The success of the oust-all-incumbents campaign in defeating Supreme Court Justice Russell M. Nigro's bid for retention and the continuing fallout from the legislative pay raise debacle have thrown a huge monkey wrench into next year's elections for state House and Senate.
Western Pa. House, Senate seats up for election in 2006
Check out our list of Western Pennsylvania seats in the state House and Senate that are up for election next year and candidates who have announced their intention to run.
The list includes the current officeholder and any announced challengers. New candidates should send announcements to localnews@post-gazette.com. The list will be updated weekly.
Although petitions can't be circulated until early next year and aren't due until March, PACleansweep says it has 52 candidates who have committed to run against incumbents, including 36 who plan to run in the primary. Many others not affiliated with the organization also have announced their intention to run next year.
In normal times, Pennsylvania voters routinely return upward of 90 percent of incumbent legislators to Harrisburg, most without opposition in the primary and many with token opposition in the fall. That allows Republicans and Democrats to concentrate their resources on a few targeted races across the state where they think a particular incumbent is vulnerable.
But that won't be the case in 2006, when 25 of 50 state senators and all 203 state representatives stand for re-election.
"Clearly, there will be fewer uncontested races, maybe, than ever before," said T.J. Rooney, Pennsylvania Democratic Party chairman and a state representative from Bethlehem, Northampton County. "We're going to have to play defense in places where we didn't think we'd have to play defense."
After its unexpected success in knocking off Justice Nigro -- the first time a state appellate court judge lost a retention election -- PACleansweep has been inundated with people wanting to run for office. The nonpartisan group was organized after the July 7 pay raise vote by Russ Diamond -- a compact disc and DVD manufacturer from Lebanon -- with the express purpose of defeating all incumbents.
"We've been absolutely slammed [since the election]," Mr. Diamond said. "It's amazing the number of people who have come forward."
Mr. Diamond said he was surprised the public outcry over the pay raises resulted in Justice Nigro's defeat since the organization spent less than $250 on its "vote no" campaign.
"In all my years, I've never seen the anger at this level," said veteran political analyst Bill Green, of Green and Associates, Downtown.
The key question is whether that momentum will be sustained. The vote against Justice Nigro is seen as a referendum on the pay raises, not a vote on his judicial record.
Since the Legislature repealed the pay raises last week, will the outrage remain through the May primary?
"I've been wrong so often since July 7, I'm turning in my political analyst badge and going back to analyst school," said Mr. Green.
Mike Long, an aide to Senate President Pro Tem Robert Jubelirer, R-Altoona, said it is way too early to say whether other incumbents will face defeat due to the pay raises. Mr. Jubelirer, who has been in office for 30 years, will be challenged in the primary by Blair County Commissioner John Eichelberger.
"The one thing I'm sure of is that it's very hard to predict what the political climate is going to be six months from now," said Mr. Long, who oversees Senate elections for Mr. Jubelirer. Last year, for example, few gave the party much chance of defeating longtime state Sen. Allen Kukovich, D-Manor, but challenger Bob Regola pulled out a victory.
In addition to repealing the raises, Republicans and Democrats said it will be important before the primary for the Legislature to show it is busy dealing with important issues such as property tax reform. That's why, within an hour after the repeal, the Senate began discussing a tax reform plan that could face a special referendum vote in March.
"I think it's absolutely vital to have an aggressive agenda doing important work for the people," Mr. Long said. "If we do that, I believe voters will factor that into these political races. Voters are people and people are forgiving."
State Rep. Dan Frankel, D-Squirrel Hill, who oversees House elections for the Democratic caucus, said legislators have to do more than make it look like they're busy.
"I think people want to see progress, but I don't think they want to see bad public policy just to get something done," he said.
Both parties also agree that contested races -- especially in the primary -- will drain resources. In the past, for example, Mr. Jubelirer and others with no opposition would contribute campaign funds to their brethren in the contested races. A lot of that money won't be available next year.
On top of that, Democratic Gov. Ed Rendell and Republican U.S. Sen. Rick Santorum also face strong challenges, which will cost their campaigns millions of dollars.
"There is going to be a lot more money involved than maybe ever before," Mr. Rooney said. "I don't want anybody to think we're going to concede any seat anywhere. We'll be supportive of incumbents."
Mr. Frankel said he expects the party to have the resources it needs to try to take down Republicans in targeted areas, especially in suburban Philadelphia. PACleansweep candidates may have a difficult time winning, he said, if they run only on the pay-raise issue and don't offer a full vision for the state.
"My experience in politics tells me it is very difficult to run a campaign around a single issue," Mr. Frankel said. "At the end of the day, do voters judge legislators on one vote or will they take into account their whole career?"
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.