There are stark contrasts in the three contested races for state House seats fully or predominantly in the city of Pittsburgh.
One is a bare-knuckles battle between candidates from powerful political families. The second involves a traditional Democrat-Republican race with a long-term incumbent, and the third features a veteran who survived a close primary race and faces token opposition Nov. 7.
Voters Guide -- General Election 2006
22nd District
Incumbent Republican Michael Diven and Democratic challenger Chelsa Wagner have deep political roots in this district, which covers mostly South Hills neighborhoods. The question is whether Mr. Diven's roots will hold strong in new soil after he switched from the Democratic to the Republican Party last year following a squabble with party leaders.
Mr. Diven, 36, of Brookline, is the son of Joey Diven, a Democratic stalwart who worked for longtime Allegheny County Commissioner Tom Foerster. His son also worked for Mr. Foerster, then served on City Council before moving to the state House, where he's seeking his fourth term.
Mr. Diven had a falling out with House Democratic leaders H. William DeWeese, D-Waynesburg, and Mike Veon, D-Beaver Falls, after some Democrats who didn't always follow leadership's voting directions had their seats eliminated during reapportionment after the 2000 census. In response, they ran a candidate against Mr. Diven unsuccessfully in 2002 and cut his office staff.
When former state Sen. Jack Wagner -- Chelsa's uncle -- was elected auditor general, Mr. Diven switched parties to run for the Senate as a Republican last year. Despite heavy spending by the party, he lost to former county Councilman Wayne Fontana.
Now, Ms. Wagner is trying to make Mr. Diven's party affiliation a major issue in his bid for re-election. She said Mr. Diven votes 90 percent of the time with Republicans, putting him out of touch with voters in the heavily Democratic district, and is beholden to party leaders as a result of their heavy contributions to his campaigns.
Mr. Diven said he's been able to use his Republican affiliation to exert influence on GOP leaders, who have the majority in the House, to support projects for the district.
"People know I've been an independent voice and that's why they elected me," Mr. Diven said. "[GOP leaders] know if it's not Mike Diven in the 22nd District, it's going to be some Democrat ... and I use that to my advantage."
Turning the issue around, Mr. Diven questions whether Ms. Wagner would be in lockstep with Democrats because, in addition to her uncle, her father is Democratic ward leader Pete Wagner.
Ms. Wagner, 29, of Beechview, came back to Pittsburgh and went to law school after working for three years for a private firm that does consulting work with state and local governments. She helped officials implement programs in Ohio and Virginia and now wants to help change the way things have worked in Harrisburg.
"I want to be taken as my own candidate, not this family member or that family member," Ms. Wagner said. "I have the professional ability to work with any leaders on either side of the floor. You can agree or disagree, but you can do so civilly."
On specific issues, Mr. Diven wants to eliminate property taxes on a person's primary residence by raising the personal income tax slightly and increasing the sales tax by one percentage point to 7 percent -- 8 percent in Allegheny County. He supports finishing the Mon-Fayette Expressway, favors extending the light rail system to the North Hills rather than building tunnels to the North Shore and has co-sponsored a bill to shift $125 million in transportation funds to mass transit.
Ms. Wagner favors shifting away from property taxes in favor of sales and income taxes, but she doesn't have a specific proposal. She would rather improve the West End Circle and the Route 51-88 intersection than build the Mon-Fayette Expressway, would only build the transit tunnels to the North Shore so the federal money wouldn't be given to another area and supports dedicated funding for mass transit but doesn't have a specific proposal.
20th District
Republican challenger Bill Stalter is trying to use incumbent Democrat Don Walko's experience against him.
Mr. Stalter, 55, of Reserve, said Mr. Walko has been unable during six terms in Harrisburg to enact property tax reform and deal with other major issues.
He wants to be part of a reform movement expected to sweep into office as a result of 30 retirements and 17 incumbents losing in the primary.
Mr. Stalter, president of East Coast Lumber Co. for 14 years, said he's gotten an earful during the campaign from residents concerned about last year's pay raises and their ability to pay property taxes. He's running under the banner of PACleanSweep, an organization formed after the pay raises with a goal of defeating all incumbents.
He favors replacing property taxes through an increase in the income tax and an expanded sales tax, which would include legal and accounting services and perhaps food and clothing. He supports a maximum of two four-year terms.
Mr. Walko, 53, of the North Side, is against term limits because he believes that would dilute the expertise of legislators.
After decades of frustration, Mr. Walko said he believes Democrats are willing to push for tax reform if they gain control of the House. To eliminate property taxes, he supports expanding the sales tax without taxing food and clothing.
Although there have been no debates and few joint appearances, Mr. Walko said he's not taking his re-election for granted.
"I'm still running like my coat's on fire," he said.
Constitutional Party candidate Jim Barr, 53, of West View, also is on the ballot.
The district includes part of the North Side, Lawrenceville and the Strip District, as well as Reserve, West View and part of Ross.
24th District
Incumbent Democrat Joseph Preston Jr., 58, of East Liberty, survived a tight primary in his bid for a 13th term. The district includes neighborhoods in the East End of the city, as well as Aspinwall and Wilkinsburg.
No Republicans ran for the seat. His opponent is Todd Elliott Koger of Wilkinsburg, a longtime Democratic committeeman who is running as an independent.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.