When retired U.S. Bankruptcy Court Judge Bernard “Bernie” Markovitz talked, people listened.

A tall man with a solemn gaze, white hair and matching beard, he had what might be called gravitas.

If his name sounds familiar to sports fans, it’s because Judge Markovitz was largely credited with saving the Penguins hockey franchise during the team’s bankruptcy in the late ‘90s.

In fact, retired Post-Gazette columnist Brian O’Neill described Judge Markovitz in 1999 as “a man whose robe ought to hang in the Civic Arena’s rafters alongside the championship banners, because he is the man who saved hockey in Pittsburgh.”

Advertise with us

For the better part of a year, Judge Markovitz subtly nudged lawyers, team owners and other interested parties to haggle through the legal red tape toward a solution that kept the NHL team in Pittsburgh under an investor group led by Mario Lemieux.

But, Judge Markovitz was also an accomplished lawyer in private practice, an assistant solicitor at Pittsburgh Public Schools and an assistant district attorney in Allegheny County.

Judge Markovitz, who retired to Fort Myers, Fla., from McCandless several years ago, died Dec. 17 of complications from pancreatic cancer. He was 83.

He came from humble beginnings, growing up in Squirrel Hill, where he helped his father on his daily travels to the Hill District, selling produce and perishable goods on a huckster truck.

After graduating from Allderdice High School, he earned a degree at Westminster College, where he played football and edited the sports section in the school paper.

Advertise with us

“My father was the youngest of five and there was a 10-year age difference between him and the next youngest,” said his daughter Susan Markovitz, of Portland, Ore. “They came from very limited means, but he was a very determined individual. He was the first one in the family to go to college. He worked odd jobs, and sometimes had to leave college to earn more money before he could go back. He wasn’t encouraged to go to college — he just found a way and he worked really hard.”

“For tuition, he would sell aluminum siding in small towns in Pennsylvania, West Virginia and Ohio,” said his lifelong friend Dr. Sherwin Siff, an orthopedic surgeon in Houston. “Growing up, we lived half a block from each other and we used to hang around a corner. He was a no-BS, delightful guy. And, he was a good athlete. He was an offensive lineman — a big guy and very strong. We were close friends forever.”

At Westminster, he met Anne Catherine “Cathy” Dalae, a prospective student visiting the school. The couple married in 1966.

Judge Markovitz earned a degree from Duquesne University School of Law and served in the office of the Navy Judge Advocate General's Corps.

He went into private practice with law partner Louis Vitti for nearly two decades and worked for a time as assistant solicitor at the Pittsburgh Public Schools.

Advertise with us

“This is a man who had nothing and built a very successful practice and went on to become a judge,” his daughter said. “I think he accomplished everything he wanted to accomplish.”

A Republican, Judge Markovitz was a protégé of the late local GOP chair Elsie Hillman and served as a local committee leader before seeking elected office, including an unsuccessful run in 1975 for district attorney against prominent Democrat Robert Colville.

With a 2 to 1 Democratic edge in voter registration in Allegheny County, Judge Markovitz didn’t have much hope.

But, he made his mark as an assistant district attorney prosecuting serious felonies, including murder.

In 1967, he secured a conviction against the notorious Stanley Hoss for rape.

Advertise with us

When he was found guilty, Hoss threatened both Judge Markovitz and his young female victim.

“I’ll come back to see you,” Hoss snarled to the girl. Turning to Judge Markovitz, he said: “And I’ll come back to see you.”

“The first thing I did when I got home was to put a shotgun near our bed,” the judge told the Post-Gazette in a 1967 story about the case.

Hoss escaped while awaiting sentencing and went on to kill several people, including a prison guard and police officer, before eventually hanging himself in prison.

When he was appointed to the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania in November 1985 by the Third Circuit Court of Appeals, Judge Markovitz became only the sixth person to hold that position.

Advertise with us

For 26 years, he presided over consumer and commercial bankruptcy cases and served as chief judge from 1997 to 2000.

Judge Markovitz also led the movement to modernize the court by relocating it from the William S. Moorhead Federal Building to the 54th floor of the U.S. Steel Tower.

Aside from complicated bankruptcy cases of the City of Johnstown and Wheeling-Pittsburgh Steel, it was his role in the 1998 bankruptcy filing by the Pens that Judge Markovitz is best known for.

Early on in the court proceedings, Judge Markovitz issued an injunction preventing the team from leaving town -- a “courageous” move that signaled his intentions going forward, said his longtime friend Judge Jeffery A. Deller, who was appointed to the bankruptcy court in 2005.

“The Pens case touched really all of Western Pa. and other judges would have lost themselves in it, but Judge Markovitz didn’t. From the early stages he took charge of the case,” Judge Deller said. “He knew how important the team was as a community asset.”

Advertise with us

In his decision, Judge Markovitz wrote, “The Penguins are as much a part of the warp and woof of this community as are its other professional sports teams, museums, parks, theaters and ethnic neighborhoods. As important as [the creditors’] interests are, they may have to give way when the interest of the community at large so dictates.”

Described as “a no-nonsense judge” with a “wry humor,” in a June 1999 Post-Gazette story, Judge Markovitz’s wit livened up what had otherwise been an eye-glazingly technical proceeding.

“You need a hockey game on TV. You surely don’t want to fill it up with mud wrestling,” the judge said in an off-the-cuff remark to a lawyer for Fox Sports Net.

In the end, the rights of creditors were preserved in a deal that included Mario Lemieux converting his debt for equity, Judge Deller explained.

In succeeding with a satisfactory conclusion in a case where so many saw no way out, the judge was “the right guy, in the right place, at the right time,” Mr. O’Neill observed in his June 1999 column.

Advertise with us

“Always,” Mr. O’Neill wrote, “Markovitz kept his perspective, even as the high-priced lawyers before him lost all theirs.”

Though Judge Markovitz reached the mandatory retirement age of 70 in 2010, he continued serving as a senior judge until 2012.

Despite his considerable expertise, Judge Markovitz consistently strived to make sure he was the best-informed person in his courtroom, said his son Bill Markovitz, of Sarasota, Fla.

“He worked extremely hard growing up, but even when he became a judge he was always going to the office on the weekend -- it was a fairly usual circumstance,” his son said. “He always needed to know the law -- the case -- better than any other attorneys. He would spend many hours working to make sure he was up on everything and knew everything there was to know about the cases.”

Even through his harried schedule, Judge Markovitz always made time for his family and loved ones.

Advertise with us

“My dad is known for his determination, his ability to overcome societal barriers and his ability to read a room,” his daughter said. “But, maybe what's lesser known is that he had a sweet side -- he loved to walk, he would sing with me -- things you wouldn’t expect from a judge.”

And though he looked the part of the stern jurist, Judge Markovitz had a legendary sense of humor.

For example, he often left hilarious voicemail messages for his friends, including Judge Deller.

In one recent message, Judge Markovitz made it clear that he expected a return phone call -- or else.

“Jeff, Bernie. Uh, nothing in particular, just calling to check in,” Judge Markovitz said.

Advertise with us

He couldn’t resist adding: “If you get a chance, give me a buzz. If not, I'll put a warrant out for your arrest. Stay well, watch yourself.”

Along with his wife and children, Judge Markovitz is survived by four grandchildren.

In lieu of flowers, the family asks that a donation be made to a charity of your choice in Bernie's name.

Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com.