The springtime political earthquake that shook loose two Republican leaders, Senate President Pro Tempore Robert Jubelirer and Majority Leader David Brightbill, and toppled 15 other incumbents delivered its aftershocks on Tuesday to two of Western Pennsylvania's most powerful Democrats.
Related article
Veon's defeat shocks Democratic leaders
Minority Whip Mike Veon lost in an upset to newcomer Jim Marshall, while Minority Leader Bill DeWeese survived an Election Day scare.
And the fault lines, observers say, can be traced all the way back to July 7, 2005, straight into the Capitol, where the General Assembly voted to increase its own pay by a minimum of 16 percent, with thousands more for party and committee leaders. With a couple of races yet to be decided, it could prevent the Democrats from grabbing the majority in the House.
The pay hikes -- which would have lifted salaries for legislators, state executive branch officials and judges -- are more than 16 months in the rear view mirror, and it's been a year since the Legislature wised up and repealed the measure. The pay raise was thought to have spent its galvanizing power after ousting Democratic Supreme Court Justice Russell Nigro last November, then bouncing Messrs. Jubelirer and Brightbill this May.
Mr. Veon and Mr. DeWeese, initially, were the only two legislators in either chamber who refused to vote in favor of the repeal. Mr. DeWeese eventually relented, but Mr. Veon never did.
"I never really thought about voting any other way," he said earlier this year. Neither Mr. Veon nor Mr. DeWeese could be reached yesterday.
If the issue had disappeared from the headlines, perhaps the passage of time might have eased the sting many voters felt over the pay raise. Or perhaps the anger was boiling under the surface, invisible beneath the Iraq war and other issues.
Either way, the state Supreme Court's decision to reinstate judicial pay raises in September brought the issue to the forefront once again and was a front-page reminder to voters of what had transpired 14 months earlier.
"This is obviously residual from the pay raise," said G. Terry Madonna, director of the Center for Politics and Public Affairs at Franklin and Marshall College. "There were a number of Democrats who voted against him in the primary and still didn't come back. Across the state, the pay raise has gone away, but district by district it was still a problem.
"The irony would be if the Democrats fall short of taking over the House by one seat, and it's his seat."
It appears that may end up being the case: The GOP is clinging to a one-vote, 102-101 majority in the state House. Two photo finishes in Chester County are leaning Republican, but will be examined by Democrats for the rest of the week -- one of the leads is just 19 votes. Had Mr. Veon only taken care of business in his own district, the House majority probably would have flipped to the Democrats, and he would have been in line to be majority leader.
And Mr. DeWeese may have returned to the speaker's chair, something he's coveted for years. He still might, if Democrats are able to eke out one more victory, or if Gov. Ed Rendell can convince a single Republican to switch sides.
Regardless, come January, Mr. DeWeese will be without his right-hand man, Mr. Veon, who is in charge of keeping House Democrats in line and bartering for tough votes.
Both of these long-tenured incumbents were considered locks, at least to outsiders who weren't privy to internal campaign polling. But faithful TV viewers probably could have sniffed out trouble for both candidates, considering how they were blanketing the television networks with advertising.
"That was the very first indication to me, the first network television commercial," said a weary Mr. Marshall. "To me, that said, 'I'm in trouble. I'm going to skip the whole cable thing, and go into network.' Obviously, he wouldn't be spending the money on that if he didn't think it was close."
It's a point that was missed even by the people who have beating the pay raise horse for a year.
"I thought Mike Veon's defeat was more amazing than Jubelirer's and Brightbill's," said Eric Epstein, self-appointed leader of the anti-raise, anti-incumbent movement, and founder of the Rock the Capital protest group.
"People went out of their way to target Mike Veon."
It seems so, after a review of Beaver County election returns.
In a county where Democrats outnumber Republicans, where voters summarily dispatched Republican U.S. Rep. Melissa Hart in favor of Democrat Jason Altmire (61-39 percent), where Democratic state Treasurer Bob Casey trounced Republican U.S. Sen. Rick Santorum (62-38), where Gov. Ed Rendell turned back Republican Lynn Swann (55-45), Mr. Veon managed to lose.
Mr. Epstein, along with most who viewed that race from afar, was surprised at how the anger over the pay raise sustained itself in a subterranean fashion. The climax of the anti-pay raise movement came in May, they'd thought, but Mr. Veon's defeat was a satisfying epilogue to the Legislature's biggest folly of 2005.
"Mike Veon was the band leader" of the crowd that organized and ratified the late-night pay raise, Mr. Epstein said. "People were tired of his tune ... Mike was totally unrepentant."
Mr. DeWeese won his race, but narrowly. Throughout Tuesday night, he and Republican competitor Greg Hopkins traded leads, with Mr. DeWeese finally able to declare victory before midnight. And that was without a major advertising investment from House Republicans, who swooped into the Veon race in the final hour to aid Mr. Marshall.
"If they had targeted Bill DeWeese, Bill DeWeese would have lost," said Mr. Jubelirer, contacted in his Altoona district office yesterday. "Bill told me that he was getting a lot of feedback as he was going door-to-door; doors slammed on him, people telling him they weren't going to vote for him. He got fair warning."
Even as it became entangled with larger issues this year, the pay raise hangover apparently caused lingering headaches in Mr. DeWeese's district, in Greene, Fayette and Washington counties.
Jeff Coleman, former Republican state legislator turned political consultant, helped GOP challengers defeat Mr. Jubelirer and Rep. Tom Stevenson, R-Mt. Lebanon, in the spring primary, largely riding the pay raise issue.
He said the evident staying power of the issue speaks to how voters are weary of Harrisburg representatives who ignore the mandate of their constituencies.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.