All of the Pittsburgh mayoral candidates at a debate in Oakland last night said eliminating property taxes is the best way to deal with assessment problems.

Five days out from Tuesday's primary, they also took swipes at Bob O'Connor, the best-known and funded candidate in the race.

Not one of the candidates at last night's session, which was broadcast on TV and radio, was about to touch the political kryptonite of property assessments. But all acknowledged it would take an act of the state Legislature to eliminate property taxes.

Asked by co-moderator Stacy Smith of KDKA and WQED-TV if they approved capping property value increases at 4 percent next year -- as proposed by County Chief Executive Dan Onorato -- all but Republican mayoral candidate Joe Weinroth said they agreed with Onorato, even though his plan was rejected yesterday by a county judge.

Advertise with us

City Councilman William Peduto said the state's property tax system, which funds public schools and local governments, is old-fashioned and has to be replaced.

"Pennsylvania will consistently fail and consistently fall behind until we modernize our tax structure," he said.

County Prothonotary Michael Lamb called on the state "to scrap the system."

O'Connor, former City Council president, said he was disappointed in Judge R. Stanton Wettick Jr.'s rejection of Onorato's proposed cap, saying Onorato "inherited a disaster."

Weinroth, the sole Republican nominee on Tuesday's ballot, said he could successfully lobby the Republican-controlled Legislature on tax reform. So did Democrat Louis "Hop" Kendrick, saying he is a former Republican whom legislators would respect.

Advertise with us

Democrat Les Ludwig also was at the forum, which was hosted by WQED-TV and simulcast on KQV Radio.

Co-moderator Chris Moore of WQED-TV urged the candidates to "take the gloves off" at the beginning of the hourlong debate, but no one did.

Later, Moore noted that the Teamsters union contributed to O'Connor's campaign and asked the former councilman how he "would deal" with unions while in office. O'Connor replied that business interests gave his campaign money, too, and he would cooperate with both sides, but that he had not made "one commitment" to anyone.

Lamb criticized O'Connor for taking money from possible gaming interests. Peduto noted that he tried to push campaign finance reform in City Council but was rebuffed.

Going back to Moore's question, Peduto promised to press for further cuts when the current firefighters union contract is reopened in 2007 and asked O'Connor if he would do the same. O'Connor did not answer directly, saying he is "committed" to fixing the city's problems.

Advertise with us

Kendrick was critical of O'Connor for campaigning on a recent Sunday at Kendrick's church, saying that was "sacrilegious and disrespectful."

Correction/Clarification: (Published May 14, 2005) Republican mayoral candidate Joe Weinroth supports eliminating property taxes, but not the effort by Allegheny County Chief Executive Dan Onorato, a Democrat, to cap property tax increases next year at 4 percent, as was indicated in the version of this story published May 13, 2005 about a mayoral debate.