Judge Joseph Cosetti wore many hats in his lifetime -— an economist in the steel industry, a delegate to the Pennsylvania Constitutional Convention, a vital fixture in the administration of the late Pittsburgh Mayor Pete Flaherty, and, finally, a U.S. Bankruptcy Court judge.

His credentials as a big-picture kind of thinker and statesman who brooked no nonsense impressed even Pulitzer Prize-winning novelist James Michener, who pointed to Judge Cosetti as one of the most influential members of the convention, held in 1968. Mr. Michener, from Bucks County, was also a delegate to the convention.

“It was a revelation to me to see Joe operate,” the late Mr. Michener wrote in 1977 for the The Pittsburgh Forum.

“He has the analytical skill of a social scientist, the imagination of a writer, and the tenacity of a good politician. And he doesn’t give a damn for anybody. Particularly, self-serving anybodies.”

Advertise with us

His former boss agreed, singling out Judge Cosetti, who served as city treasurer during Mr. Flaherty’s tenure, from 1970 to 1977.

“Joseph Cosetti was the best treasurer Pittsburgh ever had,” Mr. Flaherty said in a 1977 article in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.

Judge Cosetti, of Squirrel Hill, died Wednesday of complications from prostate cancer and dementia. He had turned 92 just four days earlier.

He came from humble beginnings as the son of an Italian immigrant in Youngstown, Ohio.

“Joe was just a year older than I and when we were born, our father was learning to read and write and speak English,” recalled his sister, Elizabeth Cosetti-Fesler, of Akron, Ohio. “He believed very strongly in education.”

Advertise with us

Her big brother spent countless hours tutoring her in math and encouraging her to take on seemingly impossible challenges, Mrs. Cosetti-Fesler said.

“Here we were, in what was probably one of the poorest neighborhoods in Youngstown —- he convinced me to join the debate team with him and we were going door-to-door, asking people what they thought about the United Nations,” said his sister, an educator and psychologist. “He was my inspiration all my life. He didn’t need attention and he never bragged about having three degrees or making more money. He never made a fuss about any of that.”

Judge Cosetti earned a bachelor’s degree in chemistry in 1951 from Ohio State University, where he went on to obtain an MBA two years later.

Until he was appointed city treasurer in 1970, Judge Cosetti worked as an economist for U.S. Steel and Jones & Laughlin Steel.

He also served in the Army Reserve for many years, attaining the rank of colonel.

Advertise with us

In 1967, he was among 163 people tapped to serve as delegates to the constitutional convention. The following year, the Pittsburgh Press named him as one of the eight most vital members of the bipartisan group, along with the late Gov. Richard Thornburgh.

In 1968, Judge Cosetti ran unsuccessfully for Congress, but by 1970, he was appointed to lead the city treasury department under Mayor Flaherty. He was largely responsible for the austerity measures that became a hallmark of that administration.

“He was always very independent; he hated inefficiencies, he hated the political patronage system that he encountered when he joined the Flaherty administration,” said his wife, Marilyn Sullivan-Cosetti, who also worked in the administration.

The reforms he enacted were swift and deep.

Judge Cosetti reduced staff at city hall by more than 100 — including patronage jobs — and trimmed positions citywide by 2,000, said former Flaherty chief of staff Bruce Campbell.

Advertise with us

“Joe Cosetti made a tremendous contribution to the city of Pittsburgh,” Mr. Campbell said. “His background in business was very helpful and he was very, very effective. He was fearless in terms of doing what needed done.”

When Mayor Flaherty accepted a position as deputy U.S. attorney general in the Carter administration in 1977, Judge Cosetti tossed his hat into the ring for mayor — but with a twist.

The lifelong Democrat switched party affiliation only 13 minutes before the filing deadline, as part of an 11th-hour Hail Mary engineered by local GOP officials, who convinced Judge Cosetti that he would be the only viable candidate against Democrat Tom Foerster.

“He liked running for mayor,” said his wife. “His slogan was, ‘Consider Cosetti.’”

His transformation from Democrat to Republican was genuine, Mrs. Sullivan-Cosetti said of her husband, who referred to himself as a “Born-again Republican.”

Advertise with us

“He remained a lifelong Republican,” she recalled.

Judge Cosetti’s hopes flat-lined, though, with the stunning announcement by interim Mayor Richard Caliguiri that he would run as an independent in the race. Mr. Caliguiri went on to serve as mayor from 1977 until his death 10 years later.

While he was serving as city treasurer, Judge Cosetti attended law school at night at Duquesne University, graduating in 1975.

By 1980, he was appointed to the U.S. Bankruptcy Court, where he served a single, 14-year term, including nine years as chief judge, before retiring.

Judge Cosetti agreed to return, however, to act as a senior recall judge for another 10 years.

Advertise with us

During his time on the bench, Judge Cosetti was elected president of the National Conference of Bankruptcy Judges, said his friend and colleague, Judith Fitzgerald.

“It was a big deal — these were his peers,” said Ms. Fitzgerald, also a retired Bankruptcy Court chief judge.

Among his higher profile cases was the complicated and contentious bankruptcy of local appliance manufacturer Allegheny International in the late 1980s and early 1990s.

“He had an absolutely unflappable personality,” Ms. Fitzgerald said, laughing. “This man was so even-keeled that no matter what was going on he kept his perspective. And he loved good jokes. He had a chemistry background, so he used to say that was the reason he liked ‘to find solutions,’ to things.”

After retirement, Judge Cosetti helped organizations, such as the First Baptist Church of Pittsburgh, where he negotiated a long-term lease of a church parking lot. The deal enabled the development of Schenley Place in North Oakland, while providing a new revenue stream for the parish.

Advertise with us

“It was very good, important work,” said Mrs. Sullivan-Cosetti, who described her husband as a humble, respectful man. “Despite his many accomplishments, Joe was a modest man who was strong in his beliefs, courageous, and cool under pressure in all of our family adventures.”

Along with his wife and sister, Judge Cosetti is survived by his children, Dr. Maura Cosetti, of Manhattan, N.Y., and John Cosetti, of Pound Ridge, N.Y., and four grandchildren.

Visitation is from 3 to 7 p.m. Friday at Freyvogel Funeral Home, 4900 Centre Ave. in Oakland. The funeral is at 11 a.m. Saturday at the First Baptist Church of Pittsburgh, 159 Bellefield Ave., where Judge Cosetti served on the board of trustees and as business manager. Burial will be in Homewood Cemetery.

Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com.