For decades, the Democratic nomination in the 42nd state Senate District has been a sure ticket to Harrisburg.

Party registration in the South Hills district favors Democrats by a margin of more than 2-to-1. The district, like all legislative seats dominated by city of Pittsburgh voters, has long been beyond Republican grasp.

Anticipating a May 17 special election for the seat, recently vacated when Jack Wagner became state auditor general, Democratic committee members from the district yesterday voted to give the nomination to county Councilman Wayne Fontana.

But suddenly the seat is no sure thing for Democrats. The only thing that seems certain about the race is that it is likely to be the most expensive and one of the most closely watched legislative contests in Allegheny County history.

Advertise with us

That prospect emerged when state Rep. Michael Diven, who was elected as a Democrat, switched to the GOP in preparation for a run at the seat with the backing of the state Republican leadership. His move came as the Senate GOP caucus seized on Diven's long-standing feud with House Democratic leaders as a target of opportunity to expand their already strong hold on the chamber's majority.

With Republican backing, Diven said that he anticipates a campaign budget of $800,000 to $1 million. Senate Democratic leader Robert Mellow didn't promise to match GOP spending but said the Democratic caucus is prepared to do "whatever it takes to hold the seat.''

"I think the unity of the party is the road map to victory,'' Fontana said shortly after claiming his nomination over state Rep. Nick Kotik, D-Robinson, and two other candidates. "Obviously, we have to overcome someone who has unlimited funds, but I'm confident we'll do that.''

The special election could easily be the most expensive in memory for a legislative seat in Allegheny County. But the likely spending is in keeping with an arms race in campaign spending on Senate seats across the state in recent years. In Westmoreland County last year, Republicans found another former Democratic recruit, Bob Regola, to defeat veteran state Sen. Allen Kukovich, in a race where spending topped $1.5 million.

Spending in another special Senate election this spring is expected to easily surpass that figure. That election, for a Lehigh Valley seat opened by Republican Charles Dent's election to Congress, pits two Allentown legislators, Democrat Jennifer Mann and Republican Pat Browne. Some early projections suggest that spending for each of the candidates will near $1 million.

Advertise with us

Democrats insist they can hold on to the 42nd District without approaching that level of spending.

"We don't have to compete with him dollar-for-dollar,'' Fontana said. "I expect to do more of a grass roots campaign. I have a track record of working with people.''

Fontana maintained that a unified party will carry him on to victory, but the Democratic nominee will have to contend with the fact that a hefty percentage of the party's voters are already accustomed to voting for Diven, whose House district is wholly within the Senate district.

Pete Wagner, the 19th Ward chairman, insists that perceptions of Diven's strength are exaggerated.

"Everyone thinks he is so strong in his legislative district, but last year [in the Democratic primary] he only won 55 percent of the vote; so 45 percent of his own voters are against him,'' said Wagner, a Fontana ally.

Advertise with us

Republican strategists claim that their internal polling showed Diven with a lead in the race regardless of which Democratic name he was tested against. Fontana said he has seen data that showed that, while Diven started with an advantage in name recognition, his lead evaporated when voters surveyed were informed that he had switched to the GOP.

Still, any number of Democrats in the district will be coping with divided loyalties. Democratic city Councilman Jim Motznik, for example, whose district overlaps the Senate district, is a former aide to Diven.

Diven has long been a fractious force within the Democratic Party. He has had a prickly relationship with Wagner and his family, who are a sort of political dynasty in the South Hills.

Over the last few years he also has feuded with the leadership of the House Democratic caucus. The dysfunctional relationship with his Harrisburg leaders was a particular spur to Diven's decision to change parties. In last year's primary, the leadership, Reps. H. William DeWeese, D-Waynesburg, and Mike Veon, D-Beaver Falls, took the unusual step of funneling sizable contributions to Diven's opponent.

While Diven won easily, his leadership opponents have now achieved the goal of getting rid of a thorn in their caucus. Whether they're happy with the way that happened will depend on the results May 17.