State Rep. Larry Roberts overcame a state grand jury investigation, a messy divorce, and a severe bout of hiccups over the last year to win re-election in the 51st District last night.

This report was written by staff writers Mark Belko, Karen Kane, Brian David, Len Barcousky, Dan Gigler, Bill Heltzel, Ann Belser, Mary Niederberger, Paula Reed Ward and Janice Crompton.<

The Uniontown legislator beat back challenges from four other candidates -- Republican Harry E. Albert III, a former Fayette County commissioner, and independents Timothy S. Mahoney, Gary Gearing and Terry Janosek -- to capture his seventh term.

Mahoney was considered Roberts' main challenger in the hard-fought race. He lost a write-in campaign to the incumbent in the spring primary after he was taken off the Democratic ballot for filing an incomplete financial disclosure form.

Advertise with us

Roberts was considered vulnerable because of controversies that popped up over the last year. He is under investigation by a state grand jury after being accused of paying candidate Michael A. Ciampanelli $200 to put his name on the Democratic primary ballot to siphon votes away from Mahoney. Roberts has scoffed at the allegation, calling Ciampanelli a "valid, legal candidate."

In June, Roberts also was accused by his ex-wife, Carol Roberts, of forging her signature on a $114,712 mortgage refinancing on their house. Roberts denied he did anything wrong, saying the allegation was the product of a "bitter divorce." In July, Larry Roberts ended up in the hospital for three weeks with a severe case of hiccups.

"I have a lot of good friends, a lot of good workers and a lot of people who believed in me and refused to believe the accusations that were made against me," Roberts said last night. "I had the A team working for me."

District 11

Butler County car dealer Brian Ellis outdistanced the competition in the three-way contest yesterday for the wide-open 11th District seat being vacated by retiring state Rep. Guy Travaglio of Butler.

Advertise with us

The Republican nominee, Ellis, 34, of Butler Township, is an owner of Hansen Auto in the Lyndora section of Butler Township.

With no incumbent seeking re-election, party leaders on both sides of the aisle were licking their chops over the 11th District race which encompasses a territory where voter registration is just about evenly split between the two major parties. The district covers the Butler County communities of Buffalo, Butler City, Butler Township, Chicora, Clearfield, Connoquenessing Township, Donegal, East Butler, Oakland, Summit and Winfield.

Ellis grabbed an early though slim lead, held it, then built on it as balloting progressed through the evening. Still, his key opponent, Democratic legislative aide Fred Vero, game him a run for his money, amassing about 40 percent of the vote.

Vero, 59, of Butler Township, has served as Travaglio's chief of staff since he took office in 1994 and he had worked in the same capacity for former state Rep. Joe Steighner until his retirement. In all, he has 18 years of service on the Harrisburg hill.

Third-party candidate, Mike Rock, 33, of Butler Township, trailed the major party candidates. A former Republican who changed his registration to the ultra-conservative Constitution party, Rock is employed in the marketing department of Sam's Club in Butler.

Advertise with us

Ellis credits "grass root support" for his success. "I'm honored to have the support of the 11th District,'' he said last night.

District 16

Democrat Sean Ramaley won an easy victory in the 16th District race, using a wide margin on the Beaver County side of the line to defeat Republican Pat Geho in a battle of first-time candidates.

Ramaley, 29, of Conway, will take the seat being vacated by Susan Laughlin, who is retiring. A lawyer, he was working for the federal Department of Labor, and was formerly an aide in the Ohio House of Representatives.

Geho, 34, of Baden, is a former aide to U.S. Rep. Melissa Hart.

Advertise with us

Both men were making their first run for public office.

The 16th District, which includes the southeastern corner of Beaver County, has long been in Democratic hands, but was redrawn in the 2001 redistricting, with a tail stretching through the more conservative North Hills.

Geho, who touted a sales tax as a replacement for property taxes, beat Ramaley in the Allegheny County part of the district, but couldn't overcome Ramaley's lead in Beaver County.

District 28

Republican incumbent Mike Turzai won a lopsided victory last night in a race to represent the North Hills' 28th District.

Advertise with us

Turzai, who lives in Bradford Woods, beat Democrat Brad Cline, 36, of Richland, by an almost 3-to-1 margin.

Cline was making his first run for office. Turzai, 45, a lawyer, was elected to the state House in 2001. Last night, he thanked his family and friends for their support in what he called a team effort to improve the North Hills and Pennsylvania.

Cline faced an uphill battle just to get on the ticket. After his nominating petitions were successfully challenged, he mounted a write-in primary campaign and won the Democratic nomination and the right to face Turzai in the general election.

"I can't say it was completely unexpected," Cline said of Turzai's victory. "We certainly got a lot more votes for the Democrat this time than last time -- when there was no Democratic candidate."

District 44

Advertise with us

As expected, incumbent state Rep. Mark Mustio, a Moon Republican, won handily in the 44th District over Democratic challenger Tim McLaughlin of Moon.

In a district where US Airways is a primary employer, "we're going to continue what we've started," Mustio said at a Republican victory party at the Radisson in Green Tree.

"Senator Pippy and I have worked very hard in economic development in the airport area, and that will continue."

Mustio was elected in 2003 to fill Pippy's seat when Pippy was elected to the state Senate.

In addition, Mustio said he would address the "brain drain" in Western Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

"We have fabulous institutions of higher learning in this region. We need to find jobs for these young people."

District 25

Incumbent Democrat Joseph Markosek won comfortably against Republican Edward Nicholson in the 25th District.

Markosek, 54, campaigned on a 22-year track record of securing state money for highway construction and state grants for ball fields, libraries, drug programs and other local projects.

Nicholson, 46, an instructor at Greater Works Outreach Bible School, campaigned for lower taxes, tort reform and education reform.

Advertise with us

The 25th District encompasses all or parts of Monroeville, North Versailles, Pitcairn, Plum, Trafford and Wall in Allegheny County and Murrysville and Trafford in Westmoreland.

Districts 54, 55, 56, 57

Four members of the state House in Westmoreland County had opposition for their seats. All of the incumbents were Democrats who won re-election as the results were reported in precincts where voter turnout in spots topped 75 percent.

In the 54th District Democratic incumbent John E. Pallone, 34, of New Kensington, beat Scott Witon, 52, of Murrysville, a part-time philosophy professor and former staff member for a number of Pennsylvania Senate members.

The campaign was a nasty one, with Witon making charges about Pallone's state car lease that were false and Pallone showing that Witon had not filed three cycles of campaign finance reports.

Advertise with us

The first 15,500 votes came in with Pallone winning 2-to-1, but still he wanted to wait to call a victory.

"I'm not completely relieved yet," he said.

The 55th District was a race of a strong incumbent, Joseph A. Petrarca, 43, of Oklahoma Borough, against Republican Ben Kissel, 39, of Latrobe. Both men were so close in their views on the issues that Kissel, who works as a manager of an engineering firm, said he was not running to oust Petrarca, but because of his own desire to enter public service. Petrarca's strength in the district proved insurmountable for Kissel.

The 56th District race was a contest between a young Republican lawyer, Scott Avolio, 29, of Jeannette, who promised to be a part-time legislator, against incumbent James E. Casorio, 40, a career legislator who won a sixth term.

Two Hempfield men who have served in elected office faced off in the 57th District race. The incumbent, Democrat Thomas A. Tangretti, 58, has held his seat in the House since 1989, and voters showed they wanted to keep him there until at least 2006. His challenger, P. Scott Connor, 42, is a former Westmoreland County commissioner who gave up his seat with the county to spend the full year campaigning.

Advertise with us

Connor spent Election Day working a polling place in the Carbon section of Hempfield where he said the people waiting in line were "extremely positive. Whether or not that turns into a vote inside, we'll see, but they are all extremely friendly outside."

District 35

The 35th District incumbent Marc J. Gergely, D-White Oak, handily defeated his challenger Libertarian David Posipanka, 46, of Homestead.

Gergely, 35, who is nearing the end of his first term, said he is looking forward to seeking a leadership position in the Legislature in his next term. He also said he respected Posipanka for "running a good election on issues that he believes in."

Posipanka, a therapist who deals with mental health, drug and alcohol issues, campaigned to eliminate a number of taxes and to reduce state bureaucracy if elected. But, he said, he found that most voters in his district "don't know too much about the Libertarians and the positions that Libertarians believe in."

Advertise with us

District 39

In the 39th District, challenger Brad Grantz, R- Elizabeth Township, ran a fierce door-to-door campaign against state Rep. David Levdansky, but it wasn't enough to unseat the incumbent, who was re-elected to an 11th term.

Levdansky, 50, of Forward, said he believes voters in his district are happy with the way he's served them for the past 20 years and that they appreciate his seniority in Harrisburg. "I focus on the needs of the citizens, neighborhoods and communities. I think the numbers [election returns] ratify that hard work," he said.

Grantz, 23, a 2003 graduate of Carnegie-Mellon University, said he still believes that a "career politician" like Levdansky should be voted out of office in order to make positive changes in the state. But, he said, his message wasn't accepted "in a very conservative area where politics have been played a certain way for 20 years and people are reluctant to change."

Districts 46, 48, 49

Advertise with us

In Washington County, the hotly contested race for the 46th District was leaning toward incumbent state Rep. Victor Lescovitz, D-Midway.

Republican challenger Paul Snatchko, 28, came within 1,600 votes of toppling the 12-term incumbent two years ago.

With a doubled war chest and a new focus on property tax and education reform, the McDonald councilman would have been the county's first Republican state legislator in 15 years.

Lescovitz, 51, touted his work for seniors, along with his work bringing in millions in state funding for local road and development projects.

In the 48th District, incumbent state Rep. Tim Solobay, D-Canonsburg, cruised to an easy victory over Republican challenger Rick Yochum of Canonsburg and Reform candidate Demo Agoris of Houston for his fourth term.

Advertise with us

Yochum, 41, focused on medical liability reform, while Agoris, 63, took a third try at unseating Solobay by voicing his opposition to the Southern Beltway.

Solobay, 48, cited his work in securing more than $500,000 in state funding last year for 50 local organizations.

In the 49th District, incumbent state Rep. Peter J. Daley, D-California, had an easy time beating Republican challenger Jeffrey J. Baker of Washington, Fayette County.

In his first general election challenge in 20 years, the 11-term incumbent, Daley, 54, said he's brought $117 million to the region during his tenure.

A civil engineer for the state Turnpike Commission, Baker, 44, lobbied for the abolishment of property tax.

Advertise with us

District 52

Democratic incumbent James E. Shaner, 69, of Lemont Furnace, easily captured a sixth term in this race against Republican challenger William R. Earnesty, 32, who described himself as a lifetime overburdened taxpayer.

District 60

Jeff Coleman should be proud.

The two-term representative from the 60th District surprised constituents and the state Republican Party when he announced in January he would not run for re-election, citing plans to run his own morning radio talk show.

Before he was done, though, Coleman tapped Ford City Mayor Jeff Pyle to replace him.

Last night, Pyle was leading the race handily over Democratic challenger Barry Crytzer.

"I'm very happy, very tired, very thankful," Pyle said from his post-election party at Lenape Heights Golf Club. "I am humbled and honored to have been selected as the choice of the people of the 60th."

He has set his goals in the House as reforming the legal system to eliminate junk lawsuits; creating a more favorable business climate to bring in jobs; and reforming property taxes.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.