Larry Lagattuta has made tens of thousands — perhaps even millions — of oblong-shaped biscotti in the Italian bakery he opened 30 years ago in the Strip District. For all that twice-baked, crunchy deliciousness, Pittsburghers have his brother, Joe, to thank.
Like a lot of older siblings, Joe wasn’t crazy about having to hang out with a kid five years his junior. So whenever he and his buddies got together in the neighborhood, “they’d take me outside and make me do something dumb, like hold the radio, or just leave me,” recalls Lagattuta with a chuckle.
Much more accepting were his Sicilian grandmother, Pauline, various aunts and a host of Italian neighbors, including the restaurant-famous Tambellinis. Any time the youngster walked into one of their kitchens, the Beechview native was showered with hugs and kisses followed by the inevitable Italian cheek pinch.
“And it just smelled so good,” he says of the meatballs and minestre simmering on the stovetop or cookies baking in the oven.
As he recalls in his just-released memoir and cookbook, “My Black Book,” the kitchen soon became his place of refuge, and what he learned there became a way to make a life instead of just a living.
Lagattuta, now 65, baked so often with his mother, Marilyn, and others while growing up that, before long, he was responsible for making the cookies his father, Sammy, loved to eat after work. By the time he was married and had a kid of his own, he had such skills that when the St. Louis bakery that supplied La Prima Espresso with biscotti went up in flames in 1992, he pitched in to help owner Sam Patti. He quickly began building a following for his oh-so-dunkable Italian cookies.
The former AT&T account executive drank a lot of coffee at La Prima following its opening in 1988 — so much so that the espresso bar, the first of its kind in Pittsburgh, almost became a second home. In an effort to reassure Patti after the fire, he told him, “Oh Sam, any old grandmother can make biscotti. I can do it.”
Then to prove his point, he did.
Lagattuta’s initial batch of anise almond biscotti was an instant hit. “So I made them again and again and again” every Friday and Saturday night for Patti’s customers, first at home and then in Antonio Branduzzi’s adjoining bakery, Il Piccolo Forno (now Colangelo’s Bakery).
The cookies were dubbed Enrico Biscotti because there was no Italian name for “Larry.” When Branduzzi was writing out an index card for the biscuits, he thought he heard his customers calling out to Henry — Enrico in Italian. A brand was born.

On his own
Demand soon outgrew what Lagattuta could produce in Branduzzi’s small bakery. Luckily, after a year or so of space sharing, an “adorable” Italian couple named Gemma and Sergio came to the rescue. With the Strip District gentrifying, they thought Lagattuta might want to rent the 500-square-foot storefront below their apartment on Penn Avenue and open a pasticceria, or Italian bakery. Rent: just $500 a month.
“And we shook hands and that was that,” he says. He quit his corporate job to bake full time and has been at 2022 Penn Ave. every since.
Starting with little more than pocket money, Lagattuta built out the space with help from family and friends to hold a work table, 30-year-old Hobart mixer and an electric convection oven behind a display case. A sign featuring a flying biscotti painted by his wife at the time, filmmaker Melissa Martin (who immortalized the bakery in the 2001 film “The Bread, My Sweet”), beckoned cookie lovers inside.
The 18-hour days that started at 3 a.m. on concrete floors left him exhausted. But it was a good kind of tired, he says, a tired that made him incredibly happy. “I just loved this.”
Today, after expanding the business into a former mechanic shop next door (a second Penn Avenue facility houses the wholesale side), the bakery’s 16 employees produce not just some 90,000 pounds of hand-shaped biscotti a year in 8-ounce bags, but also countless cookies, tarts, cakes, croissants, breads and other Italian pastries.
The biscotti come in 31 flavors — 32 if you count the peanut butter-and-bacon ones made for dogs — and are offered in specialty stores and groceries all over the country, as well as online.

"My Black Book"
With beautiful pictures by Pittsburgh food photographer Michael Ray, “My Black Book” features 20 of Enrico’s most popular recipes, along with tips on how to find, assemble and use ingredients. All are easy enough for even the novice baker, and the book’s casual, encouraging voice makes you feel like Lagattuta is in the kitchen alongside you. Even if you never plan on actually baking, it’s a fun read — especially once you know he wrote it not in his kitchen but aboard his 40-foot sailboat, John Paul Jones.
While Lagattuta toyed with the idea of a cookbook for years, he didn’t actually start writing until about a year and a half ago, when Mandi Gruenloh came on staff. The young baker couldn’t make out some of the recipes he’d compiled in a cherished black binder, so the baker had to rewrite them. In doing so, Lagattuta started thinking not just about their origins but the bittersweet tales of the people behind them.
“I just wanted to tell these stories,” he says, to keep them from being lost to history.
Not surprisingly, many of the recipes, including the bakery’s signature Linzers and twice-baked biscotti, are family favorites. Others were shared by fellow Italians who knew the baker would appreciate them. The recipe for almond macaroons, for instance, was handed to him years ago out of the blue by an almost stranger on an index card.
His flourless chocolate “oblivion” cake, meanwhile, came from Amy Rosenfield of Mon Aimee Chocolat, who offered him gourmet chocolate from her shop at Penn Avenue and 21st Street. It remains one of Enrico’s most popular cakes, “and I still buy my chocolate from Amy,” he writes in the recipe’s headnotes.
Especially close to his heart is the recipe for Enrico’s chocolate-dipped “people cookies.” Every single one — and he makes 100 a day — has been hand-cut with the same steel cookie cutter Lagattuta bought when he was just starting out.
“Kids I gave them away to 30 years ago now have kids of their own,” he says.
With his son Sam poised to eventually take over, Lagattuta says he now has the luxury of later hours and making exactly what he wants, instead of what he has to — an experimental cake here, a batch of new cookies there.
Sharing the recipes he and his customers love in “My Black Book,” and thereby ensuring their place in history, “just makes me so happy,” he says.
“My Black Book” is available for $29.95 at Enrico Biscotti Co., 2022 Penn Ave., Strip District.
Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay or IG @pittsburghpgfood.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.