During the remaining weeks of the campaign, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette will periodically review television advertisements in the race for governor, U.S. Senate and some seats in the U.S. House. Today, an ad from the governor's race.

THE CANDIDATES: Incumbent Democrat Gov. Ed Rendell and Republican challenger Lynn Swann.

THE TELEVISION AD: Called "Headlines," the ad was the first of the fall campaign and opens with a shot of Mr. Rendell making a speech and smiling, with other shots of him at a desk signing a bill and meeting with a group of voters.

The narrator says: "He's been one of the most pro-active governors in recent memory. He fought for and won a raise in the minimum wage, the first one in years.''

Advertise with us

Although Mr. Rendell complains about the news media from time to time, he shows no compunction about using newspaper headlines to bolster his claims. One headline reads, "Rendell signs $7.15 wage law to cheers,'' while another says, "Wage boost is good for workers.''

The narrator says: "His economic development plans are starting to pay off. The state's unemployment rate has been consistently better than the national average.'' Another headline talks about "job numbers'' being up.

The narrator talks about Mr. Rendell's "tough approach to budgeting,'' about how he's "cutting taxes" and boasting that the state budget "is balanced for the fourth year in a row.''

Then there are shots of children and teachers in classrooms, with the narrator talking about "increasing money to local school districts.''

The ad ends with another shot of a smiling Rendell at a podium, with the statement, "Ed Rendell -- moving Pennsylvania forward.''

Advertise with us

ANALYSIS: The claim about being one of the most pro-active governors is largely political hot air, since all new governors come into office with a list of things they'd like to get done.

As for the minimum wage, he does deserve some credit -- or blame, depending on your view -- for raising the state's minimum wage from $5.15 an hour to $7.15 an hour by next year. He led rallies at the state Capitol, met with workers around the state and urged them to call their legislators and encouraged Democrats in the Senate and House to press the GOP, which controls both chambers, to press for a vote.

As for the state's unemployment rate being less than the national average, Mr. Rendell is largely correct. According to federal labor statistics, Pennsylvania has been below the national jobless average for 30 months under Mr. Rendell and at or above it for 14 months (as of August). Five of those months at or above the national average have been recently, however, which Republicans call "a bad trend.''

Republicans also point out that his first six months in office, in 2003, the state was below the national average, which the GOP says resulted from policies under the previous Republican administration of Gov. Mark Schweiker.

Mr. Rendell's claim about balancing the state budget for four years in a row is meaningless because the state Constitution demands a balanced budget each year.

Advertise with us

Mr. Rendell did cut business taxes, but one main one, the capital stock and franchise tax, already was being phased out when he took office.

Mr. Rendell has increased tax credits for companies engaged in research and development.

The ad specifically does not talk about one of the most controversial moves of Mr. Rendell's first year -- increasing the personal income tax rate from 2.8 percent to 3.07 percent. He originally wanted to hike it to 3.75 percent but the Legislature wouldn't agree.

As for cutting spending, Mr. Rendell has trimmed about $1 billion over four years, in part by not filling several thousand state jobs, but the budget has still increased by more than 6 percent a year during his tenure, and now tops $26 billion.

Mr. Rendell does deserve credit for increasing spending for schools. He started a $200 million program for pre-kindergarten and all-day kindergarten (although he was forced to reduce it from his original goal of $650 million.)

He has also increased state funds for tutoring students in math and reading and this year will start a program to put laptop computers on the desks of all students grades 9 to 12 in four years.