Larry Lagattuta was known far beyond Pittsburgh for the hand-shaped biscotti and other sweet treats he started selling at his small family bakery, Enrico Biscotti, 30 years ago.
In the decades since its modest opening in a 500-square-foot storefront on Penn Avenue in 1992, the iconic Strip District bakery has grown to where it cranks out some 90,000 pounds of the Italian cookies in more than 30 flavors each year, along with countless cookies, tarts and other Italian pastries.
But for Mr. Lagattuta, who learned to bake as a boy, it was never so much about the business of baking as the simple joy of turning everyday ingredients like flour, sugar and eggs into something irresistible and delicious.
“He always liked to feed people,” said his brother, Joseph, of New Kensington. “It really brought him happiness.”
Mr. Lagattuta died June 26 at home following a heart attack. He was 65.
The third oldest of six children, he grew up in Pittsburgh’s Beechview neighborhood embracing his father’s Italian-American traditions — despite the fact his mother is Slovak. He especially loved the meatballs and minestra his Sicilian grandmother often had simmering on the stove, and as a child he cooked and baked alongside her and his mom.
After graduating from St. Justin High School in 1976, he studied business at Robert Morris College before starting his corporate career as an account executive at what was then called Xerox. It was a few years later, after he’d moved onto a job at AT&T, that he had his “epiphany,” said his brother Joseph. He decided to bake for a living.

Mr. Lagattuta had become a regular at La Prima Espresso after its opening in 1988, spending countless hours conversing over coffee with owner Sam Patti about their shared Italian-American heritage. So when the Missouri bakery that supplied the espresso bar with biscotti was destroyed in a fire in 1992, he offered to help him out.
“They baked all night, and when the sun came up and they sat and had a little coffee and what Larry liked to call a sand-a-which, he thought, ‘Why am I messing around with this job that is killing me and I don’t like when I can be my own boss?’” his brother recalled.
His father, of course, thought he was crazy, but “that’s what he wanted to do and he cast his whole lot into that to make [Enrico Biscotti] a success,” he said.
Immortalized in the 2001 film “The Bread, My Sweet,” by his wife at the time, filmmaker Melissa Martin, the tiny bakery eventually drew so many customers that Mr. Lagattuta had to expand into a former mechanic shop next door and also build a second facility for wholesale down the street.
His oldest son Sam joined him behind the counter in 2014, and ended up staying “because I got to spend every single day working with him,” he said. “The freedom the job gave me was really important.”
Everything produced in the bakery, from the croissants to the different tarts to the bread and hand-tossed pizza was his father’s idea. “It was his child,” he said.
In later years, he’d wake up in their apartment above the store, make a cappuccino and “bake whatever he felt like that day.”
Mr. Lagattuta was a natural storyteller who loved to engage family and friends in conversations on everything from history to science. Many of his best stories are highlighted in “My Black Book,” the memoir-cookbook he wrote aboard his 40-foot sailboat, John Paul Jones, and published last year.

“His whole face changed when he was telling you a story,” said Anna Balazs of Shadyside, who first met him about 20 years ago at his cafe. “He’d be beaming and so animated!”
“If you saw Larry on the other side of a busy street, you’d cross traffic just to talk to him,” agreed longtime friend Joe Mistick, a law professor at Duquesne University. “He knew what it was to be an Italian American better than anyone I know, the blending of the old and new worlds.”
Mr. Lagattuta also relished the sense of community he and his wife, Maureen, were famous for building — in Pittsburgh in general, and the Strip District in particular. When he started his bakery 30 years ago, the neighborhood was still evolving from a deserted warehouse district into the food and shopping destination it is today.
To be a FOL — Friend of Larry — “was a badge of honor,” said Ms. Balazs. “We felt very privileged.”
Like most successful entrepreneurs, Mr. Lagatutta made countless connections along the way.
“Feeding people is not just about the bread itself,” said Mr. Patti. “It’s also about a whole series of things on how to treat people.”
Mr. Lagattuta also mentored others who wanted to start their own businesses.
“Larry’s real talent was his ability to bring people together,” said longtime friend Ron Casertano of Consumer Fresh Produce, a Strip District wholesaler. “They gravitate not just to his products but the lifestyle he’s made.... He’s inspired a lot of people to find the courage to go ahead and step off and start.”
Passionate about preserving Italian traditions, Mr. Lagattuta was an enthusiastic self-taught winemaker who not only ran a wine club with Mr. Casertano and other friends but in 2007 started the city’s first urban winery in the basement of his cafe, producing his homemade wines for sale under the label “Carlo’s Garage Winery.” He also taught bread- and pizza-making classes.
“He liked being part of a tradition that extended back through the generations and centuries,” said his brother.

As he edged toward retirement, Mr. Lagattuta — who loved to put boat models together as a child — could often be found on his sailboat he kept in Chestertown, Md., and sailed on the Chesapeake Bay. Last year, he navigated it all the way to Florida on the Atlantic Ocean, “and that was quite an adventure,” said his brother. His classic Triumph TR6 was another favorite possession.
He also loved baseball and on occasion would stand in the vestibule of the cafe, a glass of wine and cigar in hand, and listen to a game on the radio. “It sounds simple, but that’s what made it so nice,” said Mr. Casertano.
But his greatest quality was the passion with which he lived his life, said Mr. Mistick. “What can you say about a guy who left the corporate world to chase the perfect biscotti and for who baking bread was meditation?”
“He marched to his own drummer and oftentimes that got him into trouble,” his brother said. “But he was such a big-hearted guy and everyone he met felt that about him.”
Along with his son and brother, he is survived by his mother, Marilyn, of New Kensington, wife Maureen Diskin, daughter Madeline Lagattuta Merchant (Alex) of Jersey City, N.J., son Myles of Baden, sister Paula Langer (Michael) of New Kensington, brother Ted (Sally) of Lower Burrell, and grandson Cyrus. He was preceded in death by his father, Lawrence, and siblings Roseann and Anthony.
Friends will be received Thursday from 2 to 8 p.m. at Beinhauer Funeral Home, 2630 West Liberty Ave. Dormont. A Mass of Christian Burial will take place at 10:30 a.m. Friday at St. Stanislaus Kostka Church, 57 21st St. in the Strip District. Interment will be at a later date.
In lieu of flowers, contributions can be made in Mr. Lagattuta’s name to the Greater Pittsburgh Community Food Bank.
Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.