent William Peduto, of Point Breeze, ran unopposed.
In a sign of just how inexperienced the new council will be, Mr. Motznik, a candidate for its presidency, returns as council's most senior member, having first been elected four years ago.
Ms. Payne, president and chief executive officer of the Uptown Community Action Group, and Mr. Deasy, who took office only last spring, essentially qualify as newcomers. And council will be getting another new face next year when council President Gene Ricciardi leaves to become a district judge.
Mr. Motznik, of Overbrook, doesn't see the inexperience as a handicap.
"I think it's a good thing. I think because we have new people on council that don't have the old ways to them that we are able to think out of the box at a time when we need to think out of the box," he said. "I think the city of Pittsburgh only benefits from having a young council and new administration."
Likewise, state Sen. Jim Ferlo, a former council president, and Joseph Sabino Mistick, an aide to former Mayor Sophie Masloff, said council's youth is not necessarily a bad thing.
The newcomers and a new mayor offer the city a fresh start after a decade of rule by outgoing Mayor Tom Murphy, they said.
"I think others at the state level and even locally, I think they welcome an opportunity to see some new faces, some different blood, in the decision-making Downtown," Mr. Ferlo said. "This is not meant to be critical of the Murphy administration, but I think people are looking for some new life there."
Martha Rial, Post-Gazette
Dot McFerron and her husband, Ken, work the polls together at Christian Church of Duquesne Heights in Pittsburgh's 19th Ward.
Click photo for larger image.
The new council's challenges may be greater than ever, given the bare bones city budget that has forced the closing of recreation centers and swimming pools and the independent state fiscal oversight that has eroded some of council's power.
"It's a tough job being on City Council right now because the expectations are high, but the resources are limited," Mr. Ferlo said.
Despite the penny-pinching times, Mr. Motznik and Mr. Deasy said their top priority will be adding more police officers in their districts. Mr. Deasy also wants to reopen the closed West End police station.
But if those priorities don't mesh with those of Mr. O'Connor, the newer council members, Mr. Mistick said, may quickly confront a political fact of life at city hall: The mayor controls the agenda.
"There's little that can be accomplished if you do not have a good relationship with the executive branch," he said.
Council's relative inexperience also could work to the advantage of Mr. O'Connor, who served on the body for 11 years, Mr. Mistick said.
"From the mayor's perspective, it's always good in a strong mayor form of government to have a council that doesn't have a clue," he said.
Mr. Motznik believes council will have a good relationship with the mayor. He said Mr. O'Connor has committed to working with council.
"Bob's not going to get over on council; council's not going to get over on the mayor. It's going to be a partnership," he said.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.