On Thanksgiving Day in 1965, two young guests visiting Alice Brock and her husband, Ray, repaid the hospitality by helping clean up an old church that the couple had converted into their home in western Massachusetts.
They loaded up a red Volkswagen Microbus with discarded furniture, scraps of wood and other debris. But the dump was closed for the holiday. So they tossed the junk down a hill in Stockbridge. Someone told the police.
And events were set in motion for what became folk singer Arlo Guthrie’s autobiographical anthem of wartime protest, hippie fellowship and a belly-filling Thanksgiving feast. The 1967 album “Alice’s Restaurant” also made Ms. Brock a reluctant counterculture doyenne as the purveyor of the place where “you can get anything you want.”
“It’s a lot of fun,” said Ms. Brock, who died Thursday — a week before Thanksgiving — at age 83 in Wellfleet, Mass., near her longtime home in Provincetown, “and it has a message of all the right things: of hope and music.”
The song, “Alice’s Restaurant Massacree,” spins the tale of the Thanksgiving visit with his buddy Rick Robbins and what happened next: fined $25 each for littering and how that, in a twist of fate, possibly saved Guthrie from the draft during the Vietnam War. Mr. Guthrie’s more than 18-minute mix of storytelling and song became a singular hybrid: an antiwar rallying cry and a holiday favorite that’s replayed on many radio stations as a Thanksgiving staple with a well-known refrain.
“Walk right in it’s around the back
Just a half a mile from the railroad track
You can get anything you want at Alice’s Restaurant”
Mr. Guthrie, son of the Americana music master Woody Guthrie, first met Ms. Brock in the early 1960s when he was a student at the Stockbridge School, where she was the librarian. Her rambling home, once an Episcopal church, became a place for Guthrie and other students to hang out after classes.
Mr. Guthrie and Ms. Brock stayed in touch. In 1965, the 18-year-old Mr. Guthrie and Mr. Robbins, 19, were traveling around the Berkshires and ended up as Thanksgiving guests with the Brocks. Ms. Brock cooked a traditional meal that they ate in the kitchen, tucked away on the ground floor of the church’s bell tower.
The Stockbridge police called the next morning about the trash drop. According to the song: Mr. Guthrie confessed, he and Mr. Robbins were jailed and Ms. Brock bailed them out in time for “another Thanksgiving dinner that couldn’t be beat.” The next morning, a judge fined him and Mr. Robbins for littering.
When Mr. Guthrie is later ordered to appear at an Army induction center, his criminal record keeps him out of the military. Ms. Brock said she helped Mr. Guthrie write the first part of the song. “The other half, the draft part, Arlo wrote,” she told the author C.A. Sanders.
Mr. Guthrie’s sardonic style gave the antiwar movement some new and amusing points of reference, including the Stockbridge “crime scene,” officer “Obie” William J. Obanhein and the sergeant at the Army induction center who wants to know “if I’m moral enough join the army, burn women, kids, houses and villages after bein’ a litterbug.” (Mr. Guthrie and Obanhein later became friends.)
For Ms. Brock, the attention was overwhelming and initially unwelcome. “I don’t feel very good about having people point at me and say, ‘That’s her,’ ” she said in 1978.
Her first restaurant, the Back Room, opened in 1966 in Stockbridge and closed within a year as she struggled with the business end of running an eatery. “I felt that instead of owning it, it owned me,” Ms. Brock wrote in her 1975 memoir, “My Life as a Restaurant.”
When director Arthur Penn made the 1969 movie “Alice’s Restaurant” based on Mr. Guthrie’s song, Ms. Brock (played by Patricia Quinn) bought a Mustang convertible with the $12,000 she received for the use of her name. Ms. Brock and Obanhein had cameos. (The movie scene of the Brocks’ marriage was filmed on the same day their real-life divorce became official.)
In 1971, she opened the restaurant Take Out Alice in nearby Housatonic, Mass., and later expanded it into a 50-seat dining room renamed Alice’s Restaurant. For Guthrie fans, the place became as much a Berkshires landmark as the Tanglewood performance venue or the Norman Rockwell Museum. Ms. Brock said she often hid in the kitchen to avoid tourist cameras and autograph seekers.
“I resented it for a long time,” she told WAMC Northeast Public Radio in 2014. “But I’ve come to realize now that people are just delighted when they hear my name, so how can I complain?”
Her third restaurant, Alice’s at Avaloch, opened in 1976 on a resort across the street from Tanglewood. Little of the homespun vibe from Guthrie’s song remained. Diners sometimes had to shout over the music from a disco floor.
She called it quits in 1979, packed up her car and drove to Provincetown at the tip of Cape Cod, where she spent some vacations as a child. She soon found a niche in Provincetown’s art scene as a gallery owner and painter. To make ends meet, she sometimes helped out in local restaurants. (She was a New York native but liked to tell people she was conceived in Provincetown.)
“The light is so wonderful,” she wrote on her website. “The people are pretty wonderful, too, contrarians, cranks, queers, and curmudgeons. A great mix of round pegs that stopped trying to fit into square holes. Plenty of space to be yourself or invent a new self. I fit right in.”
Alice May Pelkey was born in Brooklyn on Feb. 28, 1941. Her father was a printmaker, and her mother sold real estate.
Ms. Brock described her childhood as often difficult, coping with a father she called domineering and spending time in reform schools.
She left Sarah Lawrence College in her sophomore year and moved to Manhattan, where she met Ray Brock, an architect and woodworker. They married in 1962 and moved to Stockbridge the following year.
Her books include “Alice’s Restaurant Cookbook” (1969) and the children’s book “How to Massage Your Cat” (1985). She illustrated Guthrie’s 1995 book version of his folk song “Mooses Come Walking.” In 1991, Mr. Guthrie purchased the site of their 1965 Thanksgiving, the former church, to create the Guthrie Center as a music venue and interfaith worship space.
In 2019, pranksters dumped a load of trash and an old couch at the Guthrie Center along with a note: “Officer Obie told me to do it.”
As Ms. Brock confronted greater health problems, a GoFundMe created by a friend helped pay for her care. Her death at a hospice, from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, was announced by Mr. Guthrie on the social media page of his Rising Son Records. Survivors include three stepchildren.
In 2022, Ms. Brock joined Mr. Guthrie and Mr. Robbins for their first Thanksgiving dinner together since the fateful holiday 57 years earlier. Mr. Robbins hosted the event at his home in Housatonic, not far from the hillside where they dumped the rubbish.
“In a return to their halcyon days of youth they’ll celebrate Thanksgiving together once again,” Mr. Guthrie’s wife, Marti Guthrie, told the Berkshire Eagle. “This time without the garbage.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.