A giant in the legal and civil rights communities, retired state Superior Court Judge Justin M. Johnson also served as a “moral compass” to his many colleagues and proteges.
“You always knew if you had a question about something, he was the one you’d ask, because you would trust his judgment and understanding and that filtered through in his decisions on the Superior Court,” said Bryan Neft, a friend and former president of the Allegheny County Bar Association. “He was very thoughtful.”
Judge Johnson, a Vietnam War veteran and the second African American to serve on the state appellate court, died Friday of congestive heart failure. The longtime Shadyside resident was 88.
Much was expected of the young man who grew up in Wilkinsburg, the son and little brother of two of the most prominent Black attorneys and judges in the state — his late father, Judge Oliver Johnson, who was an Allegheny County Common Pleas Court judge and the first Black prosecutor in the county district attorney’s office, and his now 93-year-old brother, Judge Livingstone Johnson, a retired county jurist and distinguished lawyer.
“My parents had to use a straw purchaser — a lawyer and friend who was white — to buy our house in Wilkinsburg, which was an almost exclusively white suburb when we came along,” said Judge Livingstone Johnson, of Penn Hills. “The truth of it — based on oral history — is that it was racist.”
“My brother, Justin, was very intelligent, very outgoing and gregarious,” he recalled. “Justin was of the greatest integrity; he was very decisive, but not quick, in his decision-making. He was thoughtful about everything.”
After graduating from Wilkinsburg High School in 1951, Judge Johnson attended the University of Chicago, where he met Florence Lester at a party. Hers was a smile he would never forget, family members said.
“They got married in Chicago in 1960,” his brother said. “Justin was my best man when I got married a few months before, and when he got married, I was his best man.”
After graduating a year early from college, Judge Johnson enlisted in the Air Force, serving from 1956 to 1959 as a pilot and aircraft commander and from 1963 to 1973 as a major in active and reserve duty, including service in Vietnam during the war.
After his first stint in the military, Judge Johnson earned his law degree from the University of Chicago Law School.
By 1962, he brought his young family back to Pittsburgh, where he joined his brother and father at their family firm, Johnson, Johnson & Johnson.
Several years later, Judge Johnson became the first African American to be appointed by the state Supreme Court to the Pennsylvania Board of Law Examiners. He served for six years as chairman and maintained his position on the board for more than two decades.
In the 1970s, he served as solicitor for the Pittsburgh Public School board, and in 1980, he was appointed by then-Gov. Richard Thornburgh to Superior Court, where he continued until his retirement in 2007.
During his time on the bench and beyond, Judge Johnson worked to expand the role of minorities in the legal field and mentored younger lawyers, said Kathleen D. Wilkinson, president of the Pennsylvania Bar Association.
“For decades, Judge Johnson stood as a giant within the [PBA] for his unerring dedication to increasing diversity within the legal profession, supporting education for lawyers, teaching young people about the law and providing leadership for efforts to improve the provision of legal services to the poor,” she said in a statement.
“In addition to being an excellent jurist, Judge Johnson was an admired role model to many. He was among the founders of the association’s Minority Bar Committee. … Pennsylvania has lost a jurist who truly cared about his profession and his community. His decades of leadership should serve as a model to us all,” Ms. Wilkinson added.
Judge Johnson also served as an adjunct professor at Duquesne University Law School, where he became a close friend and adviser to university President Ken Gormley.
“He was an early pioneer in seeking to integrate and ensure equality in the public schools of this region, paving the way for many of the successes that were achieved due to his foresight and unflagging commitment,” Mr. Gormley said. “He was also a quiet, steady voice of logic and wisdom on the Superior Court of Pennsylvania; he was respected and admired, universally, by the entire bench and bar. For years, Judge Johnson taught with distinction at Duquesne Law School and contributed his talents in countless other ways.”
Though he was serious, even stern at times, Judge Johnson had a sense of humor, friends said.
“He was one of the most genteel, collegial people I knew, but he also had a great sense of humor. He was a little bit of prankster,” said Mr. Neft, who related a story about a trip the duo took in recent years to Harrisburg, when they served together on the board of a nonprofit legal services agency.
“We used to drive together to Harrisburg or Philadelphia or wherever the meetings were being held, and during one trip, he realized during the meeting that he’d left his medication at home,” Mr. Neft recalled. “He got a little light-headed, so we decided to go back home, and during the drive, we got a call from one of the other board members asking how he was feeling. I reassured her that he was fine, but in the background, he started yelling, ‘My heart! My heart, it’s going!’ I told her he was joking, but that’s the kind of sense of humor he had. He could really be hilarious.”
“He was a jokester,” agreed his pastor, the Rev. Randy Bush, of the East Liberty Presbyterian Church. “He had a mischievous side.”
Judge Johnson was particularly beloved in his community, Rev. Bush said, where he served on countless boards and was recognized with dozens awards.
“He was a person who would ask questions and pursue what is right and fair. He was very active in the church,” he said. “That speaks to his commitment to improving the ways we live together. He was willing to make sure doors were opened so that others could walk through them.”
Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto got to know him through Judge Johnson’s role at the church.
“Together, we worked on issues of equity, peace and gun violence with his wife, Florence. I already knew him as a brilliant legal scholar and then got to experience his passion, heart and commitment for the City of Pittsburgh and Commonwealth of Pennsylvania,” Mr. Peduto said in a statement. “After his time on the bench, we maintained our friendship, and I was honored when Judge Johnson swore me in as the 60th mayor of Pittsburgh.”
“He leaves a legacy of investing in and supporting our work in civil rights. And he would definitely speak up and tell you the truth, whether it was good, bad or ugly, because he wanted you to work with the truth,” said Esther L. Bush, president and CEO of the Urban League of Greater Pittsburgh, who met Judge Johnson when she was hired in 1994.
“The mission of the Urban League was quite personal to him,” continued Ms. Bush, who is retiring from the Urban League effective Nov. 10. “He helped me understand the political environment, and he also gave me the strength to be myself. He just had my back.”
His loss will be felt deeply, Ms. Bush said.
“This community has lost a giant during a time when we need so many more Justin Johnsons,” she said. “Judge Johnson was very special. He was a gift to this community.”
Along with his wife and his brother, Judge Johnson is survived by a sister, Justine Gutzmer, of Marietta, Ga.; two children, Elizabeth Johnson Barnes, of Point Breeze, and William, of the North Side; and four grandchildren.
He was preceded in death by his son Justin Llewellyn Johnson.
A public viewing is scheduled from 4-7 p.m. Tuesday, followed by a service Wednesday at 11 a.m., both at East Liberty Presbyterian Church, 116 S. Highland Ave., Pittsburgh 15206.
A private entombment is to follow Wednesday’s service.
Memorial contributions may be made to one of the following scholarships funds for financially disadvantaged students: The Oliver L. Johnson and William A. Lester Scholarship Fund, The Pittsburgh Foundation, 5 PPG Place, Suite 250, Pittsburgh, PA 15222; or the Justin Llewellyn Johnson Memorial Fund, Carnegie Mellon University, P.O. Box 371525, Pittsburgh, PA 15251-7525.
Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.