Michael Orstein was on the way home from a morning swim when he received the text.

He had to pull over. He started crying. Vicki Staton — a trailblazer for women’s athletics and revered volleyball and women’s basketball coach at Washington & Jefferson College — died on July 30 from a brief illness. She was 77.

Mr. Orstein, a longtime swimming and diving coach at the school, admired Ms. Staton. He eventually arrived home and sat in a quiet room as he typed out a tribute, trying to find the right words to encapsulate her profound influence. He shared a post on LinkedIn, concluding with a quote from legendary UCLA basketball coach John Wooden.

“A good coach can change a game. A great coach can change a life.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Staton won games. Exactly 646 of them between volleyball and women’s basketball from 1975-2002, making her Washington & Jefferson’s all-time winningest coach.

Even more important than the fact that she was a good coach was that she had the qualities of a great one. After receiving bachelor’s and master’s degrees from West Virginia University, Ms. Staton began working at W&J in 1975. The school didn’t allow female students until 1970. Title IX, which paved the way for colleges to add and invest in female athletics, was signed into law in 1972.

She was tireless in her efforts, insatiably working to lift women’s sports off the ground and provide opportunities for as many women as possible. Ms. Staton was demanding. Forcing her voice to be heard in countless male-dominated spaces, she was blunt when needed.

If it meant ruffling some feathers along the way, so be it.

“She was not going to educate or coach future passive women,” Mr. Orstein said. “I think that says a lot about Vicki — she was tough, but yet loving at the same time.”

Advertise with us

A staunch advocate for professionalism, she was known to badger players — and even fellow coaches and faculty members — about improper grammar. Jina DeRubbo, the current women’s basketball coach and assistant director of athletics at Washington & Jefferson, considered Ms. Staton her mentor.

Ms. DeRubbo, who hails from rural Ohio, used to endure plenty of grammatical corrections. She vividly remembers being told to stop saying, “I seen it” as opposed to “I saw it.”

“Vicki was the queen of making sure these kids spoke with good grammar,” Ms. DeRubbo said. “She was just always preparing kids to be a professional. That was kind of her thing. … She hounded these little things, even into me, and I no longer say it.

“If I do, I think of her instantly.”

She could poke fun, too. When Mr. Orstein first got to Washington & Jefferson in 1988, the swimming program was “rock bottom.” He turned things around quickly and enjoyed a storied career, earning conference Coach of the Year honors 15 times before retiring in 2018.

Advertise with us

But he remembers those early years, specifically days after meets. He held morning swim practices at 6:30 a.m. and went for roughly an hour and a half. Around 8 a.m., the door would unlock and swing open near the shallow end of the pool. In walked Ms. Staton.

“Vicki would say to me, ‘Hey Mike, I didn’t get a chance to read the paper this morning. How’d you do?’ ” Mr. Orstein said.

He quickly noticed she showed up after losses, never wins. He also knew she read the paper every single morning and was fully aware of the meet results. Sure, Mr. Orstein was irked at the time. But when he looks back now, the unlocking of the door is as vivid as ever.

“It was Vicki’s way of humbling me and just letting me know I’m certainly not big time,” Mr. Orstein said. “I would give anything to hear that unlocking of the door and see Vicki come in. It’s one of those sweet, hard memories. I didn’t appreciate it at the time, but I’d give anything for her to come and open the door early in the morning.”

After retiring from head coaching following the 2002 volleyball season, Ms. Staton remained heavily involved on campus. She served as the college’s director of wellness and intramurals while staying active on various committees.

Advertise with us

In 2005 — one year after arriving at W&J from Bethany — Ms. DeRubbo had twins. The basketball season started two days prior. She didn’t know if her absence would span weeks or months, and asked Ms. Staton if she’d be willing to help out on the staff. She agreed, and remained a volunteer coach for the ensuing 15 seasons.

Ms. Staton was at practice every day. Because she wasn’t burdened with the stressful responsibilities of head coaching like recruiting and in-depth scouting, she was more relaxed. Oftentimes, she baked cookies for the team bus when they played road games.

“They got the best of her,” Ms. DeRubbo said.

Ms. Staton stepped away from the team after COVID-19 hit, but she stayed intently aware of each game. She watched home games in person and viewed all the others online. After each game, she would send Ms. DeRubbo a text with a recap.

She would include her own analysis on what worked and what didn’t, never sparing feelings.

Advertise with us

“Almost after every game I’d wait for that text,” Ms. DeRubbo said, “and there it was.”

Ms. Staton was a role model for thousands of women she came to know. She became a second grandmother to Ms. DeRubbo and Mr. Orstein’s daughters. Prior to last season, Ms. DeRubbo’s daughter, Riley, transferred from American University to spend a graduate year playing at Washington & Jefferson.

The team went 24-5 and secured the program’s first-ever NCAA tournament win. Ms. Staton was there to see it.

Until Ms. Staton was 24 years old, college athletics were heavily limited for women. Even after Title IX was passed, she had to fight to elevate and expand those programs at Washington & Jefferson.

At 3:30 p.m. on Thursday, the campus is holding a Celebration of Life service in her honor. Ms. DeRubbo said the Salvitti Family Gymnasium will be packed. There will undoubtedly be stories of her toughness and demanding style of coaching.

Advertise with us

But her desire to see young women succeed — and the care she displayed for so many people she came in contact with — will be remembered more than anything.

“She was really one of the sweetest women you’ll ever know,” Ms. DeRubbo said. “But she was always fighting for her life. She had to fight for the young women that were trying to get started. I think that’s why people thought she was scary, per se, because she was always fighting that battle. Over the years she didn’t have to fight quite so hard, because women became equal.

“In the end, she won.”