Post-Gazette

Sala Udin's, left, 10 years on city council appeared to have ended last night in defeat to former staff member Tonya Payne in the District 6 race.v

The endorsed Democrat won the primary in a special and primary election in District 2 for Pittsburgh City Council, but that was one of the few sure things about the results in four city council races.

Incumbent Councilman Sala Udin lost the Democratic primary to a former staffer. Councilman Jim Motznik was neck-and-neck all night with a Democratic challenger in his district before he pulled out a narrow victory.

Advertise with us

And while Councilman William Peduto may have lost his mayoral bid, he appeared on his way to a comfortable margin of victory for re-election to a second term in council District 8.

District 2

Daniel J. Deasy Jr., 38, a city public works foreman from Westwood, easily won a special election in District 2 to fill the remainder of the unexpired term of former Councilman Alan Hertzberg. Hertzberg resigned his council seat earlier this year after he was appointed by the state Senate to a seat on Allegheny County Common Pleas Court. Hertzberg won yesterday's primary on the Democratic ticket for a full 10-year judicial term.

Deasy also appeared to be in the lead by a sizeable margin among a field of five Democrats in District 2, all of whom were from Mount Washington except Deasy. Deasy, a city Democratic committeeman, last night credited his victories to the support he received in the neighborhoods and his endorsement from organized labor and the city Democratic committee.

"I think it was just plain old-fashioned hard work," Deasy said last night. "People respect a guy who gets up and goes to work every day."

Advertise with us

If the margin holds up, Deasy will face-off in November against Republican Samuel C. Berninger, 28, of Sheraden, whom Deasy beat in the special election.

The other Democratic candidates in District 2, all from Mount Washington, were Paul R. Mastandrea, 55; Erin C. Molchany, 27; Paul F. Renne, 61; and Melissa Rossiter, 32.

District 2 covers Banksville, Chartiers City, Crafton Heights, Duquesne Heights, East Carnegie, Elliott, Esplen, Fairywood, Mount Washington, Oakwood, Ridgemont, Sheraden, Windgap, West End and Westwood.

District 6

Udin's 10 years on City Council appear to be at an end when his term expires at the end of this year.

Advertise with us

Tonya Payne, 41, a former Udin staffer whom he fired eight years ago, was ahead in the Democratic primary voting all night and was ultimately victorious. Payne, president of the Uptown Community Action Group, said during the campaign that voters were dissatisfied with Udin's tenure on council because he failed to fully address economic development in his district.

Udin also faced opposition from Mark Brentley Sr., a member of the city school board.

Payne will face Republican Alan Perry in November. Perry ran unopposed in the primary.

District 6 encompasses the Hill District, Strip District, Downtown and parts of the North Side and Oakland.

District 4

Advertise with us

The District 4 race between Motznik and challenger Anthony Coghill was neck-and-neck last night, with each candidate hovering around the 50 percent mark until Motznik squeaked by with a small margin of victory as the final precincts votes were tallied.

"I thought that I would win by more votes than that," Motznik said last night. "I was pretty confident. But it's pretty difficult as an elected official to be successful these days because of the city's financial situation. If you win by one, it's a victory, if you win by two, it's a landslide, so we're happy with the win."

Coghill, 38, of Beechview, a roofing contractor who runs his own business, previously lost to Motznik, 41, of Overbrook, in a special election four years ago to fill the unexpired term of former Councilman Michael Diven.

Motznik contended during the campaign that he helped revitalize the business district in Beechview, Brookline and Carrick, while Coghill claimed Motznik had not accomplished enough economic development in the neighborhoods.

Motznik will face Republican Bob Hillen in the general election. Hillen, 47, of Beechview, is the city's Republican chairman.

Advertise with us

District 4 includes Beechview, Bon Air, Brookline, Carrick and Overbrook.

District 8

While William Peduto was unsuccessful in his mayoral bid against fellow Democrat Bob O'Connor, he appeared to win the Democratic primary for a second term to his District 8 council seat. Peduto, 40, of Point Breeze, does not yet face a Republican challenger in the general election.

Peduto appeared to have a commanding lead over challenger lawyer Harlan Stone, 50, of Squirrel Hill. Stone, a 14th Ward committeeman, was endorsed by the city Democratic Party and also picked up the endorsements of many labor unions and the 14th Ward Independent Democratic Club.

District 8 includes Squirrel Hill, Shadyside, Point Breeze, Bloomfield, Friendship and North and West Oakland.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.