Addictions and overdoses have driven the nation’s medical community to dial back opioid prescribing, but the flow of narcotics remains stubbornly high in many places, including some Western Pennsylvania counties, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reported Thursday.
Nationally, opioid prescribing peaked in 2010, the CDC reported. But in rural Greene, Crawford, Warren, Venango and Elk counties, it continued to rise, according to any analysis of opioid prescribing over a decade, ending in 2015.
Among the nation’s heavy-prescribing counties were three of those — Crawford, Venango and Elk — plus Fayette, Cambria, Blair, Mercer, Lawrence, McKean and Cameron, the CDC found.
“Opioid prescribing varies as much from place to place as the weather,” said CDC acting Director Anne Schuchat. In 2015, the CDC found, counties in the top-prescribing categories saw rates six times that seen in the lowest-prescribing counties.
The overall picture: “The amount of opioids prescribed in the U.S. is still too high, with too many opioid prescriptions for too many days at too high a dosage,” she said. Even after a dip, rates of opioid prescribing in 2015 were triple 1999 levels.
She backed the theory that opioid prescribing laid the groundwork for an increased heroin market and more powerful narcotics such as illicit fentanyl. “We’re now experiencing the highest drug overdose death rates ever recorded in the U.S.,” she said. “This is just a tragic outbreak on so many levels.”
Read More
The CDC’s findings, though, come when Western Pennsylvania’s overdose counts are driven more by fentanyl, suggesting to some that to focus on opioid prescribing is now quaint.
“Where we are today may have a lot to do with the opioids that were prescribed, but you still should not throw out the baby with the bathwater and not talk about why” people are trying — and dying from — more powerful illicit drugs, said William Fritz, a Venango County orthopedist. His son Daniel died in August at age 27, after snorting a narcotic called U-47700, ordered through the internet.
Nationally, the opioid prescribing rate topped 81 opioid prescriptions per 100 Americans in 2010, then sagged to 71 by 2015. Still, that was enough to medicate every American “around the clock for three weeks,” said Dr. Schuchat.
Counties with persistently high levels of opioid prescribing tended to be mostly white and non-Hispanic, with small cities or big towns, and characterized by higher unemployment. They had higher-than-average prevalence of diabetes and arthritis, disability and suicide, and lower-than-average rates of educational attainment and private insurance coverage, the CDC found.

In many of such counties in Western Pennsylvania, “resources are definitely much needed,” said Lynn Mirigian, director of the Pennsylvania Heroin Overdose Prevention Technical Assistance Center, headquartered at the University of Pittsburgh’s School of Pharmacy. “Coroners are under water when it comes to the number of overdoses for which they have to do toxicology reports.” And for many residents of outlying counties, it’s “a 45-minute drive for treatment,” she added.
Some rural counties, though, are valiantly setting up coalitions to fight opioid problems, she said.
Judy Rosser, executive director of the Blair County Drug & Alcohol Program, said the CDC’s findings are consistent with state data she recently received, showing high opioid prescribing there.
“We have a small city,” she said, referring to Altoona. “Primarily Caucasian. Very little ethnic diversity.
“We did not realize the amount of prescriptions being written in our community,” she said, adding that the county’s doctors and hospitals now are working together to change prescribing practices.
“Fayette County is a poorer county. We do have a lot of unemployment,” said Brian Reese, treatment supervisor for the Fayette County Drug and Alcohol Commission Inc. “But then I can also say that I’ve treated doctors and lawyers. That’s not an economic thing. I’ve seen professionals to homeless.”
He said that after 24 years in the business, he still doesn’t know why addiction is surging.
“After taking [opioids] for just a few days, a person becomes more likely to take them long-term,” said Dr. Schuchat, adding that even a low-dose opioid, taken for three months, increases the risk of addiction 15-fold.
The CDC put the number of prescription opioid addicts at 2 million, and the “economic burden” of the problem at $78.5 billion a year.
An even grimmer metric is the 52,404 overdose deaths in 2015, of which 63.1 percent involved opioids, as often as not including prescription narcotics, the CDC reported.
The CDC has recommended that doctors honor opioid prescribing guidelines promulgated last year, and use state drug monitoring programs that allow them to see whether patients are getting narcotics from multiple sources.
Some states — the CDC noted Ohio, Kentucky and Florida — took vigorous action and drove prescribing down in the majority of their counties. Such policies, the CDC added, “might reduce the number of persons initiating illicit opioid use in the longer term,” and aren’t driving up overdoses.
Pennsylvania took many of the same measures late last year. In May 2016, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette launched its series Overdosed: How Doctors Wrote the Script for an Epidemic.
Last month the Drug Enforcement Administration reported that in Pennsylvania, 4,642 people died from drug overdoses last year, up from 3,377 the year before. In Allegheny County, the drug death toll was 648, up from 424 the prior year.
Dr. Fritz said his son wasn’t a pill addict or heroin user, but rather “a seeker” who got caught up in the easy availability of narcotics. He ordered a compound called U-47700 from China and “just snorted a little bit of it. … He stopped breathing.”
“You can go on the internet with $100 and order it and have it delivered to your house in four days,” he said.
He has noted overprescribing of narcotics in the idyllic Franklin and DuBois areas for decades but still wonders why, suddenly, so many people are falling for pills, heroin or exotic narcotics.
“I believe that, yes, there probably are statistics out there that most people that end up to be heroin addicts started out on pills,” he said. “And maybe part of it is they’re hurting, and there’s a whole lot of us hurting, because we’re socially disconnected.”
We’re less active, and less connected with nature, often starting in childhood, he added. “It’s the drugs, society, illnesses and the person.”



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.