Skeptic:
We know that incumbents were ousted who backed the pay raise. Can you put this in historical perspective? That is, utilize your "Stats Geek" expertise to explain whether the number of incumbents turned out was: (1) earth-shaking, (2) somewhere in the range of routine, or (3) somewhere between the two? And yes, I realize this was just the primary -- some incumbents who survived the first round still may get tossed.
Brian O'Neill: I wouldn't call it earth-shaking, as the Democratic leaders survived even as the Republican leaders were turned out, but this is highly unusual turnover for Pennsylvania. Along with 27 lawmakers who retired, 13 more lost yesterday, so that's about 16 percent turnover. Not bad when the norm in recent years (excluding retirements) has been about 2 percent in the House. As you suggest, there will be more races in November, too, so it's possible about one-fifth of the faces in the General Assembly in January will be new ones I believe you'd have to go back to 1978 to find such an overhaul. And I heard Lisa Bennington, a new rep from Morningside, say on the radio this morning that she is the first Democratic woman to go the House from western Pa. since 1975.
Steve_Gruber: In today's PG, it was reported that: "Among those who survived the purge were Marc Gergely, D-White Oak; David Levdansky, D-Forward; Joseph Markosek, D-Monroeville; Don Walko, D-North Side; and Tom Petrone, D-Crafton Heights." Brian, why did any incumbents survive, and what can we do to ensure they lose in the general election? The obvious answer is for me to "vote against them." but obviously I can only vote in my local election. How can I find out who is going to challenge these survivors in the general election, and where do I send a check to support the campaigns of those challengers? Of those who survived, do you know if any of them expect little or no opposition from a republican candidate, because of the demographics of their area? For instance, could Jay Paisley seek to run against Minority Whip Mike Veon as a republican candidate in the general election? Or are the Republicans already planning to run their own candidate, and if so, who?
Brian O'Neill: I can't answer all your questions, but I'll answer the ones I can. Some of these guys won because they're nice guys, they've returned money to their districts, and that's enough for some people. A couple, such as Walko and Petrone, were helped because their challengers split the vote and they won with a minority of the votes cast. I expect some close races in November, but some of them involved two new faces (i.e. the races in the Shaler and Mt. Lebanon-based districts.). Rep. Dermody, a Democrat from Oakmont, also should have quite a race against Republican Eileen Watt. I'd imagine Operation Clean Sweep would have some more detailed information on where some of the races will be. The House Speaker Perzel should have a significant challenge from a Democratic challenger in Philadelphia.
AndrewKefer: For the first time in many years, I am proud to be a Pennsylvania Voter. Do you think its possible that this will begin a period of great reform in Harrisburg?
Brian O'Neill: I think it's possible we'll see some changes, but I don't want to get my hopes too high. We have a long way to go before we have enough people who are for shrinking the size of the Legislature or imposing term limits, for instance.
Atuschak: Isn't it disappointing that Democratic voters were so much less willing to hold the officials accountable? With a few notable exceptions, this was mostly an exercise of Republicans sending a message to their party.
Brian O'Neill: You might amend that to say "central Pennsylvania Republicans'' sent the message. Most of the Republicans here, apart from Stevenson in Mt. Lebanon, returned without opposition, though that was likely because most of the returnees either voted against the raise or, at the least, never took it. I don't have the stats at my fingertips. I am somewhat disappointed there wasn't more of a shakeup on the Democratic side, though, yes.
Don: How many of the incumbents got voted out? What about the mainstays, Veon and Lagrotta?
Brian O'Neill: Thirteen got voted out at last count, in addition to the 27 who retired. A few more should go down in November, though Pennsylvania districts are mostly favored to lock in one party or the other. Veon used copious amounts of money to finance a winning campaign. LaGrotta lost narrowly, by less than 30 votes.
Skeptic: Catherine Baker Knoll, who will turn 76 this year and has referred to the Governor as "Edward G. Robinson" easily won the nomination without real opposition. Could she become a major issue for Rendell? After all, she is just one cheese-steak away from being Governor. Will Rendell's association with the pay raise become an issue for him?
Brian O'Neill: I think Rendell can distance himself from the pay raise and the race with Swann will be more about property taxes, casinos, the minimum wage and whether anyone should care how well one catches a football. That's how it should be. As for Mrs. Knoll, she's a wonder. I voted for Gene Stilp because he promised to put the lieutenant governor's mansion on E-bay, but evidently that wasn't enough for most voters.
Pittnh: How could people vote for Veon? He was the ringleader of the pay raise and never apologized? Can we ever get this guy out?
Brian O'Neill: I can't answer for why people voted for Veon, but he seems to be in there to stay. He spent scads of money and made it seem like the challenger was the incumbent. The only way to get Veon out of his leadership position, I guess, is to vote out several dozen Democratic lawmakers who vote to keep him whip.
jeda41: I am appalled at the low turnout yesterday, what do you think happened?
Brian O'Neill: I think no candidates for American Idol were on the ballot. Most people just don't care enough, or know enough, about this stuff. MadVoter: What will our next move be in November?
Brian O'Neill: I hate to be put in the position of giving marching orders. That's not what democracy should be about. I will say this, though. Get on the phone with your new or old rep, congratulate him (or her) on his (or her) victory, and then say what you expect. Do you want term limits? A raise in the minimum wage? No raise in the minimum wage? Whatever it is, say so. These people should be properly chastened and humbled by what they had to do to get this far.
Skeptic: With former Justice Byron White, candidate Lynn Swann and Judge Dwayne Woodruff paving the way for him, why not Joey Porter in public office? Wouldn't he be more interesting than what we have now?
Brian O'Neill: Joey would be very interested indeed. He's already backpedaling like a scared politician on his Bush comments, if you check our Web page.
Steve_Gruber: Veon made the challenger seem like the incumbent? That is both hilarious, ingenious, and absolutely turns my stomach, all at the same time. Can you provide a link, or a reference, to somewhere I could see that for myself. I'm already Googling "Veon" in a separate window.
Brian O'Neill: I got an e-mail from Veon, and I saw one of his commercials, which just had a bunch of regular people saying, essentially, "I don't trust Jay Paisley.'' Who these people were was never said, but it got Paisley's name out there, and not in a good way.
Putz: What's wrong with the voter's in the 14th leg. district? I live there and I'm ashamed that Veon was won. I voted for paisley as did my friends and family. But how do you overcome stupidity and 500,000 dollars?
Brian O'Neill: The dignity is in the struggle, I'm told. I trust you woke up today with yours intact. Take solace in that.
AndrewKefer: I am writing from the Philadelphia Area. The Phil. Inquirer has reported recently about spending habits of one of our esteemed representatives (Mark Cohen). Can you explain not only how this guy get re-elected term after term, but how he actually can run unopposed? Is it voter apathy? I don't understand!
Brian O'Neill: It's voter apathy. What you have to do, if you live in his district, is either run, or get someone you respect to run. There's still time to file as independent, I believe. If the lawmakers believe they can't lose, we will.
Lucabrasi: Why do you think this 'reform movement' had more impact in Western and Central PA than in the East (other than Brightbill)?
Brian O'Neill: I can only guess, but some arch-conservatives backed the challengers out there, and they had less reason to do so out here against the Republicans.
Hawkeye: Do you see a backlash at Republicans coming in November, both on the state and national level?
Brian O'Neill: I'm not very good at sensing the national will. I thought "Arrested Development'' was a good show, but the rest of America voted no. Seriously, I expect there to be good strong races in November. If we don't have them this year with all the issues on the table, God help us all.
Skeptic: One of the real challenges, in my opinion, is to reduce the size of the legislature. Can you tell us what needs to be done, from a legal perspective, for that to happen?
Brian O'Neill: Good question. Shrinking the Legislature is a difficult process, as it would require a constitutional change. That means two consecutive sessions of the Legislature must approve a reduction in size of what is now America's Largest and Most Expensive Full-Time State Legislature. If that happens, the measure goes to voters in a referendum, where I think it would pass easily. At least a few successful challengers -- Bill Kortz of West Mifflin comes to mind -- are in favor of reducing the size of the Legislature and saving perhaps $100 million yearly. But he will need a lot of help.
Atuschak: Do you know where I can find stats on the write-in votes? I'm a big fan of the write-in because I think it sends my party a message & shows that I'm not happy with their decision. I was outside of a poll yesterday for a candidate & was told by many voters that they chose to write-in against Santorum, Hart, Knoll, Rendell, etc. I'd like to see the numbers.
Brian O'Neill: I'm a write-in fan myself. My state rep and state senator had no challengers, and I wound up voting in someone I knew for both offices, as I did for the state committee. It felt good. I'll try to get that number from the county Elections Division. You might try to do the same.
Lucabrasi: Do you think the anger that the Republican Voters showed yesterday is more due to the pay raise? Or do you think there is this more because of some of the apparent problems the President is having within his own national party?
Brian O'Neill: I don't think it had anything to do with Bush. If anything, the challengers are more conservative than the centrists they're replacing. This was about getting the architects of the pay raise.
jeda41: I know that my "rep" stated that he was in Harrisburg for 11 straight days, now why was he there when there was no voting on the budget, was it to collect the $140 per diem? Talk about money grubbing! By the way, he won.
Brian O'Neill: There's always November. If you see an independent with a petition, sign it.
Norm: I am frustrated by the small number of incumbents that were ousted. In several cases, they received fewer than 50% of the vote, but since multiple candidates opposed then, they were re-elected anyway. These opponents lost sight of the goal and allowed their own ambitions for political office to split to opposition vote. I am sure the incumbents were pleased when multiple candidates filed.
Brian O'Neill: I'm sure incumbents preferred facing multiple challengers, too, but as my dear old daddy used to tell me, dem's da breaks. I know of one challenger who wanted another to step aside and I asked , why should she? Everyone who runs for office puts his or her name on the line in the belief that a difference can be made. I find it hard to fault anyone for getting out there and trying, no matter what the result may be.
Exiledinva: One can obtain the number of write-ins for each office for Allegheny County at this site: http://www.county.allegheny.pa.us/elect/el45.htm
Brian O'Neill: This is great information for everyone. Thank you so much.
Atuschak: I suggest an organized effort to circulate petitions demanding a reduction in the size of the legislature. If we start a petition with very specific demands for action based on an existing reduction plan (for instance, use Kortz's), voters in each district could make it a focal point to the candidates. The issue would demand attention during campaign season & the petitions could be delivered to Harrisburg en masse. Do you think this could have an effect, similar to the Cleansweep efforts?
Brian O'Neill: I think it could have an effect. Personally, I don't like Kortz's plan. It's too simplistic. When we last spoke, he suggested one representative for each county, which would mean a massive shift in power from the city and suburbs to rural areas. I like sheep, if properly cooked, but I don't think they should have as much representation as people. Call me prejudiced. Cutting the House in half, from 203 to 101 members, and the Senate from 50 to 40, would be enough for me.
Skeptic: You are closely associated with the publicity in Western Pennsylvania to hold legislators accountable for the pay grab. They've given themselves pay raises in the past and it has gone little noticed, why was this time different?
Brian O'Neill: I'm not sure why this time was different, but it absolutely was. The move was brazen, coming without public debate or public hearing and in clear contradiction of our state constitution which prohibits mid-term pay raises. I think the public grasped the pay grab on a very basic level, and the timing actually worked against the legislators. I think they did it on the last day before recessing for the summer in the belief that people would forget about it, but it actually gave people the time to mobilize and run for office. Almost a year later, some lawmakers are reaping what they have sown.
Politicallyangry: Did the polls stay open in Beaver County an extra hour? If so, how much did this help Veon?
Brian O'Neill: I don't know the answer to that, but Veon won pretty easily. It wasn't all that close.
Hello: That only gives you the number of write in votes. It doesn't tell who the votes were for. How can you find out who the votes were for? Mustico in Moon wanted a write in for Democrat for himself because Uhric was trying a write-in for democratic spot.
Brian O'Neill: Thanks for the update. I guess someone will have to make a phone call. I don't have the Elections Bureau phone number. Marcassha: As a poorly paid former legislative staffer who worked for 6 and a half years in the PA House, I found Veon's arrogant statement that he "deserved" the pay raise to be particularly galling. As a member of leadership, he's paid better than rank-and-file members, and also gets per diem, housing allowance, vehicle leasing and of course -- access to the legislative slush fund.
Brian O'Neill: I don't think I can improve on that statement.
Voltaire: The Porter story That brings up an important subject: What would President Bush's nickname be if he and P. Jeezy exchange pleasantries? Dub Baddee? Maybe politicians have to include a handle to run...
Brian O'Neill: Now we're getting into the issues people really care about.
Nitromasta: Everybody seems to talk about Altmire, but what do you think about Kluko and Irey? Do they have a chance?
Brian O'Neill: I have no idea.
MadVoter: Wouldn't you think those people are on Veon's payroll?
Brian O'Neill: I can only hope so.
Ol_Froth: I know I'm late to the party, but I'm disappointed that only 10 incumbents were fired yesterday
Brian O'Neill: I think the number is up to 13 in the two Houses. It's a start.
Ol_Froth: I think a crowded ballot in some races lead to some incumbents hanging on...looks like Walko and Petrone would have lost if not for a split opposition
Brian O'Neill: I think that's true.
Brian O'Neill: Thanks to everyone for coming. I have to write my post-election column now. Look for it in tomorrow's PG, if you would. Sincerely, Brian O'Neill




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.