HARRISBURG -- A Commonwealth Court judge yesterday ordered a Republican state representative's name removed from the April 27 primary ballot because he failed to list the proceeds from the sale of his business as income on a financial-disclosure form.

The ruling by Judge Dan Pellegrini left the Republicans without a candidate on the ballot in the 69th House District in Bedford and Somerset counties, although incumbent Rep. Bob Bastian vowed to run a write-in campaign for the GOP nomination.

"This is politics in Harrisburg," the third-term lawmaker said after the ruling, which he did not contest. "We'll get back on the ballot in the fall."

Bastian, who was without opposition in the primary, would require 300 votes to win the nomination as a write-in candidate, Pennsylvania State Department spokesman Jesus Pena said.

Advertise with us

At issue in the case was income that Bastian received from the sale of his veterinary practice in 2003, as well as his salary and other income from his legislative positions -- neither of which was included under "direct and indirect sources of income" on his statement of financial interests.

John Connelly, the Hummelstown lawyer for the voter who challenged Bastian's nominating papers, said the omission of that information invalidated Bastian's statement of financial interests.

By not contesting the challenge, Bastian "conceded effectively that we could prove our point and that he would be stricken from the ballot," Connelly said.

Bastian maintained that the rules for completing the financial statements were unclear. He said he omitted the income from the sale of his practice because it was a capital gain, not earned income, and that he felt his legislative income was implicit in listing his occupation as state representative.

"I did absolutely nothing wrong," he said.

Advertise with us

The issue of whether legislative income must be listed on the financial statements will be the focus of legal arguments Wednesday on challenges to the nominating petitions of three other Republican House incumbents. A panel of three Commonwealth Court judges will preside over that session.

Two of the three legislators have no competition in the primary -- Rep. Kerry A. Benninghoff, R-Centre, and Rep. Chris Ross, R-Chester. The other lawmaker, Rep. William I. Gabig, R-Cumberland, faces one opponent in the primary.

Lawrence Tabas, the Philadelphia lawyer who represented Bastian and the other three lawmakers, called the issue in the pending cases "hyper-technical." He maintains that candidates should be allowed to amend their financial statements as long as they are filed on time and with the right agency.

It was unclear whether any other Republican incumbents in the House face similar challenges. GOP leaders did not immediately telephone calls.

Of the 94 Democrats who make up the House minority, 91 are seeking re-election. None of them face any challenges to their ballot qualifications, said Bill Patton, an aide to Minority Whip Mike Veon.