The job involves managing a shrinking budget, facing high expectations and lacking the power to achieve them, absorbing vitriol from the public and taking home a salary of $53,687 with no prospects for a big raise.
Yet the title of Pittsburgh City Council member perennially draws competitors willing to knock on doors and spend money for the opportunity to join in the nine-member body's oft-interminable meetings.
"It's been very difficult to be an elected official over the last four years because of the financial situation the city has been in," said Councilman Jim Motznik, a Democrat from Overbrook.
Yet he's running for re-election, facing Republican Bob Hillen of Beechview. Council newcomer Dan Deasy, a Westwood Democrat who won a special election in May, faces Sheraden Republican Sam Berninger. And Tonya Payne, a Democrat from the Uptown section of the Hill District, is battling Republican Alan Perry of Manchester for the seat now held by Sala Udin.
Ask the candidates what they're hearing as they knock on doors, and they all say basically the same thing.
"It's just too dangerous out here," summarized Ms. Payne, 41, who heads the Uptown Community Action Group. "We shouldn't feel like we're hostages."
She pointed to the Oct. 9 shooting death of Mr. Udin's son, Patrice Howze, in the Hill District, as a prime example.
"All our lives are in danger," she said.
Ms. Payne's platform centers on public safety. Endorsed by the Fraternal Order of Police, she said she was the best person to "build a real partnership between the police department and the community."
She'd also like to return to the days when police officers walked the beat, a practice largely ended in 2002.
"They were the eyes and the ears and it was a deterrent to some degree," she said. She'd also like to go beyond current plans to bring the Police Bureau up to 900 officers.
Mr. Perry, 59, said he'd like to see 1,400 city police. The addition of 500 rookie officers would cost the city $18 million in salaries, plus benefits, but he said it would be possible if you "look at the budget carefully and get help from the state."
He argued that as an insurance broker who balances his books monthly, he'd be able to find budgetary savings. As a Republican, he could relate to state and federal leaders from that party and win funding. And as a former encyclopedia salesman, he could market areas of the district, like Downtown's Fifth and Forbes retail corridor, to developers.
Mr. Berninger, 29, comes from his party's conservative wing.
"Everything comes back down to the taxation," he said of the city's ills.
He'd like to slash council to five or seven members, and possibly merge the city's Urban Redevelopment Authority into Allegheny County's development agency. He'd be open to privatizing city functions.
Mr. Berninger lost 3-to-1 to Mr. Deasy in the special election to finish the term of Alan Hertzberg, now a Common Pleas Court judge. But he said Mr. Deasy has done little to secure his post.
"We just really haven't heard many ideas from him," Mr. Berninger said.
Mr. Deasy, 39, noted that in four months in office, he helped reopen Ream Pool in Mount Washington, got residents in 12 neighborhoods $20 refunds from a failed home value insurance program and laid the groundwork for a possible new park.
Next up? He said he hoped to reopen the police station in West End, closed since 2003.
Such a move might draw fire from the city's two state-appointed fiscal overseers, the Act 47 team and the Intergovernmental Cooperation Authority. They've criticized council efforts to add to its own operating funds and to hire rat control contractors.
"It's tough being put in the middle of both of those" boards, said Mr. Deasy. He said his 17 years of experience in the Public Works Department would help him find practical solutions to problems.
Mr. Motznik, 42, was also a public works veteran before he became a council aide in 1998 and a councilman in 2001. A frequent critic of the city's fiscal overseers, he is also considered a front-runner for council's presidency -- if he can hold off Mr. Hillen.
Theirs is a rematch of a 2001 race Mr. Motznik won by a nearly 5-to-1 margin. This time, Mr. Hillen, a 47-year-old painting contractor, is hoping changes in neighborhoods like Beechview may help him even the score.
Mr. Motznik barely held off a Democratic primary challenge by Anthony Coghill of Beechview.
Beechview is home to a growing Latino population, and the scene of a URA-supported renewal effort by developer Bernardo Katz.
"To the residents of Beechview, it's not a good thing," Mr. Hillen said, echoing a theme he's used on the campaign trail.
Mr. Katz "is moving in the right direction," countered Mr. Motznik, who said the developer closed two nuisance bars. "Unfortunately, politics comes into play when you're trying to make improvements in Beechview."
That brings up one other part of the job: bare-knuckled politics, every four years.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.