State Rep. Frank Dermody, D-Oakmont, will not face a primary election challenge in the 33rd state House District after a Commonwealth Court judge ruled that his Democratic opponent had not collected the 300 valid signatures he needed on his nominating petitions.

Following a hearing Wednesday, Judge Dan Pellegrini found that petitions circulated on behalf of Jeff Hammer, an energy consultant from Indiana Township, contained only 265 valid signatures. The judge threw out 254 of the 519 names on Mr. Hammer's petitions. Mr. Hammer said he did not plan to appeal.

While Mr. Dermody, D-Oakmont, will not have an opponent in the May 16 primary, he is expected to face Eileen Watt, of Cheswick, who is unopposed for the Republican nomination, in November. Mrs. Watt was the upset winner in a 2003 race for County Council, defeating then-Council President Rick Schwartz in the race for the District 7 seat, representing the Allegheny Valley.