HARRISBURG -- State Rep. Michael Diven, R-Brookline, got the most votes in the 22nd District House Republican primary, but it's not clear whether his name will be on the general election ballot in November.
That will be up to Senior Commonwealth Court Judge James R. Kelley.
Pittsburgh Republicans Anthony William Oliviero, Dennis Underwood and Katherine White were in court yesterday to ask for an injunction preventing Mr. Diven from running in the general election.
They claim Mr. Diven circumvented state election laws by running as a write-in candidate after he withdrew from the race to avoid testifying in a separate court case over whether his nominating petitions contained forged signatures, including names of dead people.
Mr. Diven's campaign treasurer and chief of staff, Debora Romaniello, 51, of Brookline, was arrested last Friday in connection with the allegedly fraudulent signatures.
"Had [Mr. Diven] been confident that there was not this level of fraud, he would have gone forward for vindication" in the initial court case, said the claimants' attorney, Charles Fedel of Pittsburgh.
Instead, Mr. Diven withdrew his petitions on March 28, prompting Commonwealth Court to cancel a March 29 hearing on whether enough valid signatures remained to keep him on the primary ballot.
Mr. Diven's withdrawal should have precluded him from continuing to participate in the election cycle, Mr. Fedel argued in court yesterday.
Instead, with no other Republicans on the primary ballot, Mr. Diven kept campaigning and received 1,444 write-in votes, enough for a spot on the general election ballot.
His actions were proper and legal, said L. Lawrence Boyle, attorney for Secretary of State Pedro Cortes, who also was named in the complaint.
Mr. Diven's attorney, Michael P. O'Day of Pittsburgh, agreed.
"He made a politically savvy decision which actually required a lot of work on his part to win as a write-in candidate," Mr. O'Day said.
Mr. Fedel said the court should consider that motivation in rendering its decision.
Mr. Diven withdrew the nominating petitions "based on the tacit admission or knowledge that a fraud had been committed, not a decision to not participate in the electoral process. To the contrary, his decision was to manipulate the judicial process so he could conceivably retain his ability to participate in the electoral process," Mr. Fedel said in a court brief.
"One who manipulatively chooses not to answer well-founded allegations of fraud from his constituents should not be granted a second bite at the apple," he wrote.
Now it's up to Judge Kelley to decide whether Mr. Diven will face Chelsa Wagner, winner of the Democratic primary, in November.
It is unclear when a ruling will be issued.
"It's a unique case. I don't know of any case like it," Judge Kelley said. "It's an important case [that will] provide guidance for the future."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.