The race to replace outgoing state Sen. Jack Wagner, who last month was elected to be Pennsylvania's next auditor general, is at the outset a two-horse affair between two Allegheny County officials, at least on the Democratic side.

Several Democratic insiders said Wayne Fontana, who sits on Allegheny County Council, and John Weinstein, the county treasurer, both have expressed interest in the seat.

"They're the two candidates who have indicated they are serious," Wagner said.

But Democrats won't pick a nominee until late January or February, and other potential candidates might emerge between now and then, including Pittsburgh city Councilman Jim Motznik. Following Thursday's council meeting, Motznik said that he's thinking about running for the party nomination, but hasn't made up his mind yet.

Advertise with us

No date has been selected for the special election. In a special election for an unexpired term, party nominees are selected by committees, not through a primary election. The winner would fill out the remainder of Wagner's four-year term -- he was elected in November 2002.

The 42nd Senate District is a heavily Democratic one, and a Democrat seems likely to retain that seat. However, if Weinstein is eventually selected as the Democrats' nominee, Republicans might be tempted to dump some money into the race.

That's because of Weinstein's alleged involvement with a voter-fraud scheme in 1997. A handwriting expert suggested that more than two dozen absentee ballots from the 1997 general election might have been completed by the same person -- Kennedy Township Treasurer Melvin Weinstein, John Weinstein's father.

The younger Weinstein, according to the same handwriting expert, might have forged five more ballots.

The Weinsteins called the accusations a "political lynching."

Advertise with us

The ballot case was eventually investigated by the FBI, and the charges, though never proven, may create a vulnerability, in the GOP's eyes. But that might not matter, said Tom Flaherty, Pittsburgh city controller and chairman of the Allegheny County Democratic Committee.

"I still think that district is so heavily in the Democratic registration column that whomever is nominated by the Democratic committee is the prohibitive favorite," he said. "Republicans can spend as much as they want."

Mike O'Connell, executive director of the Republican Committee of Allegheny County, naturally disagreed. "Weinstein is a crippled candidate from the beginning, and he's one that Democrats and Republicans alike will reject," he said.

Fontana, a real estate consultant, lives in the Brookline section of the city, and is council's vice president. He's already planning fund-raisers toward his goal of winning the seat.

Other names being floated in Democratic circles include Frank Gigliotti, son of the former state representative of the same name who resigned from the House in June 2000, and county Prothonotary Michael Lamb, considered a long shot because he's inclined to seek his party's nomination for the Pittsburgh mayoral race.

Advertise with us

Flaherty said he wouldn't count out current state House members, many of whom have a natural ambition to move to the Senate. "It's not every day a Senate seat comes open," he said.

Wagner's opinion will count as much as anyone's before the selection is made. He and the rest of the Democratic committee would prefer it if they could settle on a single nominee and convince the rest of the field to drop out, rather than put the matter to a potentially divisive committee vote, Flaherty said.

"That's desired," he said. "But sometimes people want to take their chance. Sometimes you do have a spirited race."

Though no date has been chosen for the special election, the election will probably be in the spring, and could coincide with the spring primary.

To date, the only Republican to publicly express interest in running for Wagner's Senate seat is David Jason, a Scott Township commissioner.