HARRISBURG -- The race to get on the May primary ballot is turning into a roller derby with candidates maneuvering in court to throw competitors off the ballot.
More election news
State poll shows low ratings on incumbents' work
Santorum's only GOP challenger bowing out of primary
Eighty-one Commonwealth Court challenges have been filed seeking to have candidates disqualified, claiming invalid petition signatures, incomplete forms, failure to meet residency requirements and, in one case, contending that a candidate's criminal record bars him from running.
"This is without precedent," said G. Terry Madonna, head of the Keystone Poll at Franklin & Marshall College. "You've got party people challenging non-endorsed people, you've got incumbents going against challengers, you've got organizations filing suits. It's chaotic. It's wild."
The challenges are part of the continuing fallout from the pay raises lawmakers gave themselves last summer and later repealed because of voter outrage, he said.
"The pay hike has created extraordinary political instability and everybody is trying to clear the decks," he said.
In all, 591 people are running for 203 state House seats and 25 state Senate seats.
One House candidate, Michael Cavanagh of Uniontown, sees the court challenges as cowardly attempts to gain political advantage and take choices away from voters. Mr. Cavanagh is one of 12 candidates from southwestern Pennsylvania whose candidacy has been challenged.
Mr. Cavanagh's candidacy is under attack because he was convicted of insurance fraud in 2004. The state constitution prohibits people from holding office if they've been convicted of "embezzling public money, bribery, perjury or other infamous crimes."
Mr. Cavanagh, whose case is on appeal, said he is innocent and that, in any case, insurance fraud isn't "infamous."
Most of the other filings challenge signatures, residency and paperwork. Candidates must collect 300 signatures from party members in their district and must live in the district for one year before the election.
Rep. Michael Diven, R-Brookline, is being challenged because six of the 614 signatures on his petition allegedly belong to dead people. Campaign worker Debora Romaniello collected the six signatures and three Pittsburghers who filed the court challenge say all 183 signatures she gathered should be disqualified.
Mr. Diven said someone signed the deceased people's names without Ms. Romaniello's knowledge.
"The people associated with me are people who would not intentionally or willfully disrespect the law or do something like this," he said.
Republican candidate Bob Hillen, who is running for the seat now held by Mr. Diven, collected just 324 signatures. Ken Heiss and Jane E. McMullen, both of Pittsburgh, challenged Mr. Hillen's petitions, saying 68 of the signatures "appear to be forged, false or illegible."
Nine other local candidates face challenges.
Democrat Brian Blasko, who is running against incumbent Rep. James Casorio Jr. of Irwin, is being challenged by three North Huntington residents, Dominic Laverde, Timothy Eichelberger and Marilyn J. Mogush. They say some signatures are invalid and that Mr. Blasko doesn't meet the one-year residency requirement.
The nomination of Mike Galovich, a Democrat running against incumbent Rep. Tom Petrone of Crafton Heights, is being challenged by Daniel E. Cindric, who claims some people who signed Mr. Galovich's petition are not registered voters, don't live in the district or used nicknames instead of their legal names when signing.
Mr. Galovich filed a challenge against another opponent, Democrat Michael J. Crossey, alleging that Mr. Crossey does not live in the 27th District. Mr. Crossey, a former Allegheny County councilman from Mt. Lebanon, has said he moved to Dormont a year ago.
The candidacy of Republican Bill Bates of Upper St. Clair, who is running against incumbent Rep. John Maher, is being challenged by Alberta Mercer of Peters, who alleges that Mr. Bates failed to disclose he is part-owner of a refractory in Alabama or that he is an officer at Milbro Refractories in McMurray. Mr. Bates said he does not own a refractory and that he is Milbro's director of operations, not a company officer.
Three Westmoreland County residents are challenging New Kensington Democrat Rob Fusia because he did not use the name "Robert L. Fusia," the name on his voter registration card. Mr. Fusia is running for the House seat held by John Pallone of New Kensington.
Seventy-two signatures on the petition of Democrat Robert E. Rhoderick Jr. of Elizabeth, who is running against incumbent Rep. Dave Levdansky, are being challenged.
Democrat Bill Robinson, who is challenging Rep. Jake Wheatley, D-Hill District, alleged that some signatures were not from Democrats and others "strongly appear written by the same person."
George F. Matta II, a White Oak Democrat running against incumbent Rep. Marc Gergely, is accused of failing to disclose that he owns and collects rental income from a townhouse in Seven Springs.
The candidacy of Indiana Township Democrat Jeff Hammer, who is running against incumbent Rep. Frank Dermody of Oakmont, is challenged based on allegations he failed to complete information about his occupation on two signature pages on his petition.
Correction/Clarification: (Published Mar. 18, 2006) State House candidate Bob Hillen, of Pittsburgh, collected 324 signatures on petitions for the May primary. This story as originally published on Mar. 16, 2006 reported an incorrect number of signatures.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.