WEST CHESTER, Pa. -- Control of the state House will remain up in the air for at least another week, and maybe two.
Elections officials in Chester County have yet to count 549 absentee ballots in two key House races that are too close to call.
They say they won't start counting until they have determined the eligibility of 88 voters who cast provisional ballots because their names could not be found on registration lists on Election Day.
So far, Republicans lead in both races, and if those results hold, the GOP would have a 102-101 majority in the coming session.
Meanwhile, back in Harrisburg, loyalists in both parties reportedly are trying to woo moderates from the opposing side to achieve a majority that way.
"There have always been those kinds of discussions and there will always be," said Al Bowman, spokesman for the House Republican Campaign Committee.
This year those talks are likely to be more intense because the majority could be decided by just one seat. Added to the equation are an unusually high number of freshmen legislators, who may be more susceptible to pressure to switch.
For now, though, all eyes are on Chester County, where election workers spent the last two days comparing names on provisional ballots to the voter registration list. Meanwhile, in the lobby of the county government building, gaggles of attorneys and House staffers from both parties double-checked their work and issued 28 challenges in the two days.
The three county commissioners, acting as the Board of Elections, are expected to hear arguments on those challenges Tuesday. Absentee and provisional ballots will not be counted until rulings have been made on the challenges, commissioners said.
Elections employees have validated 20 of 38 provisional ballots in the 156th District, in which Republican Shannon Royer had a 19-vote lead over Democrat Barbara McIlvaine Smith based on unofficial totals of 23,018 non-provisional ballots cast on Election Day.
Democrats and Republicans both are disputing election employees' determinations in that race. Republicans say only 12 provisional ballots should count while Democrats say 31 should.
Meanwhile, Republicans agree with election workers' determination that 18 of 50 provisional ballots are valid in the 167th District but Democrats say 38 of those ballots should be counted. There, Republican Duane Milne leads Democrat Anne Crowley by 136 votes, according to an unofficial count of the 26,545 ballots cast on Election Day.
In races this tight, provisional ballots could be a deciding factor, attorneys for both sides said.
"This case highlights the value of every vote. There are 101 Democrats in the House, 100 Republicans and two undecided races, one with a margin of 19 votes," said Pittsburgh attorney Cliff Levine, who represents the Democrats.
Republicans want to exclude ballots that weren't filled out completely or that weren't signed in the proper place and, in some cases, not signed at all. In one case, a voter didn't provide her birth date on the form; in another, a poll worker failed to sign the form.
"It's a technicality, but that's what the law says. If you don't sign it and if you don't provide the information, how do we know it's really you?" said Lawrence J. Tabas, attorney for the Republicans.
"There's a law, and the law says you have to do X, Y and Z. If you don't do it, it doesn't count. It's a technicality, but that's what the law says."
Democrats have a different view.
"We believe everybody who tried to cast a ballot legitimately should have their votes counted," said House Democratic spokesman Bill Patton.
"There are cases where it was the election official, not the voter, that didn't sign properly. There are cases where a voter says they changed their address through motor voter (a voter registration service offered at the Department of Motor Vehicles) but the county says it didn't get notification," he said. "That's not the voter's fault."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.